I didn't mention the milk because I wasn't sure what it did and I wanted to see if I got some sort of good result back from it. I was worried that Mafia might think it gave me an advantage and kill me off before drinking it

I forgot about Vlady, he comes off as scum too

However my reads have been shit this game so what the fuck do I know

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:03

I didn't mention the milk because I wasn't sure what it did and I wanted to see if I got some sort of good result back from it. I was worried that Mafia might think it gave me an advantage and kill me off before drinking it

Or you were worried it might kill you as you are scum and she wasn't.

I believe Herm. Yesterday I was one of the people pushing him but today I agree that I think he's just been confused about the mirror shit. Having been Mafia with Herm multiple times before, he's always very well prepared when trying to come up with a fake claim

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:04

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:03 I didn't mention the milk because I wasn't sure what it did and I wanted to see if I got some sort of good result back from it. I was worried that Mafia might think it gave me an advantage and kill me off before drinking it Or you were worried it might kill you as you are scum and she wasn't.

Why'd I drink it the next night then

Spin who's scum other than me

Christian @ 10/4/2017 22:57

Timmah @ 10/4/2017 22:54 At this point, I will be legitimately surprised if Herm isn't mafia ninja or something similar. (TIB posted this at the point in the thread where I am - it was like he was reading my mind currently from 6 hours in the past...) It would make sense, and explain why nobody else has experienced the charred results. I know that I will always question his claim. But if the vote was between Herm and Aries yesterday, and there were people staying away from Aries, unless Herm's role is more useful than Mafia Watcher, how likely is it that Herm is also Mafia?

With the cult recruiter dead, how important is an inactive mafia watcher?

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:04 Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:03 I didn't mention the milk because I wasn't sure what it did and I wanted to see if I got some sort of good result back from it. I was worried that Mafia might think it gave me an advantage and kill me off before drinking it Or you were worried it might kill you as you are scum and she wasn't. Why'd I drink it the next night then

I don't know, because Buffy was dead!

Lol, no idea where that exclamation mark came from.

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:02

Vic @ 10/4/2017 22:58 Jamie Spin 317 I'm still catching up but those three are who I'm most uneasy about right now You forgot to jump on the crowd favorite in Herm, which is your MO this game.

And your MO is waiting for someone to accuse someone and then jumping on them after so you don't look as bad (:

Except for me I guess, I'm honored

It kind of seemed like he was trying to make a big deal of the mirror shields to make his role seem more important. There's only been one instance of redirection that we know of. And there's only been one instance of a mirror shield that we know of.

spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:06

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05 spindoctor02 @ 11/4/2017 0:04 Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:03 I didn't mention the milk because I wasn't sure what it did and I wanted to see if I got some sort of good result back from it. I was worried that Mafia might think it gave me an advantage and kill me off before drinking it Or you were worried it might kill you as you are scum and she wasn't. Why'd I drink it the next night then I don't know, because Buffy was dead!

How would Buffy being dead suddenly make the milk bad?

Timmah @ 10/4/2017 23:06

Christian @ 10/4/2017 22:57 Timmah @ 10/4/2017 22:54 At this point, I will be legitimately surprised if Herm isn't mafia ninja or something similar. (TIB posted this at the point in the thread where I am - it was like he was reading my mind currently from 6 hours in the past...) It would make sense, and explain why nobody else has experienced the charred results. I know that I will always question his claim. But if the vote was between Herm and Aries yesterday, and there were people staying away from Aries, unless Herm's role is more useful than Mafia Watcher, how likely is it that Herm is also Mafia? With the cult recruiter dead, how important is an inactive mafia watcher?

Actually, someone said that Herm and Aries were tied when Aries started hinting and then claimed? That would be the opposite of what I just said, and would actually help Herm's cause imo. My thought being that he claimed vig so late that it would be likely that the real vig may not cc until the following day, thus getting Aries through another day and getting a town player lynched?

Vic @ 10/4/2017 23:05

Spin who's scum other than me

I could see Timmah, Herm, DS, and some of the less actives being scum. I also think Christian could be scum too, but that's just moreso vibes.

I've been too busy to dive in too deeply.

I didn't mean to start an argument over spilled milk.