I mean, I don't think she's scum, but she could be. Is losing a Town Vanilla is better than no lynch?

ahoda @ 14/1/2015 14:50

Ari @ 14/1/2015 10:47 schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:36 ## unlynch Ari I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look. You think its more likely that scum Moose would claim on day 1 a role that he cant prove he has? Seems pretty risky seeing as she didnt have any heat on her. It's dumb and selfish. I'd rather lynch her then making someone else role claim imo. I think she's being honest but I've also used that same tactic as scum and claimed VT on Day 1 and lasted until the end of the game.

So you think she is town and you still want to lynch her based on a play you made in a previous game?

schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:52

Ari @ 14/1/2015 14:47 schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:36 ## unlynch Ari I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look. You think its more likely that scum Moose would claim on day 1 a role that he cant prove he has? Seems pretty risky seeing as she didnt have any heat on her. I agree, that's why I didn't think we should lynch her earlier, but how does a Town Moose, claim VT and help the town?

Because numbers matter? Moose might also start contributing some delicious posts in later days. Do you think Moose is town?

I think lynching an inactive is better than no lynch is better than VT lynch.

Do we still have time to make that happen?

Christian @ 14/1/2015 14:59

I mean, I don't think she's scum, but she could be. Is losing a Town Vanilla is better than no lynch?

Well you should lynch someone you think is scum. A no lynch is the worst possible outcome.

Ari @ 14/1/2015 10:04

Christian @ 14/1/2015 14:59 I mean, I don't think she's scum, but she could be. Is losing a Town Vanilla is better than no lynch? Well you should lynch someone you think is scum. A no lynch is the worst possible outcome.

Right. But I thought we were out of time and Moose had 3 votes. A couple of others had 2. I didn't want to join one of those trains and tie the vote.

Theres almost 2 hours left so... I'm willing to switch to an inactive or Nobert if that saves Moose, i have a feeling scum is trying to get her lynched bcuz its easy ("worst case we lose VT").

@ Ari, I'm not sure if Moose is scum or not. I have leaned town with her, that's why I said I was starting to warm to the idea, only because there wasn't a valid reason for it imo.

I don't think Moose is scum. I think it was stupid to claim Vanilla with no reason to at all. That doesn't help Town in any way. But I kind of feel like she's still new enough to not realize that that was a mistake? I could be wrong, and am not totally against seeing what happens if she's lynched actually.

Also, where's my good friend, Chris? :P

Lamps @ 14/1/2015 10:03

I think lynching an inactive is better than no lynch is better than VT lynch.

I agree with this and Basically Jeff is the equivalent of an inactive :p

I wasn't too thrilled with Kat or dds contributions either but Chris hasn't even shown up

There's two on tricks so we could make it happen with two votes.

Lamps @ 14/1/2015 15:03

I think lynching an inactive is better than no lynch is better than VT lynch.

Well the only ones left that haven't posted per my count and trying to determine who is who based on posting names and sign up names are:

Chris
Jamie
Tricks

I also think Rob seems scummy but I'm on phone at work and dont have the ability to elaborate

There's 2 on Jeff, 2 on Tricks, 2 on Curtis right now.

Tricks also falls into the inactive camp. But based on their discards, I'd fell better about lynching Jeff honestly.