## lynch Kat

I'm not sure if she's scum or not, but taking into account what she has contributed thus far she's definitely a good candidate.

Btw, Animal, I do agree with you on Kat. She just posts 1 or 2 times a day, saying nothing, usually lynching, then leaves. Greenday, I'm not so sure. I think he usually hangs back more when he's scum.

ninja'd by Sir Harryson

Meow.

disingenuous*

Christian @ 24/12/2014 0:39

What say you, Samm?

I mean - honestly, not going to lie, my participation is pretty dismal. It's been a little hard keeping up while in Florida, aha. But idk, it is hard to tell, I would say looking more into the shadows would be the best call. I don't want to be the guy that repeats everything, but it's very scummy to me how Vernon acted until he was called out on his personality change and then his instant shift.

Also, since Moose was such an indefinite target, I would say it's easy for the entirety of the scum team to just hide in the past couple of days. More than not, I think Day 3 would be more telling than Day 4 in terms of lynches considering Kimmy died. (Chris, Patrick, Vernon, Tony). Vernon/Patrick's back and forth the past couple days has seemed a little fishy and unneeded.

Regardless, I think we're probably looking at mafia roleblocking SK and town roleblocking mafia.

Buffy @ 24/12/2014 1:55

Animal @ 24/12/2014 0:41 Buffy @ 24/12/2014 1:35 I would not be surprised if there were at least 1 scum on that train. Probably more. ##lynch Animal Why me over the other 10 or so people? Just cuz others keep mentioning me and it looks like it's easy to get votes on me? I'm not mafia and I guarantee there will be scum on my train because they will see it as an opportunity to get a contributing member of the town out. I mentioned you yesterday, too. Day 1 you didn't vote and only one post was game-related and it was just to ask how much logic can go into a D1 lynch. But, it was D1 so lots of silly, non-contributing posts and little to go on. But also an easy day for scum to hide. Day 2 your lynch of Matt was strange given the previous day but I kind of chalked it up to the fact you were traveling and maybe missed some things. Day 3 your post asking if Aries was scum struck me as ingenuous and like you were trying to pretend you didn't know that he flipped scum. You did vote kimmy instead of Moose and scum would have a reason to do that, obviously. Day 4 your opening post, as I mentioned then, just looked weird to me. I know you explained it, it was just the wording you used. Also, you have been very slow to cast suspicions on anyone until pushed. Yesterday, for example, and you included Wikey so...idk if you're really not paying attention or just playing like you're confused town.

Day 1 if I wanted to lay back I wouldn't have even made that comment. I'm annoyed I even posted it now cuz even as I was posting it, I was like "I know this COULD be interpreted scummy but ANYTHING can be interpreted scummy so idc" and I didn't care because I'm just NOT scum so I didnt feel the need to hide my thoughts. Turns out ppl thought it was scummy just bc I voiced my thoughts. & i suppose that's why I felt the need to be more reserved.

Day 2 I didn't think Moose or Kimmy were good lynches bc we had no info to go off of, but thought Moose contributed more than kimmy… but thought Matt contributed even less so I went with that. lynching matt would have given us information on everyone who was on his lynch train vs the train that diverted off of matt, so at least we would have had info. yes it was dumb in hindsight, but if i was mafia, why would i kill matt just after being the sole vote on him? lol… and I didn't think my reasoning was that dumb. I wanted to be independent instead of try to hide behind people, which i thought is generally looking positively upon; I don't see how you say I'm hiding behind people yet also standing out as scummy to you? Doesn't make sense to me.

Day 3 I still don't know if Aries is scum but I can go check now. I'm sorry I'm not too familiar w/ (most) FE people so I do mix people up often unless I go check. I had been traveling so no, I didn't check then, so i asked and voiced my opinions. if i were scum i don't think i would have. I'm not trying to pretend I didn't know or playing like I'm confused. I just genuinely am.

Day 4 I guess you just don't like how I word things. Ya I'm slow to cast suspicion but thats cause every time i do someone says "that's scummy" but i think its just how i word things or my naivety? I'm not trying to act a certain way or anything. also i have been voicing opinions. I've said many times I think we should look to people who don't contribute as much bc the more we have contributing, the more information we have to base lynches off of, etc… contributing only helps town imo. I think I've lynched almost every day, but some can't say the same… If you're looking for someone who is trying to blend in, you're looking at the wrong person.

also, I was with you on trying to save kimmy, hence my unlynch on her and I went to lynch Tony or whoever w/ you and Shadow and whoever else, but the thread got locked.

weeeeee

Animal @ 24/12/2014 1:09

I don't see how you say I'm hiding behind people yet also standing out as scummy to you? Doesn't make sense to me.

Did I say this? I don't remember saying you were hiding behind people.

Well you said day 1 is an easy day for scum to hide, which I apparently did not do if something I said stood out to you. :P

Animal @ 24/12/2014 1:17

Well you said day 1 is an easy day for scum to hide, which I apparently did not do if something I said stood out to you. :P

I wasn't necessarily saying you were (unless you're scum), it was a general comment because day 1 is a day for scum to hide. I was just explaining my sequence of evolving suspicion on you and started with day 1.

idk Animal, you have 1 vote and you're kind of defensive which is making me think you protest too much

Buffy @ 24/12/2014 2:26

idk Animal, you have 1 vote and you're kind of defensive which is making me think you protest too much

ya but ppl have been saying this for like 2 days now lol. and u posted an analyzed thing on me so i posted a reply. ya it was a lot but I'm also wordy

Buffy @ 24/12/2014 2:23

Animal @ 24/12/2014 1:17 Well you said day 1 is an easy day for scum to hide, which I apparently did not do if something I said stood out to you. :P I wasn't necessarily saying you were (unless you're scum), it was a general comment because day 1 is a day for scum to hide. I was just explaining my sequence of evolving suspicion on you and started with day 1.

oh & I know, I was just trying to hypothetically apply myself to your sequence; defending myself by saying i don't follow that sequence lol i guess it didnt make sense nvm

Idk I'm tired and sick. (On meds hehe) so I'm going to bed soon. I'll be on before work but I work all afternoon/evening until deadline the next four days. #SeasonalEmployeeHours

Lucky me lol

Anyway my thoughts are still to look at people who aren't contributing. Yeah Kat has come up for not posting much substantial, but DD didnt talk at all yesterday, Tony posted once, I will say I am impressed with Brian's recent contributions, Cash Money but he's confirmed town right?, I am still unsure if Chris has posted anything substantial, and I could go on but I'll leave it at that. I'm fine lynching any less actives tbh - or anyone else that information comes up pointing toward. if that makes sense idk

Hermarajah @ 24/12/2014 6:56

## lynch Kat I'm not sure if she's scum or not, but taking into account what she has contributed thus far she's definitely a good candidate.

Why Kat over like DD when it comes to contributions? Kat at least voted every day iirc.