I'm not going to announce who I'm hiding behind before I do it. Scum can just kill that person and then have two townies die.

Vic @ 27/1/2016 11:42

N1 - Buffy N2 - Rob N3 - Merc N4 - ahoda N5 - JC N6 - Angi N7 - JC N8 - Angi N9 - JC

Why'd you say on D6 that JC could be Mafia godfather if you had just cleared him? Huh?? HUH?!?

Because I was very against giving any indication that I had a role that allowed me to potentially clear people. I didn't even wanna do it the day we all claimed

There's not that many people left to choose from tho. If mafia kills the person you're hiding behind we lose two townies tonight. But if you think I am mafia with Curtis I understand your reluctance.

Vic @ 23/1/2016 20:39

Alright I take it back. Pretty confident Curtis isn't Mafia HOWEVER, if we're under the assumption the Cult Leader has a choice to recruit or not, Curtis, even though you didn't visit anyone last night, you could indeed be him I think we're pretty much able to narrow down our Mafia search at this point. We have a lot of confirmed roles left compared to the number of people still in the game. Four Mafia dead, I would think one or two tops would be left and based on outed roles I would think the remaining Mafia has to be in this group Herm (claimed but it's still questionable) im317 Ari Curtis Angi?? JC? Vic I put JC there because IF Timmah was Cult when he scanned JC, he could've most definitely gotten a guilty read on him and lied about it. Cult should still want Mafia alive in my opinion so I can definitely see it as a possibility. I put Angi there because with the weird shit happening in this game I can still see something being funky with her claim but she's probably the one I'm least suspect of on the list BASED ON TRACK RECORD: I would like to think that myself, Curtis and MAYBE Herm and Ari should be cleared of being Mafia. We've all had good insight and lynch patterns (for the most part) so I would cross myself and Curtis off and keep the other two as a maybe Meaning my final Mafia list comes from this group Herm? im317 Ari? JC? Angi???

But why theorize about JC and Angi both being mafia here when you had just cleared them both as Town? Like...why could up with this THEORY about JC? That's what's weird to me. I get not wanting to tip Mafia off even though there's no way they'd ever suspect it, but to actively theorize against the people is weird

Herm @ 27/1/2016 11:50

There's not that many people left to choose from tho. If mafia kills the person you're hiding behind we lose two townies tonight. But if you think I am mafia with Curtis I understand your reluctance.

If (when) I'm lynched today, Vic (if town) will know for a fact that you're Mafia when I flip town either way so it doesn't matter much

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 11:52

Vic @ 23/1/2016 20:39 Alright I take it back. Pretty confident Curtis isn't Mafia HOWEVER, if we're under the assumption the Cult Leader has a choice to recruit or not, Curtis, even though you didn't visit anyone last night, you could indeed be him I think we're pretty much able to narrow down our Mafia search at this point. We have a lot of confirmed roles left compared to the number of people still in the game. Four Mafia dead, I would think one or two tops would be left and based on outed roles I would think the remaining Mafia has to be in this group Herm (claimed but it's still questionable) im317 Ari Curtis Angi?? JC? Vic I put JC there because IF Timmah was Cult when he scanned JC, he could've most definitely gotten a guilty read on him and lied about it. Cult should still want Mafia alive in my opinion so I can definitely see it as a possibility. I put Angi there because with the weird shit happening in this game I can still see something being funky with her claim but she's probably the one I'm least suspect of on the list BASED ON TRACK RECORD: I would like to think that myself, Curtis and MAYBE Herm and Ari should be cleared of being Mafia. We've all had good insight and lynch patterns (for the most part) so I would cross myself and Curtis off and keep the other two as a maybe Meaning my final Mafia list comes from this group Herm? im317 Ari? JC? Angi??? But why theorize about JC and Angi both being mafia here when you had just cleared them both as Town? Like...why could up with this THEORY about JC? That's what's weird to me. I get not wanting to tip Mafia off even though there's no way they'd ever suspect it, but to actively theorize against the people is weird

Because there were times in the beginning of the game where I suspected JC and Angi and they hadn't really done anything gamewise for me to suddenly go "YOU KNOW WHAT, they are definitely town." I always planned on waiting until I revealed my role to confirm them as town, but if they were ever in danger of being lynched then I would've done it then. At the point this post was made, there was never any chance of them getting lynched

I thought Mafia would know for sure that I had a useful role "even though its not useful at all unless I pick town people" and didn't want them taking me out for it.

This day could be do or die for us, depending on who is scum.

And to be fair I was not at all "actively theorizing" against JC and Angi at that point. I made like a few posts here and there

"they hadn't really done anything gamewise for me to suddenly go "YOU KNOW WHAT, they are definitely town." "

Then why'd you hide behind them? You listed Angi in your suspect list on d5 or whatever and then hid behind her that night

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 12:03

"they hadn't really done anything gamewise for me to suddenly go "YOU KNOW WHAT, they are definitely town." " Then why'd you hide behind them? You listed Angi in your suspect list on d5 or whatever and then hid behind her that night

I hid behind her N6 not N5

And I chose JC because I looked at the list of people and literally categorized them into like four different catergories

Likely Town but could be killed
Likely Town but won't get killed
Could go either way
Likely Scum

IN MY OPINION, on N5 I put JC in the 2nd category. He was someone that I didn't necessarily think was scum BUT also wasn't really going to be a kill target.

N6 I chose Angi because she was kind of the same. The more I thought about her role the more I realized she was probably town

What else you wanna know Curt??

Is it still Day 9, or did you guys rush the hammer?

Note: I've got about 5 minutes now, and then I'll be gone until late tonight (PT), as I'm flying across the country for a conference starting tomorrow morning.

I'll make sure to check in when I get there tonight and try to catch up (if it isn't already locked, like last night).

JC who is your preferred lynch target?

It is Day 10 right now.

My "drive-by, could probably be wrong" scum list would go like this right now:
Note: I haven't had a chance to look at voting records, etc. yet, these are just gut feels.

Most Scum

Herm - I just can't get the Anti-town scan out of my head. It's like a scab...you just want to pick it and cant stop messing with it until you pull it off.
Curtis - Playing a very smart game, and I could easily see all this work leading to driving the town bus, when actually scum.
Vic - I buy the hider claim somewhat, but it'd be easy as scum, with no active trackers/watchers, to claim a role like that, when you already know who townies are, especially when he "cleared it up with the mod" that he could also hide behind cult and not die. Actually, now that I type that out, Curtis and Vic are tied for me at scum slot #2
Angi - I just don't see that role being part of the mafia, especially if the mafia only has 1 person left. Just not enough abilities to offset having a 1-time only vote (per day).
JC - I'm Town Bulletproof, so obviously I'm the most town one of us all. ldo

Most Town