Herm @ 1/12/2018 15:51

In short, no. I never ever considered checking out Nav. I thought he must be trolly town and that he would use his role endgame.

And what do you think of him now?

I think he's scum, seeing how he survived an attack.

Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:48

JJ @ 1/12/2018 14:46 Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:41 JJ @ 1/12/2018 14:37 Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:29 I believe Herm. He came out firm on lamps d5. Lamps is also an easy answer and he didn't really push very hard for Lamps instead of Helios. He put Lamps in a pool of people so it's possible.. He also lynched him, but then: Herm Day 4 Helios is probably frustrated that his team's kill failed, is how I read the situation right now. Why this post if he really wanted Lamps to be lynched? His first post of the day was a lamps lunch. He also said lamps was definite scum pretty early in the day. He did look at some others, but started and finished on lamps like he had info. Didn't see it at the time, but in retrospect, I do. His 9th post was a Lamps lynch. His 4th post mixed Lamps into a pool of 4: Kat, Lamps, Helios and Ahoda. I can agree to disagree. He's town on my list for now.

Herm @ 1/12/2018 15:25

I'm The Weak Cop. My night actions are N1: Primate N2: Lamps N3: Lamps N4: Kat N5: Spider

You're looking at Day 5, he said he had results on Night 3 that Lamps was scum. Just humor me and look at his Day 4 posts.

Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:46

I consider this game a personal loss because my one chance to kill was foiled. I want whomever is responsible for that to die.

I am upset about that for you too.

Killing Christian gives us time to figure out nav. Killing nav gives us instant info, but shortens the time to endgame.

JJ @ 1/12/2018 14:54

Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:48 JJ @ 1/12/2018 14:46 Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:41 JJ @ 1/12/2018 14:37 Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:29 I believe Herm. He came out firm on lamps d5. Lamps is also an easy answer and he didn't really push very hard for Lamps instead of Helios. He put Lamps in a pool of people so it's possible.. He also lynched him, but then: Herm Day 4 Helios is probably frustrated that his team's kill failed, is how I read the situation right now. Why this post if he really wanted Lamps to be lynched? His first post of the day was a lamps lunch. He also said lamps was definite scum pretty early in the day. He did look at some others, but started and finished on lamps like he had info. Didn't see it at the time, but in retrospect, I do. His 9th post was a Lamps lynch. His 4th post mixed Lamps into a pool of 4: Kat, Lamps, Helios and Ahoda. I can agree to disagree. He's town on my list for now. Herm @ 1/12/2018 15:25 I'm The Weak Cop. My night actions are N1: Primate N2: Lamps N3: Lamps N4: Kat N5: Spider You're looking at Day 5, he said he had results on Night 3 that Lamps was scum. Just humor me and look at his Day 4 posts.

Oic. I was off by a day. I'll go look

JJ, are you going to claim today?

I honestly wanted to keep my Cop claim hidden for as long as possible, I'll be a huge target tonight and I wanted to get more scans.

Christian @ 1/12/2018 15:50

Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:46 I consider this game a personal loss because my one chance to kill was foiled. I want whomever is responsible for that to die. JJ @ 1/12/2018 15:48 Christian @ 1/12/2018 15:45 hi. Just checking in. We've only seen one instance of the redirection. I know that I myself in 5 nights have not experienced being redirected. That's the only defense Nav has. Anyone worried about me being controlled at night...I see it, but not likely. JJ, are you and Nav scumbuds? No, but good try. You are claimed SK. He's a question mark (although probably mafia with Herm after Herm's claim), so you both need to go but you're a sure thing. That's fine. He survived a kill and I exposed myself to let you know that. So I'll take Nav down with me. But you're leaving the Mafia with numbers at this point. So I have to question your true alignment.

Mafia has one kill
You have one kill

What don't you get about wanting one less kill per night?

Herm @ 1/12/2018 15:54

I think he's scum, seeing how he survived an attack.

so then you believe me.

JJ @ 1/12/2018 15:55

Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:46 I consider this game a personal loss because my one chance to kill was foiled. I want whomever is responsible for that to die. I am upset about that for you too.

so give him his wish. Nav would be dead. Yet you won't lynch him today.

JJ @ 1/12/2018 16:00

Christian @ 1/12/2018 15:50 Primate @ 1/12/2018 15:46 I consider this game a personal loss because my one chance to kill was foiled. I want whomever is responsible for that to die. JJ @ 1/12/2018 15:48 Christian @ 1/12/2018 15:45 hi. Just checking in. We've only seen one instance of the redirection. I know that I myself in 5 nights have not experienced being redirected. That's the only defense Nav has. Anyone worried about me being controlled at night...I see it, but not likely. JJ, are you and Nav scumbuds? No, but good try. You are claimed SK. He's a question mark (although probably mafia with Herm after Herm's claim), so you both need to go but you're a sure thing. That's fine. He survived a kill and I exposed myself to let you know that. So I'll take Nav down with me. But you're leaving the Mafia with numbers at this point. So I have to question your true alignment. Mafia has one kill You have one kill What don't you get about wanting one less kill per night?

Because at best, I have one kill left. And that's it. You have an opportunity to remove one scum today, and weaken that faction and me tomorrow.

I see it now jj. I looked at the wrong day. Herm definitely doesn't look as town as I thought.
Him asking for one more day before he claimed would have made sense with his role had he looked at kat again last night.

okay bye again. Have fun. Play nice.

I believe you're both scum, yes.

Serial Killer = Christian
Some other Third Party role = Nav