Zach is very quiet about all this lol

Oh wait, there are posts.

Sorry.

I didn't see you over there.

Zach, clear this up for us. Why would someone make up lies about you?

Mercator @ 22/5/2017 19:59

Primate @ 22/5/2017 18:54 Stephen @ 22/5/2017 19:46 Primate @ 22/5/2017 21:44 2 town roles that publicly out scum seems like it might be a little op to me. What other role in your opinion publicly outs scum? Ds' role publicly outed visitors. Having the role that intercepts messages would be too much, imo. I think an uninformed messenger type role is about as likely. The role merc describes would probably announce results each night, so unless it's a rotorole like joat, it's possible. That was a one-use role though. I think this role was in the last game?

Yes, but not a peep until night 3means it's probably not the same role. It would have to be a pretty modified version, limited use, or one of many roles unless you are thinking this person was blocked the first 2 nights.

If it's part of a joat role I could buy it.

Hern @ 22/5/2017 20:00

Rotorole sounds like motor oil.

I just made it up. Please don't let people start using it as a verb.

I don't see a combination of DS' role and this anonymous leaker role as overpowered as it is possible that the anonymous role outs people who are actually mafia whereas DS' role can cause the town to misinterpret, such as what happened D2

By no means am I insinuating that Zachary is for sure Mafia, I'm just aeguing that from my point of view I could see both roles be town sided

Stephen @ 22/5/2017 20:09

I don't see a combination of DS' role and this anonymous leaker role as overpowered as it is possible that the anonymous role outs people who are actually mafia whereas DS' role can cause the town to misinterpret, such as what happened D2

My main point being. Did people learn nothing from the mittens lynch?

Primate @ 22/5/2017 19:04

Mercator @ 22/5/2017 19:59 Primate @ 22/5/2017 18:54 Stephen @ 22/5/2017 19:46 Primate @ 22/5/2017 21:44 2 town roles that publicly out scum seems like it might be a little op to me. What other role in your opinion publicly outs scum? Ds' role publicly outed visitors. Having the role that intercepts messages would be too much, imo. I think an uninformed messenger type role is about as likely. The role merc describes would probably announce results each night, so unless it's a rotorole like joat, it's possible. That was a one-use role though. I think this role was in the last game? Yes, but not a peep until night 3means it's probably not the same role. It would have to be a pretty modified version, limited use, or one of many roles unless you are thinking this person was blocked the first 2 nights.

From D2:
"Urgent Breaking News Alert! Just kidding, none of you bitches did anything noteworthy. Maybe tomorrow someone can do something entertaining."

Implies it has a scanning role tied to the reporting.

I'm guessing N2 he missed the window to post.

Or was blocked.

I can't believe Herm hasn't asked Zach the super important question yet. Herm, you scum?

Stephen @ 22/5/2017 20:10

By no means am I insinuating that Zachary is for sure Mafia, I'm just aeguing that from my point of view I could see both roles be town sided

It could happen, especially if it's limited use like a joat. I just distrust outed info like this. I've seen it be worthless or scum more often than not. I could see it as a scum role who did the killing instead of using the role until last night.

Interesting about the Zachary thing.

And LOL @ Farlig getting randomized results, yet still hitting Mafia.

Hey guys! Able to talk again (f u silencer)... Catching up on yesterday's day thread now.