I voted for Wall-E but I didn't see that you could vote for three choices. I would add The Incredibles and Toy Story if I could. And I'm sorry, but in my opinion Up is easily their most overrated movie and nowhere near their best. Aside from a heartfelt first ten minutes, the rest of the movie descends into their most juvenile story with talking dogs and and old man fight. I don't have a problem with fantasy or the fact that it's a movie for children but it came off as such a jarring tonal shift, especially for a movie touted as their most emotionally mature.

Ecto @ 7/12/2013 23:12

Aside from a heartfelt first ten minutes, the rest of the movie descends into their most juvenile story with talking dogs and and old man fight. I don't have a problem with fantasy or the fact that it's a movie for children but it came off as such a jarring tonal shift, especially for a movie touted as their most emotionally mature.

lol I agree. The rest wasn't bad or anything, but the first ten minutes was SO GOOD in every way. I would've loved to see the whole movie keep that tone up. But kids etc

I totally disagree! Obviously the opening is the best part, but I thought the rest was great too. I do think it got a bit TOO over-the-top with the whole BLIMP FITE but I think that's the only weak spot. The part where Carl finds Ellie's note in the scrapbook is almost as affecting as the opener to me

Really anything involving Carl and Ellie I loved, all throughout the movie. But anything with Russel(?) and the talking dog/flying dogs and that bird I could've done with it. The Carl stuff was always really strong though. Russel(?) was only good because of Carl's relationship with him

I DUNNO I haven't seen the movie in a long time really

Curtis @ 7/12/2013 2:58

KC @ 7/12/2013 4:25 - Toy Story - Toy Story 3 - Monsters, Inc. - Toy Story 2 - Up - Finding Nemo - WALL-E - A Bug's Life Never saw: The Incredibles Cars Ratatuille Cars 2 Brave Monsters University Same for me in terms of not seen Cars never interested me at all and I don't know why they made a sequel. Ratatouille and The Incredibles never interested me either but I heard they're good. Brave I'd like to see and Monsters University I'd really like to see

BUT WHAT ABOUT PLANES?!!?!?! It looks nothing like Cars!

Monsters

Monsters University was really funny too, I think. But I wouldn't vote for it because it's still kind of fresh and not a classic!!

On the topic of the merch monster that it Cars - Out of my friends that have kids, I think only of the kids isn't obsessed with Cars. It's all coming up Lightning McQueen - except for Spider-Man/Batman kid.

Toy Story 2 was shit

Toy Story > Monsters Inc > Up

I only voted for Up and it was just cause I love Dug.

Toy Story 3
The Incredibles (pure fun)
Finding Nemo

Stupid_Panda @ 8/12/2013 22:12

I only voted for Up and it was just cause I love Dug.

"I hid under your porch because I love you."

Toy Story
Toy Story 2
The Incredibles

From the remainder of the list I've only seen A Bug's Life and Finding Nemo

FE CONSENSUS:

Up: 8
Toy Story: 7
Finding Nemo: 6
Monsters, Inc.: 5
Toy Story 3: 4
The Incredibles: 4
WALL-E: 4
Toy Story 2: 2
Ratatouille: 2
Brave: 2
A Bug's Life: 0
Monsters University 0
Cars: 0
Cars 2: 0


lol fuck Cars