Kiwi @ 14/1/2015 13:37

Why Rob?

Rob had 2 offtopic-ish posts and one answering Shadow. ie. he didnt bring anything new. Then he jumped on the moose train. Out of all moose voters I find Rob the most suspicious.

I also think Dylan's vote on Jamie is fishy, in the first place because cheap and easy inactives-vote, and secondly because earlier he announced focussing on the ppl discarding town (which i don't think makes sense but ok) and then didnt follow thru since he lynched someone who discarded a shitty scum role when there were other options available.

A dolphin swam up to me and told me that Kiwi is scum. /jokin

Rob of 2015 @ 13/1/2015 23:26

##lynch Moose. As I see it, best-case scenario we lynch scum. Worst-case scenario, we lose a vanilla. Worst-worst-case scenario Moose was some valuable town role and claimed vanilla for some stupid reason, and then we lose someone who claimed vanilla for some stupid reason and caused a bunch of unnecessary suspicion to distract us from finding people who are actually evil.

On the case of Rob, I dont like this post at all. This is a horrible reason to lynch someone.

Kiwi @ 14/1/2015 2:45

I think there is some knowledge that can be based on discarding. Particularly if we take into consideration peoples preferences (I know Paul has said in the past he likes town roles and Curtis, mafia roles). It doesn't mean they for sure are that but it's something to consider. Brian dropping the mafia doctor is most likely telling. Nothing can be read into people dropping vanilla/enabler type roles IMO.

you didn't say what was telling about me dropping maf-doc, but i figured i'd address it anyway. i hate being scum. my other role could've been town voteless loser and i still would've picked it.

Ari @ 14/1/2015 8:41

Rob of 2015 @ 13/1/2015 23:26 ##lynch Moose. As I see it, best-case scenario we lynch scum. Worst-case scenario, we lose a vanilla. Worst-worst-case scenario Moose was some valuable town role and claimed vanilla for some stupid reason, and then we lose someone who claimed vanilla for some stupid reason and caused a bunch of unnecessary suspicion to distract us from finding people who are actually evil. On the case of Rob, I dont like this post at all. This is a horrible reason to lynch someone.

i agree but i can actually see rob having that opinion regardless of his faction.

end of day is soon no? A vote count would be really helpful but im mobile so eep.

50 minutes or whats mst?

mountain standard time so we probably have 2:40 left, or until noon eastern.

I think this is correct?

Curtis 2/17 - Wikey, Ari
Christian 1/17 - Ahoda
Ahoda 1/17 - Moose
Matt 1/17 - Samm
Moose 3/17 - Shadow ,Rob, Kru
JJ 1/17 - Kiwi
Jeff 2/17 - Boc, JJ
Jamie 1/17 - Dylan
Ari 1/17 - Schrauben
Tricks 2/17 - Herm, Paul
Rob 1/17 - Lamps

All over the place xD Rly not a fan of the moose lynch.

## unlynch Ari

I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look.

schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:36

## unlynch Ari I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look.

You think its more likely that scum Moose would claim on day 1 a role that he cant prove he has? Seems pretty risky seeing as she didnt have any heat on her.

Ari @ 14/1/2015 10:47

schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:36 ## unlynch Ari I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look. You think its more likely that scum Moose would claim on day 1 a role that he cant prove he has? Seems pretty risky seeing as she didnt have any heat on her.

It's dumb and selfish. I'd rather lynch her then making someone else role claim imo. I think she's being honest but I've also used that same tactic as scum and claimed VT on Day 1 and lasted until the end of the game.

Ari @ 14/1/2015 14:47

schrauben @ 14/1/2015 14:36 ## unlynch Ari I agree with Lamps reasoning on Rob, however I'm going to save my vote for a bit, I'm starting to warm up to a Moose lynch, cause the more I think about it, I don't understand as a Town Vanilla why one would claim that soon putting pressure on themselves, when imo the way to play it is essentially sacrifice and allude to more of a power role that would take attention during the night and saving a power role. Someone said something similar to this earlier, but I can't remember who and don't have time to go back and look. You think its more likely that scum Moose would claim on day 1 a role that he cant prove he has? Seems pretty risky seeing as she didnt have any heat on her.

I agree, that's why I didn't think we should lynch her earlier, but how does a Town Moose, claim VT and help the town?

I don't think Moose is scum, but tying the vote right now to save her is not something I'd like to do.