They should've just made this a fans vs favs season. They could've made such a good fvf bunch here

Tony
JT
Varner
Caleb
Tai

Sandra
Cirie
Debbie
Michaela
Aubry or Hali


Those 10 on a tribe together vs. 10 non-caramoan type newbies would've been amazing

Nicole is a very big Troyzan fan. So she is excited. I would love to see him go first

And we've seen those under the radar picks work out. Even though I wasn't a huge fan Wentworth was great TV. Parvati was another random returnee pick and she is probably a top 5 all time player.

So maybe Sierra will wow us. There is just a list of probably 150 survivor girls I'd rather see play again

im a big fan of sierra because she sounds like that girl who says ghost funny that i fucking hate

Curtis @ 15/12/2016 14:53

They should've just made this a fans vs favs season. They could've made such a good fvf bunch here Tony JT Varner Caleb Tai Sandra Cirie Debbie Michaela Aubry or Hali Those 10 on a tribe together vs. 10 non-caramoan type newbies would've been amazing

u r forgetting fan favourite sierra dawn thomas!!!!!

Matt @ 15/12/2016 10:25

Jeff said in the EW interview that they wanted a spectrum of people who they thought were game changers. We have no insight to the interview process and it wouldn't surprise me at all if Sierra's main argument for coming back was that she regrets not using her power in the game to change the outcome of the season and she wants to remedy that. WA was a fairly predictable Pagonging season and Sierra was really the only hope for that to change so she got a lot of flack for it. Casting had to have felt good enough about Sierra wanting to play hard to let her on.

cmon now I think you know that's complete bullshit. they decide the name / theme after they pick the cast not before it. that happened with Kaoh Rong / Cagayan / Worlds Apart too.

Maddie S. @ 15/12/2016 11:16

Also Curtis I see where your annoyance for no S33 cast photos comes from now. Did they use a mirror selfie of Michaela? Wtf...

they have the photos somewhere they just never released them fully. Ive seen them super tiny in promo stuff. what they did was so ugly

They have some shitty photos that they never released because they didn't come out right. I've only seen them on that one image

curt, im happy for you that s12 of SI is a returnee season, or else you would have had to have dealt with all those cast photos..

Sucks to be an org host now.

Shadow @ 15/12/2016 17:12

Matt @ 15/12/2016 10:25 Jeff said in the EW interview that they wanted a spectrum of people who they thought were game changers. We have no insight to the interview process and it wouldn't surprise me at all if Sierra's main argument for coming back was that she regrets not using her power in the game to change the outcome of the season and she wants to remedy that. WA was a fairly predictable Pagonging season and Sierra was really the only hope for that to change so she got a lot of flack for it. Casting had to have felt good enough about Sierra wanting to play hard to let her on. cmon now I think you know that's complete bullshit. they decide the name / theme after they pick the cast not before it. that happened with Kaoh Rong / Cagayan / Worlds Apart too.

Mhm they just happened to only pick one timers for second chance.

Cool Girl @ 15/12/2016 19:34

Shadow @ 15/12/2016 17:12 Matt @ 15/12/2016 10:25 Jeff said in the EW interview that they wanted a spectrum of people who they thought were game changers. We have no insight to the interview process and it wouldn't surprise me at all if Sierra's main argument for coming back was that she regrets not using her power in the game to change the outcome of the season and she wants to remedy that. WA was a fairly predictable Pagonging season and Sierra was really the only hope for that to change so she got a lot of flack for it. Casting had to have felt good enough about Sierra wanting to play hard to let her on. cmon now I think you know that's complete bullshit. they decide the name / theme after they pick the cast not before it. that happened with Kaoh Rong / Cagayan / Worlds Apart too. Mhm they just happened to only pick one timers for second chance.

what

Curtis @ 15/12/2016 20:37

Cool Girl @ 15/12/2016 19:34 Shadow @ 15/12/2016 17:12 Matt @ 15/12/2016 10:25 Jeff said in the EW interview that they wanted a spectrum of people who they thought were game changers. We have no insight to the interview process and it wouldn't surprise me at all if Sierra's main argument for coming back was that she regrets not using her power in the game to change the outcome of the season and she wants to remedy that. WA was a fairly predictable Pagonging season and Sierra was really the only hope for that to change so she got a lot of flack for it. Casting had to have felt good enough about Sierra wanting to play hard to let her on. cmon now I think you know that's complete bullshit. they decide the name / theme after they pick the cast not before it. that happened with Kaoh Rong / Cagayan / Worlds Apart too. Mhm they just happened to only pick one timers for second chance. what

I was giving an example to the contrary. Keep up.

Sierra was a last minute replacement though. They obviously had the theme picked out before that bc they need to put the logo on the buffs and stuff.

I listed every season they didn't pre plan a twist
I didn't mention Cambodia and obviously that was different since we voted

I don't remember Sierra or Hali at all.

This is the cheesiest cast ever. I really hate the concept of 3rd/4th time returnees and I hate some of the random castaways. It's just a mix of Jeff's favorites. Mehhh. Not saying it's gonna be a bad season, but damn this cast!