spindoctor02 @ 10/4/2017 23:09

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 Spin who's scum other than me I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes. I've been too busy to dive in too deeply.

I'm not scum, Spin. And I think my actions speak to that.

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:09

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 Spin who's scum other than me I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes. I've been too busy to dive in too deeply.

So if the Vig killed Wikey N1 then scum Timmah was killed by scum?

thisisbad @ 11/4/2017 2:08

Herm @ 10/4/2017 19:06 My role is Town Escort. I can protect a player of my choice each night from roleblocks and redirections. Night 1, I picked Christian because he was one of the few people I got a town read on. Night 2, I picked Maddie in order to shield her from the redirections. Sock was lynched at this point so I didn't worry about a roleblocker. Night 3, I picked Cherry, same reasons as above. So why did you say non lethal scum actions?

Because roleblocks and redirections don't kill players, thus non lethal. At first I didn't want to reveal too much so I went with the non lethal angle since it was correct.

## lynch Spindoctor02

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:09 Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 Spin who's scum other than me I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes. I've been too busy to dive in too deeply. So if the Vig killed Wikey N1 then scum Timmah was killed by scum?

Attacked by scum.

For now

I miss Miko's music

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:09 Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 Spin who's scum other than me I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes. I've been too busy to dive in too deeply. So if the Vig killed Wikey N1 then scum Timmah was killed by scum?

If Herm is telling the truth, there is a redirector. While not likely, could mafia make use of their redirector to attack the GF to make him look pro-town? It'd be a dumb thing to do N1, but it's not like the mafia has been all that great so far.

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12

## lynch Spindoctor02

I hope you keep the vote there, so you lose it when I mod-prove I'm town later in the day phase with the ability I unlocked last night.

Christian @ 11/4/2017 0:07

It kind of seemed like he was trying to make a big deal of the mirror shields to make his role seem more important. There's only been one instance of redirection that we know of. And there's only been one instance of a mirror shield that we know of.

My memory on these is fuzzy. With the mirror, the latest theory we've pondered is what Jamie suggested today - Zersch mirrored Curtis' action back onto Curtis. Have we been told what that action was? (Not asking anyone to out themselves, just asking if it's already out there.) What is the redirect you're referencing?

spindoctor02 @ 10/4/2017 23:16

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12 ## lynch Spindoctor02 I hope you keep the vote there, so you lose it when I mod-prove I'm town later in the day phase with the ability I unlocked last night.

Are you going to use that ability today?

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:16

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12 ## lynch Spindoctor02 I hope you keep the vote there, so you lose it when I mod-prove I'm town later in the day phase with the ability I unlocked last night.

If you're town you've been doing a terrible job. Then again so have I so I can't say much

My thoughts from earlier while I was catching up haven't really changed much, though I'm torn on Herm ATM. Also read Primate more town-ish again today.

Christian seems to be actively trying to figure things out and scum hunt. I definitely lean town.

I don't really have a scum read on spin either though.

Oh yeah, I also agree with the thoughts that Curtis wouldn't go to bat for a scum teammate in herm like that. Now, if Herm is town then that could present an interesting scenario where scum Curtis is buddying up in the event of a Herm town flip? I've read Curtis mostly town-ish though so far.

CherryBerry @ 10/4/2017 23:16

Christian @ 11/4/2017 0:07 It kind of seemed like he was trying to make a big deal of the mirror shields to make his role seem more important. There's only been one instance of redirection that we know of. And there's only been one instance of a mirror shield that we know of. My memory on these is fuzzy. With the mirror, the latest theory we've pondered is what Jamie suggested today - Zersch mirrored Curtis' action back onto Curtis. Have we been told what that action was? (Not asking anyone to out themselves, just asking if it's already out there.) What is the redirect you're referencing?

That one instance of the mirror shield is the redirect I'm referring to and we don't even know that that is actually the case. Nobody knows what it does since apparently the thing didn't come with instructions.

spindoctor02 @ 10/4/2017 23:14

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:12 spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:09 Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 Spin who's scum other than me I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes. I've been too busy to dive in too deeply. So if the Vig killed Wikey N1 then scum Timmah was killed by scum? If Herm is telling the truth, there is a redirector. While not likely, could mafia make use of their redirector to attack the GF to make him look pro-town? It'd be a dumb thing to do N1, but it's not like the mafia has been all that great so far.

Why would they go through the trouble of redirecting when they can just attack the godfather directly?