Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2 3
Mafia Wincon
 Poll Question: Which do you prefer?
50%
 
7 Votes
(58%)
More than 50%
 
5 Votes
(42%)
 
Curtis
User Avatar
First Place Dick
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,170
Group:Admin
Posts:79,236
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #31: 26th Oct 2023 12:21 PM 
im317 @ 26/10/2023 13:13
wasn't og mafia just 1 cop and the rest vanilla?


Def, but that rule still makes sense to me, kinda feels like the best of both worlds? Game doesn’t end if a day ends at 50%, but if a new day STARTS at 50% then sorry town, game over
Posted Image
   
Curtis
User Avatar
First Place Dick
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,170
Group:Admin
Posts:79,236
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #32: 26th Oct 2023 12:22 PM 
Again I’m not tryna have us all agree on one ruling, every game will be different, just curious what people prefer and why
Posted Image
   
dr
User Avatar
- cute and very brutal -
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 192
Group:Admin
Posts:17,989
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #33: 26th Oct 2023 12:30 PM 
i might make that rule the rule i go with if and when i run mafia again. SOMEDAY
d ( i n o s r o a ) r
"She essentially tore apart the Hex Girls with a simple STAT"
LUCK CREATOR | HEART HACKER | BUY GOLD BYE

+
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #34: 26th Oct 2023 1:28 PM 
Curtis @ 26/10/2023 12:21
im317 @ 26/10/2023 13:13
wasn't og mafia just 1 cop and the rest vanilla?


Def, but that rule still makes sense to me, kinda feels like the best of both worlds? Game doesn’t end if a day ends at 50%, but if a new day STARTS at 50% then sorry town, game over

Wouldn’t a 50/50 game to start a day almost always end the day 50/50 and tied? If so, and you’d play out the night in that case, why not play out the day?
 
   
Curtis
User Avatar
First Place Dick
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,170
Group:Admin
Posts:79,236
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #35: 26th Oct 2023 1:31 PM 
Spin @ 26/10/2023 14:28
Curtis @ 26/10/2023 12:21
im317 @ 26/10/2023 13:13
wasn't og mafia just 1 cop and the rest vanilla?


Def, but that rule still makes sense to me, kinda feels like the best of both worlds? Game doesn’t end if a day ends at 50%, but if a new day STARTS at 50% then sorry town, game over

Wouldn’t a 50/50 game to start a day almost always end the day 50/50 and tied? If so, and you’d play out the night in that case, why not play out the day?


It’s just…boring? And like I said earlier, it just becomes taunty and feels bad for the four townies who either know they already lost or have no idea it’s already game over
Posted Image
   
John Snav
User Avatar
Confirmed misogynist
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 120
Group:Overlord
Posts:16,277
Joined:Sep 18, 2014
Post #36: 26th Oct 2023 4:24 PM 
drrr @ 26/10/2023 10:30
i might make that rule the rule i go with if and when i run mafia again. SOMEDAY

idt ive ever played a drr mafia game. make it happen!
Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image
   
dr
User Avatar
- cute and very brutal -
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 192
Group:Admin
Posts:17,989
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #37: 26th Oct 2023 4:28 PM 
TheNavneet @ 26/10/2023 17:24
drrr @ 26/10/2023 10:30
i might make that rule the rule i go with if and when i run mafia again. SOMEDAY

idt ive ever played a drr mafia game. make it happen!

i think ive only run... one? two? i've PLANNED a lot of them but i always put off running until the point where I just don't feel like it anymore
d ( i n o s r o a ) r
"She essentially tore apart the Hex Girls with a simple STAT"
LUCK CREATOR | HEART HACKER | BUY GOLD BYE

+
   
JJ
User Avatar
Pig
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 164
Group:Godfather
Posts:33,771
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #38: 28th Oct 2023 1:18 AM 
drrr @ 23/10/2023 15:56
I like the Nothing Prevents It clause the best. The idea is that the Mafia wants to Kill everyone else in the game, and once things are at 50% that's usually a done deal, but certain mechanics can make that not as foregone

If not Nothing Prevents It though i prefer Mafia to have a voting majority, so >50%


IMO it should be "Mafia has 50% or nothing can prevent it" depending on the roles that are left. You have to account for the possibilities if you have a vig/rb/redirector, etc etc left.

FE Mafia is not basic. It's essentially "role madness" and the roles make a difference.
 
   
3 Users Viewing (3 Guests)
  Mafia  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service