Matt, you said you thought you were the baby.

Vern is SK, though. I'm lynching him. Please, is this even a question?

Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:19

Matt @ 25/8/2020 21:17 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:16 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:13 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 19:13 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:10 Ehhh Mal had an early vote on Zach. ## unlynch ## lynch Stargate Ouch, Vern. I'm sorry man but you gotta admit after your sixth beer yesterday you were making some really terrible arguments against Me or Matt as being mafia. I never said that at all. I thought you were Hollywood and that Hollywood was a vote controlled by the SK. I didn't think Matt was mafia. I said a hundred and three times, by my count, that he couldn't be. I wouldn't think him a baby possibility if not for his own words thinking he could've been the baby. Which gives me pause on that actually being a thing. I don't understand why he'd say anything at all if he actually was. Yeah exactly, I was throwing out the possibility that the baby might not even be a threat. With no kills last night and the game still going on, I'm on board with the notion that the baby IS a threat, and so I can firmly say it is not me. I guess there is a possibility you are the baby and you don't know it, and you win with the town? How does 3p work? The mom could kill. If the baby can't, can it win with town or does it need to be F2? If it can win with town, then Vern has to be the sk? But I kinda worry that if he was he would've made a kill last night, at the very least he would've attacked me to burn my bp?

Vern had already committed to not killing last night though. For all he knows, there could have been a seventh scum, and if there were two kills he would pretty much be outed as scummy for not following through with his promise not to kill. It doesn't necessarily clear or damn him either way unfortunately.

And to answer the question about "why Vern wouldn't kill if he's SK?"

So he can ask that question.

If the game doesn't end after a Vern lynch, I'll be annoyed and we can look for the baby. There's no reason to think the baby kills, though.

JJ @ 25/8/2020 22:21

Matt, you said you thought you were the baby. Vern is SK, though. I'm lynching him. Please, is this even a question?

I thought I was the baby because I really did not think there was any third party left. I felt like once we lynched the last mafia we would have been good. However, now that mafia is presumed dead and the game isn't over, I have to reprioritize my strategy and thought process and consider the real possibility that there is a third party baby out there hoping they survive long enough to win. I agree with Vern's point that Jamie pretty much functioned as the serial killer so I'm inclined to think pursuing the baby might actually be in our best interest.

I dunno, this shit is TOUGH

JJ @ 25/8/2020 19:21

Matt, you said you thought you were the baby. Vern is SK, though. I'm lynching him. Please, is this even a question?

If you are the Baby, good job, JJ.

I am Town. LOOK AT BOOB'S ROLE.... how are you just ignoring this fact!? There is a Baby that needs to be killed.

I'm logically the last person it would be since I singlehandedly killed Boobs and Wikey.

If there IS a baby I think we need to look at the people who were most supportive of the theory that I was the baby. That would be the perfect thing for them to hide behind if that were the case.

Matt @ 25/8/2020 19:22

Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:19 Matt @ 25/8/2020 21:17 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:16 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:13 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 19:13 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:10 Ehhh Mal had an early vote on Zach. ## unlynch ## lynch Stargate Ouch, Vern. I'm sorry man but you gotta admit after your sixth beer yesterday you were making some really terrible arguments against Me or Matt as being mafia. I never said that at all. I thought you were Hollywood and that Hollywood was a vote controlled by the SK. I didn't think Matt was mafia. I said a hundred and three times, by my count, that he couldn't be. I wouldn't think him a baby possibility if not for his own words thinking he could've been the baby. Which gives me pause on that actually being a thing. I don't understand why he'd say anything at all if he actually was. Yeah exactly, I was throwing out the possibility that the baby might not even be a threat. With no kills last night and the game still going on, I'm on board with the notion that the baby IS a threat, and so I can firmly say it is not me. I guess there is a possibility you are the baby and you don't know it, and you win with the town? How does 3p work? The mom could kill. If the baby can't, can it win with town or does it need to be F2? If it can win with town, then Vern has to be the sk? But I kinda worry that if he was he would've made a kill last night, at the very least he would've attacked me to burn my bp? Vern had already committed to not killing last night though. For all he knows, there could have been a seventh scum, and if there were two kills he would pretty much be outed as scummy for not following through with his promise not to kill. It doesn't necessarily clear or damn him either way unfortunately.

I assumed that HAD to be the last mafia. So there was no point in me attacking anyone until we all could enter the next day to discuss.

Also, Stargate and Mal are the two I most suspect.... and were also the only two I literally couldn't touch because of my shotgun range :glare:

JJ @ 25/8/2020 19:22

And to answer the question about "why Vern wouldn't kill if he's SK?" So he can ask that question.

JJ, please go read Boob's role flip and stop just saying I am the SK.

