Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2 3 4
Round 3
 
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #31: 18th Feb 2016 6:30 PM 
Herm @ 18/2/2016 23:19
Did Dylan mean started?


Dylan don't have shit.
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #32: 18th Feb 2016 6:41 PM 
Chris - Essex County Fair+


I actually, really, really like it!! Nice narrative and I like the time-jumping, but I did see something that didn't fit the time-period. The Essex County Fair didn't officially open until 1848, but I saw you mention that your character was in Salem during 1692. Even if the character had traveled from Salem to Essex County, the time-period still wouldn't have fit considering your story ended with the opening of the Essex County Fair, but the real historical opening wouldn't be for another 156 years.

So unless I missed out on something, feel free to elaborate so I can notice it and maybe give you some points back. I still really like the story though! I think you did a good job!

~Creativity (9/10)
~Grammar (8/10)
~Historical Accuracy (9/10)
~Consistency (7/10)
~Presentation (6/10)

Post Edited by Miko @ 23rd Feb 2016 6:05 PM
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #33: 18th Feb 2016 6:50 PM 
Escape from Chimneyville - American Civil War+


I like the fact that you put in historical figures, and I like the narrative as well. I see you weren't aiming for an epic ending, but more letting the readers have the realization of despair from back then sink in. And that it was an unpleasent world to live in, and that you could truly never feel safe in the heart of war. So I really do like that approach and feel like you did an amazing job!

~Creativity (8/10)
~Grammar (8/10)
~Historical Accuracy (9/10)
~Consistency (8/10)
~Presentation (7/10)
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #34: 18th Feb 2016 6:51 PM 
Herm - Mesopotamia+


You have yet again made an amazing story Herm! The time-period was done amazingly and the motives of the characters' decisions really fit within that time period and culture. I liked the political aspect as well, I'm a complete sucker for king and queen tales, so I loved this even more!

~Creativity (9/10)
~Grammar (10/10)
~Historical Accuracy (10/10)
~Consistency (9/10)
~Presentation (8/10)

Post Edited by Miko @ 18th Feb 2016 10:56 PM
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Chris25
User Avatar
Head of Human Resources
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -167
Group:Elite
Posts:3,544
Joined:Dec 29, 2013
Post #35: 18th Feb 2016 6:58 PM 
The narrator was just being cynical. He actually moved through time and knew what a fair was but the fact that the people in the town had all gathered for his/her hanging was just like an ironic way of putting that his/her execution was akin to a county fair.
 
   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #36: 18th Feb 2016 7:00 PM 
Ahh okay, I get it! I'll discuss it with Bryce later tonight, thanks for the insight Chris! :)
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Herm
User Avatar
Definitely not a Quran Burner
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Godfather
Posts:29,713
Joined:Feb 20, 2014
Post #37: 18th Feb 2016 10:54 PM 
Miko, you didn't post the whole story lol
 
   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #38: 18th Feb 2016 10:57 PM 
Fuck the king...

I mean, fuck my computer!! I could have sworn I added that in there.
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #39: 18th Feb 2016 11:10 PM 
Herm @ 16/2/2016 13:59
Mine is gonna be much shorter this time as well! :)


Lies! ;)
 
   
JJ
User Avatar
Pig
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 164
Group:Godfather
Posts:33,771
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #40: 18th Feb 2016 11:45 PM 
Miko @ 18/2/2016 19:00
Ahh okay, I get it! I'll discuss it with Bryce later tonight, thanks for the insight Chris! :)


You won't discuss with me?
 
   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #41: 19th Feb 2016 12:11 AM 
JJ @ 19/2/2016 4:45
Miko @ 18/2/2016 19:00
Ahh okay, I get it! I'll discuss it with Bryce later tonight, thanks for the insight Chris! :)


You won't discuss with me?


Aww sorry JJ. :(. I was in a freaking hurry as I needed to go somewhere, and for some reason the surface of my mind only registers Bryce as a judge until I think later on, 'oh yeah, Buffy is one too'. I'm so sorry, I know I suck majorly for forgetting such a kindness, but I still love ya though! <3 <3
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #42: 19th Feb 2016 12:12 AM 
And ofcourse I will discuss it with you
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
JJ
User Avatar
Pig
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 164
Group:Godfather
Posts:33,771
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #43: 19th Feb 2016 12:28 AM 
What is the deadline? I have yet to read anything but I trust you have all researched your historical data and I will not need to check up on you!
 
   
Miko
User Avatar
Bomb
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -42
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,952
Joined:May 12, 2014
Post #44: 19th Feb 2016 1:00 AM 
Ah, perferably tonight still. But it can hold up for tomorrow. I still need to do calucations from last round and maybe even reveal the next rounds genre already.
'Oh my god, it's full of stars!'

Posted Image

   
Herm
User Avatar
Definitely not a Quran Burner
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Godfather
Posts:29,713
Joined:Feb 20, 2014
Post #45: 19th Feb 2016 6:38 AM 
JJ @ 19/2/2016 6:28
What is the deadline? I have yet to read anything but I trust you have all researched your historical data and I will not need to check up on you!


Timmah @ 19/2/2016 5:10
Herm @ 16/2/2016 13:59
Mine is gonna be much shorter this time as well! :)


Lies! ;)

I aimed for short, but for some reason it got a bit longer than expected. Think it's my shortest story yet though so progress lol!
 
   
1 Users Viewing (1 Guests)
  33. Fictional Tournament  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service