The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:44

Mittens @ 27/10/2017 7:42 The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:41 Mittens @ 27/10/2017 7:40 The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:39 WIFOM incoming but do you think that I would admit to being roleblocked if I was the one Mafia sent out for a kill last night? It probably looks better than part way through the day the roleblocker coming in and bringing the info to light.. So you want the town roleblocker (because you're assuming that I am Mafia) to come in and out themselves in the middle of the day. Hmmmm. I never said that. It's actually literally what you said.

I said from your perspective it's better to come clean at the beginning of the day as opposed to waiting for the roleblocker to come in later on.

You've already said that you were blocked so there's no reason the roleblocker would come forward.

Mittens @ 27/10/2017 7:55

The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:44 Mittens @ 27/10/2017 7:42 The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:41 Mittens @ 27/10/2017 7:40 The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 9:39 WIFOM incoming but do you think that I would admit to being roleblocked if I was the one Mafia sent out for a kill last night? It probably looks better than part way through the day the roleblocker coming in and bringing the info to light.. So you want the town roleblocker (because you're assuming that I am Mafia) to come in and out themselves in the middle of the day. Hmmmm. I never said that. It's actually literally what you said. I said from your perspective it's better to come clean at the beginning of the day as opposed to waiting for the roleblocker to come in later on. You've already said that you were blocked so there's no reason the roleblocker would come forward.

The roleblocker has no reason to come forward BECAUSE I said I was blocked.

If I waited, it would have put pressure on the role blocker to come forward. Which is better for me if I'm Mafia. But since I'm town, and I don't know who blocked me, I can't forward with it immediately

Btw whoever blocked me ended up inadvertently doing me a favor. Thanks for that.

imo withholding that info looks bad on you, especially if it comes out later in the game whether that be today's discussion or a future day's thread. If you're town and withhold, looks bad. If you're scum and withhold, looks worse.

Truly your intellect is dizzying ...

This is kind of a small, basic game ... I'm not sure there is a Vig. Isn't that more in-line with and "old-school" mafia game?

Is suffering a necessary part of the human condition? What would people who never suffered be like?

Day 2 Vote Count

Navneet (1/8) -- Mittens

Not Voted: TIB, Dadd, Zach, Jamie, Herm, Josh, Navneet, DS, Merc, Ben, Curtis, Sock, Ahoda

----------
Deadline is 9 am CT on Saturday.

Dadd @ 27/10/2017 8:08

Truly your intellect is dizzying ...

Ouch. :(

Pumpkin King @ 27/10/2017 8:02

imo withholding that info looks bad on you, especially if it comes out later in the game whether that be today's discussion or a future day's thread. If you're town and withhold, looks bad. If you're scum and withhold, looks worse.

The point I'm trying to make is, as Mafia, withholding the info is more profitable for me because it might potentially lead to the town RB coming forward.

I see where you're coming from Nav. But also with a game this small Idk if mafia would take that risk

The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 10:13

Pumpkin King @ 27/10/2017 8:02 imo withholding that info looks bad on you, especially if it comes out later in the game whether that be today's discussion or a future day's thread. If you're town and withhold, looks bad. If you're scum and withhold, looks worse. The point I'm trying to make is, as Mafia, withholding the info is more profitable for me because it might potentially lead to the town RB coming forward.

Risky to hold information and being caught with your dick in your hand

Mittens @ 27/10/2017 8:17

The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 10:13 Pumpkin King @ 27/10/2017 8:02 imo withholding that info looks bad on you, especially if it comes out later in the game whether that be today's discussion or a future day's thread. If you're town and withhold, looks bad. If you're scum and withhold, looks worse. The point I'm trying to make is, as Mafia, withholding the info is more profitable for me because it might potentially lead to the town RB coming forward. Risky to hold information and being caught with your dick in your hand

It's like you're completely ignoring what I'm posting

The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 10:18

Mittens @ 27/10/2017 8:17 The Sebbyman @ 27/10/2017 10:13 Pumpkin King @ 27/10/2017 8:02 imo withholding that info looks bad on you, especially if it comes out later in the game whether that be today's discussion or a future day's thread. If you're town and withhold, looks bad. If you're scum and withhold, looks worse. The point I'm trying to make is, as Mafia, withholding the info is more profitable for me because it might potentially lead to the town RB coming forward. Risky to hold information and being caught with your dick in your hand It's like you're completely ignoring what I'm posting

I'm just disagreeing with your argument

Either way, we should revisit the "was Nav scum RBed" convo once we see evidence that there are two killers even in the game