Seeing as I am town.......saying my name is not scum hunting. I also believe Timmah.....although maybe third party no clue. I've asked before about non town roles that could be BP bUT everyone convinced me he's town so now I believe it.

Darren Sanders @ 15/4/2017 19:38

CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:36 Herm asked me and I said I'm currently of the thought that we don't have one. Lets work with the assumption that since the mod specified hidden notes in a cop role dictating what would occur if the cop visited the SK that there is one.

Oh I think I missed that
If there is an SK it would have to be Cherry right?

Angi @ 15/4/2017 16:39

Darren Sanders @ 15/4/2017 19:38 CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:36 Herm asked me and I said I'm currently of the thought that we don't have one. Lets work with the assumption that since the mod specified hidden notes in a cop role dictating what would occur if the cop visited the SK that there is one. Oh I think I missed that If there is an SK it would have to be Cherry right?

Or Timmah or you would be the most likely options.

I could see Timmah not killing to throw everyone off if he were allowed to.
I dont believe you would be able to not kill if you were a SK.
Cherry seems to be the most obvious SK option.

If Cherry flips town then we know who to look at.
If Cherry flips SK then Timmah is cleared from being both SK and Mafia.
You could still technically be mafia, though it would be a stretch since the godfather is already dead.

Just so I don't feel like I'm crazy because you shot it down so quickly earlier, DS. Curtis said:

"Something strange to keep in mind. I have no idea if it's relevant or if I'm reading too much into things (Primate noted something similar in his PM earlier)

I was told that I felt confident that Herm and Christian were town, but with Darren I got that I BELIEVE he is town

Could be nothing. Probably nothing? But worth keeping in the backs of our heads I guess"

It wasn't Curtis just coming to the conclusion that Christian and Herm were town because visiting them didn't kill him, he says he was told that he felt confident. His unlocked interrogator ability seems like it would make his reports more certain given that the wording in his flip indicates he's told their alignment. When he visited you he was only told he "believes" you are town. You were quick to try to move away from this earlier today.

CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:42

Just so I don't feel like I'm crazy because you shot it down so quickly earlier, DS. Curtis said: "Something strange to keep in mind. I have no idea if it's relevant or if I'm reading too much into things (Primate noted something similar in his PM earlier) I was told that I felt confident that Herm and Christian were town, but with Darren I got that I BELIEVE he is town Could be nothing. Probably nothing? But worth keeping in the backs of our heads I guess" It wasn't Curtis just coming to the conclusion that Christian and Herm were town because visiting them didn't kill him, he says he was told that he felt confident. His unlocked interrogator ability seems like it would make his reports more certain given that the wording in his flip indicates he's told their alignment. When he visited you he was only told he "believes" you are town. You were quick to try to move away from this earlier today.

Again, his mod confirmed flip stated nothing about receiving any partial or false results. If he was told that he believes that I am town, im town.

My reason for saying that I doubt we have a SK is because I don't see the bodies. I understand why I can say that with more certainty than others because I KNOW my role, but unless you're proposing the Mafia hasn't been killing at night, I think the bodies are all accounted for.

Darren Sanders @ 15/4/2017 20:44

CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:42 Just so I don't feel like I'm crazy because you shot it down so quickly earlier, DS. Curtis said: "Something strange to keep in mind. I have no idea if it's relevant or if I'm reading too much into things (Primate noted something similar in his PM earlier) I was told that I felt confident that Herm and Christian were town, but with Darren I got that I BELIEVE he is town Could be nothing. Probably nothing? But worth keeping in the backs of our heads I guess" It wasn't Curtis just coming to the conclusion that Christian and Herm were town because visiting them didn't kill him, he says he was told that he felt confident. His unlocked interrogator ability seems like it would make his reports more certain given that the wording in his flip indicates he's told their alignment. When he visited you he was only told he "believes" you are town. You were quick to try to move away from this earlier today. Again, his mod confirmed flip stated nothing about receiving any partial or false results. If he was told that he believes that I am town, im town.

But then you're also ignoring what I said earlier today. I don't argue what you said about his role. Nothing in the role as it flipped says he gets partial reports. Therefore, there's something peculiar about the person he visited OR there's some action a third party made on his report (unlikely after Vlad's lynch,) to obfuscate it.

CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:46

Darren Sanders @ 15/4/2017 20:44 CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:42 Just so I don't feel like I'm crazy because you shot it down so quickly earlier, DS. Curtis said: "Something strange to keep in mind. I have no idea if it's relevant or if I'm reading too much into things (Primate noted something similar in his PM earlier) I was told that I felt confident that Herm and Christian were town, but with Darren I got that I BELIEVE he is town Could be nothing. Probably nothing? But worth keeping in the backs of our heads I guess" It wasn't Curtis just coming to the conclusion that Christian and Herm were town because visiting them didn't kill him, he says he was told that he felt confident. His unlocked interrogator ability seems like it would make his reports more certain given that the wording in his flip indicates he's told their alignment. When he visited you he was only told he "believes" you are town. You were quick to try to move away from this earlier today. Again, his mod confirmed flip stated nothing about receiving any partial or false results. If he was told that he believes that I am town, im town. But then you're also ignoring what I said earlier today. I don't argue what you said about his role. Nothing in the role as it flipped says he gets partial reports. Therefore, there's something peculiar about the person he visited OR there's some action a third party made on his report (unlikely after Vlad's lynch,) to obfuscate it.

Or, both you and Curtis are looking too heavily into a single word.

I find it interesting that you believe that Curtis getting the word "believe" from the mod makes me possible scum yet you dont believe that the mod putting an entire line about there being a SK into Curtis' role flip means that there is a SK.

Tell me one person who was killed by a SK.

He believes I am town, because I am town.

Also feeling certain isnt the same as being certain if we really want to get into the linguistics of Curtis' investigations

CherryBerry @ 15/4/2017 16:49

Tell me one person who was killed by a SK.

Wikey, Miko, Merc, Lamps

all town btw

Both reports about DS said the same thing though. I said at the beginning i think he could still easily be third party. But not an sk

##Lynch im317

honestly what the fuck

Hmmm wait a minute. Didn't Primate visit DS?