Bye Mittens we will lynch you while you are gone

Timmah @ 26/10/2018 19:48

My list looks a lot like im317’s. But, I’d lynch havo, jackie, Henry, nav, mittens, merc, TIB or Zach today. Don’t think I’m willing to lynch anyone else right now barring new info.

Why Henry?

Mercator @ 26/10/2018 22:36

Timmah @ 26/10/2018 19:48 My list looks a lot like im317’s. But, I’d lynch havo, jackie, Henry, nav, mittens, merc, TIB or Zach today. Don’t think I’m willing to lynch anyone else right now barring new info. Why Henry?

Why Tib

I'd prob start with Mittens or Havo today

Or Shawn just cause he loves when i mention him

Yes I got Boc killed

And the 3rd party theory for me is... Silly. Why would 3rd party killer drrrr counterclaim third party killer Helios's town vig claim?

It's a lazy theory and it's giving me a scum lean on Vic for rolling with it (when in combination with his Weird Feelings about every town train)

THE ROSE @ 27/10/2018 1:30

Yes I got Boc killed And the 3rd party theory for me is... Silly. Why would 3rd party killer drrrr counterclaim third party killer Helios's town vig claim? It's a lazy theory and it's giving me a scum lean on Vic for rolling with it (when in combination with his Weird Feelings about every town train)

Me saying I could see it doesn't mean I'm rolling with it, just thinking everything out. But thinking about it now you have a point with the counterclaim argument

I used to be a werewolf but I’m alright nooooooooooooow

Can we kill Henry now

Kat were you cursed to only post gifs now lol

THE ROSE @ 27/10/2018 0:30

And the 3rd party theory for me is... Silly. Why would 3rd party killer drrrr counterclaim third party killer Helios's town vig claim? It's a lazy theory and it's giving me a scum lean on Vic for rolling with it (when in combination with his Weird Feelings about every town train)

It isn't lazy at all. I want to believe you are town, but if that is the case than we need to account for why we started with a 2:1 advantage in killing roles over the mafia.

Imagine Roland had lived a bit longer. In combination with you killing every night, he would be priming someone else to die the following day. Effectively giving us two kills every cycle to the Mafia's one. Nevermind the fact we also have several x shot killing roles.

So, what possible explanations could there be for giving the town so much firepower? You can dismiss the player count, because even in a game this size that would be way too OP. Here are some possibilities:

- Mafia are very strong. They perhaps have higher numbers than a usual game, so town needed two killing roles for them to have a fair chance.

- There's a powerful third party role out there that justifies giving town extra firepower.

- This game is unbalanced as shit

I don't think the last one is an actual possibility. So...either mafia is really strong, in which case we are probably very close to losing anyway, or there's another third party that hasn't revealed itself yet. Possibilities there include an arsonist or a cult.

I find it strange that you don't seem to recognize the balance issue here Rose. Even if you are town, you must admit that somethings up with this, and your attempt to dismiss the theory as silly and lazy only makes me suspect you more.

Regarding your counterclaim; for third parties to survive long term, usually they need to make a bold move at some point in the game, and I think you made yours against Helios. Well played if that is the case btw.

So, if you are town, help me out and come up with explanations for why we have so much firepower. Any you know...maybe shoot scum at night, instead of doing exactly what third party scum would be doing right now, which is shooting people like Boc.

Shadow @ 27/10/2018 21:11

Kat were you cursed to only post gifs now lol

Buffy, could you enlighten me as to why I think you are confirmed town. Did you claim something?

Mercator @ 26/10/2018 22:36

Timmah @ 26/10/2018 19:48 My list looks a lot like im317’s. But, I’d lynch havo, jackie, Henry, nav, mittens, merc, TIB or Zach today. Don’t think I’m willing to lynch anyone else right now barring new info. Why Henry?

Same reasons from yesterday. Mostly those are just the people I don’t have good town reads on.