##lynch Maddie

Merc, did you kill Ahoda?

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:34

thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) I'm not saying that, but just to say - okay he may be town but he's inactive so let's lynch him anyway (Badger comes to mind) is not a good idea imo. But, even just saying you are town, TIB, do you not agree that mafia had a big stake in wanting Nofo gone and would've probably either been on his train or at least not helped to lynch Vlady over him? Even if Vlady is town, they don't see him as a threat but they would see Nofo as a threat. I still say I understand why some town would vote Nofo as third party, possible mafia, but I think looking at the trains, I'm most interested in the Nofo train right now. Or non-voters. Or people voting Vlady late when they knew it didn't matter.

I see your point there, but i still think it holds that nofo was the lynch. I hate to bring up other games, but i think this forum has been consistent in lynching third party.
(Hold on, Timmah is calling me....he's whining about being lynched and then his lynch target getting lynched the next day. No idea what he means)

I would agree with your point if someone had come out and said "Hey Vlady scanned mafia, let's lynch him". But he was an unknown. Nofo was caught. I have to take that lynch.

spindoctor02 @ 5/3/2017 21:31

So, I was blocked last night. Anyone want to claim it?

I doubt it since only mafia roleblocker probably still alive.

Starting to think ahoda mentioning Herm yesterday wasn't a "slip up"

Herm, thoughts?

##give Jamie $50
##give Buffy $50

thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:38

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:34 thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) I'm not saying that, but just to say - okay he may be town but he's inactive so let's lynch him anyway (Badger comes to mind) is not a good idea imo. But, even just saying you are town, TIB, do you not agree that mafia had a big stake in wanting Nofo gone and would've probably either been on his train or at least not helped to lynch Vlady over him? Even if Vlady is town, they don't see him as a threat but they would see Nofo as a threat. I still say I understand why some town would vote Nofo as third party, possible mafia, but I think looking at the trains, I'm most interested in the Nofo train right now. Or non-voters. Or people voting Vlady late when they knew it didn't matter. I see your point there, but i still think it holds that nofo was the lynch. I hate to bring up other games, but i think this forum has been consistent in lynching third party. (Hold on, Timmah is calling me....he's whining about being lynched and then his lynch target getting lynched the next day. No idea what he means) I would agree with your point if someone had come out and said "Hey Vlady scanned mafia, let's lynch him". But he was an unknown. Nofo was caught. I have to take that lynch.

IF Dylan was cop (he kind of hinted at it), he would've probably scanned GF as town. If anyone has any other ideas as to what Dylan was claiming please post them. But,it seemed coppish to me.

This might not answer your point lol

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:39

spindoctor02 @ 5/3/2017 21:31 So, I was blocked last night. Anyone want to claim it? I doubt it since only mafia roleblocker probably still alive.

Shhhhhh.

Do we know what Dylan was? Wonder why they hid his role from us

Really surprised vlady made it through the night. gg on Ahoda tho merc

Angi @ 5/3/2017 21:42

##give Jamie $50 ##give Buffy $50

Thanks but don't give me more $ anyone. I don't have a way to use it right now.

Quote

My role and alignment both rhyme with gown.

Vlad can we get some more info on your "role name" that rhymes with gown?

Angi @ 5/3/2017 21:43

Do we know what Dylan was? Wonder why they hid his role from us

Why do you think he hid it?

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:43

thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:38 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:34 thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) thisisbad @ 5/3/2017 21:28 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 20:25 BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/3/2017 21:22 So we've got 19 people left, and we've only hit one (maybe two) mafia. That puts us in a pretty bad position, IMO. Right, which is why we probably shouldn't have voted for a person who hinted at a possible town role D1 - yeah he was inactive but he was a number. If the game was lost on day 1, then the game was broken. I'd say it's more about who we have lynched. And at 3 kills a night, to only hit one mafia is almost unheard of (barring Dylan's flip) I'm not saying that, but just to say - okay he may be town but he's inactive so let's lynch him anyway (Badger comes to mind) is not a good idea imo. But, even just saying you are town, TIB, do you not agree that mafia had a big stake in wanting Nofo gone and would've probably either been on his train or at least not helped to lynch Vlady over him? Even if Vlady is town, they don't see him as a threat but they would see Nofo as a threat. I still say I understand why some town would vote Nofo as third party, possible mafia, but I think looking at the trains, I'm most interested in the Nofo train right now. Or non-voters. Or people voting Vlady late when they knew it didn't matter. I see your point there, but i still think it holds that nofo was the lynch. I hate to bring up other games, but i think this forum has been consistent in lynching third party. (Hold on, Timmah is calling me....he's whining about being lynched and then his lynch target getting lynched the next day. No idea what he means) I would agree with your point if someone had come out and said "Hey Vlady scanned mafia, let's lynch him". But he was an unknown. Nofo was caught. I have to take that lynch. IF Dylan was cop (he kind of hinted at it), he would've probably scanned GF as town. If anyone has any other ideas as to what Dylan was claiming please post them. But,it seemed coppish to me. This might not answer your point lol

No but brings up another interesting point. Dylan def hinted as cop. IM seemed to be very powerful. The odds that no one decided to protect either one of them makes me really wonder about this game.

Angi @ 5/3/2017 20:43

Do we know what Dylan was? Wonder why they hid his role from us

Yes, he was ??????????????