BRIAN. CONFIRM YES OR NO. DID YOU KILL HERM.

ANSWER.

STAT!!!

Something is strange with the info relating to Shadow.

Claims: Shadow claims being Town Messenger. Merc confirmed (D2) that he knew that Shadow visited him N1. Shadow claims to have been roleblocked N2. Nobody claims to have received a message on N2.

Options:
#1) Shadow is the 3rd Hex Girl, and knew to visit Merc N1, thus joining him in a PF. This explains Merc's confirmation. However, this means Shadow is the odd-night SK, and couldn't have killed N2. There is still a missing kill N2.

#2) Shadow is mafia. Shadow was roleblocked N2, preventing the mafia from killing N2. This explains the lack of a kill. However, why would Hex Girl/SK Merc confirm that Shadow visited him N1? I don't see anyway the SK would do that.

#3) Shadow is Town Messenger. Shadow delivered a message to Merc N1, and was roleblocked N2. This fits with Merc's confirmation, and fits with the fact that nobody is claiming to have received a note N2. However, if Shadow is Town Messenger, and was roleblocked N2, where did the mafia kill go? Is there another roleblocker out there? Did the mafia no-kill?

#3b) Tin-foil hat time -- DS was the mafia killer N2, but was jailed, preventing him from carrying out his action and silencing him for today. Would explain the lack of posting and the lack of a death, without having the town roleblocker visit him.

--------------
I really wish Brian would have shot Shadow instead of Herm, so we could actually address some of these questions.

## Unlynch

I just get the strange feeling we are missing something obvious, and I think shadow may actually be telling the truth about their role.

THE GREAT DR @ 13/8/2017 20:22

Zersch @ 13/8/2017 20:18 Rose I know he isn't a Pokemon but could you MS Paint me a George Costanza? i'll do it for a mew

If shadow is mafia why would merc have confirmed his claim? IMO, shadow is either hex girl or town. It's 50/50 for me, but either way I bet there's multiple mafia on shadow's lynch.

Forgot to color its eyes.

Has DS been seriously "posting" all day??

Don't want to quote spins post be ... wall o' text.

But DS has been claiming to read me as town. Which has occurred exactly never. And gives me vibes.

Angi @ 13/8/2017 19:35

Has DS been seriously "posting" all day??

Yes, and all night last night too.

I'm sad that Curtis let go of my hand.

Timmah @ 13/8/2017 19:35

If shadow is mafia why would merc have confirmed his claim? IMO, shadow is either hex girl or town. It's 50/50 for me

I've said this exact thing at least twice today, and been ignored exactly twice. You repeat what I've said, and everybody jumps right on your post.

FU Everyone

Exactly there will be scum on my train
You let me live today and nobody gets a note tomorrow shoot me or lynch me then

Seems unlikely for the time left so good luck all

##lynch Ahoda

Defended maddie. Lynching shadow. Acting indignant that I read him as mafia. I'm not sure what to do about shadow, so I'll park here for a minute while we continue talking.

Nobody responds spin because it's prettty obvious shadow is either telling the truth or she's the 3rd hex girl.

Shadow @ 13/8/2017 19:43

Exactly there will be scum on my train You let me live today and nobody gets a note tomorrow shoot me or lynch me then Seems unlikely for the time left so good luck all

It's 50/50 you are the odd-night SK. If we let you live another night, you'll have the chance to kill.

Mittens @ 13/8/2017 19:46

Nobody responds spin because it's prettty obvious shadow is either telling the truth or she's the 3rd hex girl.

I don't recall a single person attempting to explain where the missing kill went. Everybody says "shadow must be the SK" or "shadow was roleblocked, and we are missing a kill". Those two things don't jive.

It wouldn't surprise me to see a bunch of mafia on Shadow's train.