Cody @ 12/8/2019 14:40

Are 3 VTs in a game this size believable?

The last game had more than this and less players

Granted it was by design.

I think I really want Timmah and Mittens to claim today.

I think one has to be mafia. MAYBE both but that would be a stretch

It's hard to get much of a read on IM because he isn't posting much, but I have been leaning town on him honestly. He claimed Day 1.

I could be wrong but I see no reason to doubt him right now.

TIB's claim is far more suspicious to me.

I’m leaning town on 317 as well.

Though then I have to rationalise why he advocated both a Brian and Buffy lynch in the same day.

Difficult.

##Unlynch

This game has suddenly become quite difficult.

took a nap

still not dead

I think I had a small revelation. But I want Herm to confirm his night actions.

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 14:35

Penner @ 12/8/2019 14:33 Mittens @ 12/8/2019 15:25 Penner @ 12/8/2019 14:20 Mittens who we lynching, man? Top of my list is im317 or Timmah depending on what Timmah claims Why them? im317 because he's been extremely unhelpful, and the VT claim is a low risk lynch. Timmah because he seems to be stuck on a bad read of me, and isn't seeming to provide much of anything else.

Why do you keep saying this? Do you just skip all of the posts I actually make so that you can keep claiming that I haven’t said anything worthwhile?

Just gonna put my thoughts out there regarding everyone alive. Feel free to poke holes, I won’t be offended.

PROBABLY TOWN:

Lamps- He’s proven enough, I think

Herm- Didn’t want to believe the motivator stuff at first, but Farlig confirmed he received motivation so I dont think it gets much more town than that

Cody- Yeah his role doesn’t look great, but I feel a lot of right in him and believe he’s town. Maybe I see a lot of myself from Battlestar mafia in him this game, and I’m just sympathetic?

Wikey- he’s voted against Josh for a while now. If Josh flips as 3P, could be mafia role cop trying to play good for town? Had been on hot seat D2 with Brian until he came back.


MAYBE TOWN:

Mittens- In favor of shooting Josh. Was pretty invisible D2 and D3. I don’t have much more for him.

Nav- Keep going back and forth on this one. He acted weird to me the first few days, and a couple people (Wikey, Cody) have said he’s off his game, which I agree with. I think lynching him would give us the most clarity for the remaining days.

Timmah- I think he’s been posting well for town, not really giving much new insight tho. Would be nice to see him take scum down or give us a reason to trust.

SCUM LIST:

TiB- We were right on the meta read for Brian. Might we be 2 for 2?

Josh- Good as dead rn, but need to add him for full list. He never helped town one iota.

im317- Not helpful at all. Easy claim.

Cody @ 12/8/2019 14:40

Are 3 VTs in a game this size believable?

I basically asked this earlier, and no one answered.

Not helping town once is a bit of a stretch

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 13:10

Cody @ 12/8/2019 14:40 Are 3 VTs in a game this size believable? I basically asked this earlier, and no one answered.

I wanna say my answer to this is yes but. All speculation at the end of the day

Josh @ 12/8/2019 16:10

Not helping town once is a bit of a stretch

Do you have a counterpoint?

oh shut. i just re-read my role pm

i have some good news guys!