rose = drr

well I'm an idiot. I thought drrr and rose were 2 different people both claiming to be bullet proof.

:facepalm:

Move along, nothing to see here.

Still think Herm is scum though. Not so sure on drrr now though.

Yeah I can't help but wonder if the mafia saw an easy scapegoat in Herm since he is acting very scummy. He was before his bizarre role claim.

I want to hear from DR. There is no harm in hearing who she has visited, and quite frankly her telling us should be enough confirmation of her role. Knowing that Patrick didn't leave his house could be put down to a lucky guess.

Knowing the activities of two others (would it be two or three now?) would be more than just luck, and we could write her off.

Herm @ 17/4/2014 2:24

There are three people I'm not sure about atm, those three are Boc, Angi and Gogo girl. Angi feels like she had been kinda in the shadows like Brian was. .

Can you explain this more to me please. I think of people in the shadows as lurkers and I've been consistently posting and here. Just not understanding your theory.


After seeing Brian's role, and what I was thinking yesterday


##lynch Herm

Patrick @ 17/4/2014 5:56

Certainly nothing is confirmed, but with Brian flipping town, Herm has fallen from my list. I don't see the scum connection, especially with Brian going after Herm.

You obviously have missed a few games where scum buddies have done this exact same thing lol

Ahoda @ 17/4/2014 5:57

I don't get how Herm wasn't the lynch over Vernon. He claims the exact same role and PM that a dead person has. A naive vig? Really?

Watch the show, it would make more sense then.

Angi @ 17/4/2014 8:17

Patrick @ 17/4/2014 5:56 Certainly nothing is confirmed, but with Brian flipping town, Herm has fallen from my list. I don't see the scum connection, especially with Brian going after Herm. You obviously have missed a few games where scum buddies have done this exact same thing lol

o sassy

Angi @ 17/4/2014 14:14

Herm @ 17/4/2014 2:24 There are three people I'm not sure about atm, those three are Boc, Angi and Gogo girl. Angi feels like she had been kinda in the shadows like Brian was. Can you explain this more to me please. I think of people in the shadows as lurkers and I've been consistently posting and here. Just not understanding your theory. After seeing Brian's role, and what I was thinking yesterday ##lynch Herm

No Angi, don't be so quick to lynch me. :)

I didn't mean to say you've been a lurker, I was just drawing comparisions to everyone still left. I just haven't been able to figure you out yet, I don't know whether you're town or scum. You're just in a grey area for me right now.

You just haven't been as vocal or out there as those who have been either gung-ho against me or those who have really tried to save me from being lynched. I feel you've been in the shadows because I can't properly read you like I can with those who have been seriously set from day 1 to get rid of me or those who have tried to save me. Scum wouldn't put themselves in a position like that, it'd be strange if they did tbh. Or at least that's how I see it. I'm going back and forth on Boc too. Brian and Hot Cocoa both said they thought I was scummy, but said they weren't sure. If you guys lynch me today, it should be relatively easy to determine who's scum or town seeing as pretty much everyone has been vocal about me lol.

And guys lol, I'm not third party. I'm town. The exact same role as Tim's. Nofo, for some reason, made two roles that were the exact same. It's so funny that none of you believe but still chose to lynch Vernon.

I don't think Wikey or Gogo girl posted yesterday, so I believe whoever was silenced out of those two is town.

And hang on, Brian flipped scum. Not town. Would Brian lynching me both on Day 2 and Day 3 really put me and him on the same team? Thanks to Brian's vote on Day 3 I was almost lynched, if I hadn't roleclaimed I would've probably been lynched instead of Vernon.

And ops, I realize Wikey's posted lol. Well, then Gogo girl is town for sure. And I don't remember much of what Shawn has posted, I think he tried to convince people that I was too out there to be scum but that was actually Ari. Ahoda is definitely town though, so so against me lol.

Nofo can you update the player list please?

As I see it

Town:
Ari - tried to lynch Brian
Perry - claim makes sense. No one has claimed BP.
Buffy - tried to lynch Brian

Likely town:
Greenday - dont think he would claim something as silly as he has if he was mafia.
Tricks - has acted townlike for the most part.
Herm - brian tried to lynch him. Dont think he is mafia. His claim fits with the buffy universe
DRRRRR - definitively not mafia. Brian attacked her yesterday and has been subject to multiple lynch trains.
g0 - didnt post yesterday. Possibly silenced? Mafia trying to lynch him?

Meh:
Patrick - not sure. Has he actually told us his suspects yet?
Wikey - has been vocal about what he thinks. Not much else.
Shawn - tried to lynch Greenday.

People who I would be okay with lynching:
Ahoda - lynched Curtis. Hasnt said much about anyone else
Angi - Has been lynching a lot. Only pointed fingers at townies that I can think of.
Boc - brought up lynching Vernon because he was making too much sense (lol). Has been pushing town lynches all game.
Cash Money - lynched Vernon. Didnt mention Brian. Thinks Herm looks good. Herm claims, then he lynches Herm.

People who mentioned g0 as possible scum (maybe trying to use the silence?:
Brian
Boc

I guess id be okay with lynching people in the MEH section if the arguments brought up are worthy.

That reminds me, I wrote down some reads last night before I fell asleep. They have been slightly revised for deaths and new info.

Ahoda –a good chunk of posts are being confused, and I would think a mafia member would be able to ask the scumboard if they were behind
Angi – don’t know what to think
Ari – seems rather UTR which I think feels off
Boc - town
Buffy – on the fence, says a lot but the content feels off
Drrr – I doubt scum would be as aggressive as that
G0 – clearly inexperienced and not sure what to think about that
Greenday – the roleclaim doesn’t completely clear him, but it’s plausible
Herm – still suspicious of that role, even if Brian’s aggression was a bit too much to be distancing for me
Patrick – trying to contribute as best he can, not that suspicious
Panda – pretty well cleared, it would seem
Shawn – not sure what to think, hasn’t posted that much
Tricks – pretty town
Wikey – would seem to have softclaimed an investigative role? Town enough

Wikey White @ 17/4/2014 6:54

Hey DR, maybe you could tell us who you have visited in recent nights!

On Night 1, I visited Patrick. He didn't leave his house.
On Night 2, I visited Buffy. She didn't leave her house.
On Night 3, I visited Curtis. In the flavor result I got, it said he hadn't left his house when I saw someone approach and left.

I hope Gogo shows up today so we can confirm that Brian even silenced someone yesterday.

g0 isn't confirmed silenced at all to me, much less confirmed town. He was really quiet the first two days so it's possible he just went inactive. I mean it'd be weird for Brian not to use his role obviously but there's always the possibility of blocking or whatever. And I don't remember anyone claiming they were silenced on D2? So even though I'm sure g0 will claim he's silenced now that he has the opportunity (I kinda wish he would've been on here before Wikey so he wouldn't be able to now use the excuse) he's not confirmed town for me at all. And even if he WAS silenced, it's not unheard of for scum to silence one of their own just to 'clear' them like this

And I know Ari's gonna use this as me trying to still use the scum silence to my advantage but I don't care! :P ;)

Ari @ 17/4/2014 9:36

Boc - brought up lynching Vernon because he was making too much sense (lol).

Incorrect!

tho my actual reasoning wasn't much better admittedly since it was mostly metagaming