Mal, did you look at anyone's tags last night? Maybe Mal can be our mvp if the baby has a baby tag?

Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:26

Matt @ 25/8/2020 19:22 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:19 Matt @ 25/8/2020 21:17 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:16 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:13 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 19:13 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:10 Ehhh Mal had an early vote on Zach. ## unlynch ## lynch Stargate Ouch, Vern. I'm sorry man but you gotta admit after your sixth beer yesterday you were making some really terrible arguments against Me or Matt as being mafia. I never said that at all. I thought you were Hollywood and that Hollywood was a vote controlled by the SK. I didn't think Matt was mafia. I said a hundred and three times, by my count, that he couldn't be. I wouldn't think him a baby possibility if not for his own words thinking he could've been the baby. Which gives me pause on that actually being a thing. I don't understand why he'd say anything at all if he actually was. Yeah exactly, I was throwing out the possibility that the baby might not even be a threat. With no kills last night and the game still going on, I'm on board with the notion that the baby IS a threat, and so I can firmly say it is not me. I guess there is a possibility you are the baby and you don't know it, and you win with the town? How does 3p work? The mom could kill. If the baby can't, can it win with town or does it need to be F2? If it can win with town, then Vern has to be the sk? But I kinda worry that if he was he would've made a kill last night, at the very least he would've attacked me to burn my bp? Vern had already committed to not killing last night though. For all he knows, there could have been a seventh scum, and if there were two kills he would pretty much be outed as scummy for not following through with his promise not to kill. It doesn't necessarily clear or damn him either way unfortunately. I assumed that HAD to be the last mafia. So there was no point in me attacking anyone until we all could enter the next day to discuss. Also, Stargate and Mal are the two I most suspect.... and were also the only two I literally couldn't touch because of my shotgun range :glare:

Did Brian say you couldn't shoot me? Isn't im317 a tree stump and doesn't count anymore?

JJ @ 25/8/2020 19:23

If the game doesn't end after a Vern lynch, I'll be annoyed and we can look for the baby. There's no reason to think the baby kills, though.

Boobs was the killer of the Family. So we know the Baby is just some type of Survivor, because there have been no Family night-attacks since Boobs died.

I've been killing or trying to kill since Night 1, JJ.

There is SO MUCH evidence here supporting I literally cannot be the Baby.

Matt @ 25/8/2020 19:26

If there IS a baby I think we need to look at the people who were most supportive of the theory that I was the baby. That would be the perfect thing for them to hide behind if that were the case.

lol I feel like YOU have always been the biggest supporter of this theory

Stargate @ 25/8/2020 19:28

Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:26 Matt @ 25/8/2020 19:22 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:19 Matt @ 25/8/2020 21:17 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 22:16 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:13 Stargate @ 25/8/2020 19:13 Not that many ppl liked ur post its just me Vern @ 25/8/2020 21:10 Ehhh Mal had an early vote on Zach. ## unlynch ## lynch Stargate Ouch, Vern. I'm sorry man but you gotta admit after your sixth beer yesterday you were making some really terrible arguments against Me or Matt as being mafia. I never said that at all. I thought you were Hollywood and that Hollywood was a vote controlled by the SK. I didn't think Matt was mafia. I said a hundred and three times, by my count, that he couldn't be. I wouldn't think him a baby possibility if not for his own words thinking he could've been the baby. Which gives me pause on that actually being a thing. I don't understand why he'd say anything at all if he actually was. Yeah exactly, I was throwing out the possibility that the baby might not even be a threat. With no kills last night and the game still going on, I'm on board with the notion that the baby IS a threat, and so I can firmly say it is not me. I guess there is a possibility you are the baby and you don't know it, and you win with the town? How does 3p work? The mom could kill. If the baby can't, can it win with town or does it need to be F2? If it can win with town, then Vern has to be the sk? But I kinda worry that if he was he would've made a kill last night, at the very least he would've attacked me to burn my bp? Vern had already committed to not killing last night though. For all he knows, there could have been a seventh scum, and if there were two kills he would pretty much be outed as scummy for not following through with his promise not to kill. It doesn't necessarily clear or damn him either way unfortunately. I assumed that HAD to be the last mafia. So there was no point in me attacking anyone until we all could enter the next day to discuss. Also, Stargate and Mal are the two I most suspect.... and were also the only two I literally couldn't touch because of my shotgun range :glare: Did Brian say you couldn't shoot me? Isn't im317 a tree stump and doesn't count anymore?

I didn't perform an attack last night so there was no information given at all.

I just sent in ## no kill

Oh I think I see your question though -- im317 still counts as a player on the player list. So I couldn't attack you even if I wanted to, Stargate