JJ @ 15/8/2017 14:24

Farlig, sounds like we have a misunderstanding and you are calling me Dadd for not getting what you are saying lol. Is that correct?

Yes, I only intended fishing to apply to the mason role listed, not all of them :)

I'm torn between Christian and Jamie. Christian is typically this UTR when scum and Jamie's claim is fishyyyy. Hmmmm

im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:27

thinking about it some more and i could see Jamie having a real list as scum either with the role hes claiming or as a role cop. ##lynch Jamie

The only thing that makes me pause at this is strongman being included. But like primate said, all the roles could just be to throw us off if Jamie is scum.

farlig @ 15/8/2017 15:35

im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:27 thinking about it some more and i could see Jamie having a real list as scum either with the role hes claiming or as a role cop. ##lynch Jamie The only thing that makes me pause at this is strongman being included. But like primate said, all the roles could just be to throw us off if Jamie is scum.

didn't we have 2 people flip BP on day 1 alone?

JJ @ 15/8/2017 19:31

Ben @ 15/8/2017 15:27 Same for you JJ, why Christian? He's been very quiet this game. Very unlike him, since he's usually one of the top town scum-hunters imo. Most of his posts seem to be filler. Also, the fact DS listed him as scummy and could've blocked him N2 doesn't change my mind.

Similar to what Vic said earlier as well when I went back and looked.


I'll switch my vote for now, for I'm not sure we'll garner anything more from pressure on Jamie, but I'd like to hear more from Christian for sure.

##unlynch

##lynch Christian

Yeah what JJ said

im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:36

farlig @ 15/8/2017 15:35 im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:27 thinking about it some more and i could see Jamie having a real list as scum either with the role hes claiming or as a role cop. ##lynch Jamie The only thing that makes me pause at this is strongman being included. But like primate said, all the roles could just be to throw us off if Jamie is scum. didn't we have 2 people flip BP on day 1 alone?

Strongman is a role modifier that signifies that any kills performed by this player cannot be blocked by any means - neither by Bulletproof, nor by Doctor or other protective roles, nor by Roleblocks.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/?title=Strongman

But again, scum would have no reason to out a real mafia role.

I was thinking the Jamie vs. Mittens thing might have some legs.

@ Mittens would a mafia role cop specifically want you dead?

farlig @ 15/8/2017 15:41

im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:36 farlig @ 15/8/2017 15:35 im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:27 thinking about it some more and i could see Jamie having a real list as scum either with the role hes claiming or as a role cop. ##lynch Jamie The only thing that makes me pause at this is strongman being included. But like primate said, all the roles could just be to throw us off if Jamie is scum. didn't we have 2 people flip BP on day 1 alone? Strongman is a role modifier that signifies that any kills performed by this player cannot be blocked by any means - neither by Bulletproof, nor by Doctor or other protective roles, nor by Roleblocks. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/?title=Strongman But again, scum would have no reason to out a real mafia role.

i know what the role is, i was just saying that there is a good chance they have one. 2 town BPs have flipped so far along with 2 3rd party BPs and another 3rd party who became BP once one of the first 2 died.

farlig @ 15/8/2017 13:41

im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:36 farlig @ 15/8/2017 15:35 im317 @ 15/8/2017 14:27 thinking about it some more and i could see Jamie having a real list as scum either with the role hes claiming or as a role cop. ##lynch Jamie The only thing that makes me pause at this is strongman being included. But like primate said, all the roles could just be to throw us off if Jamie is scum. didn't we have 2 people flip BP on day 1 alone? Strongman is a role modifier that signifies that any kills performed by this player cannot be blocked by any means - neither by Bulletproof, nor by Doctor or other protective roles, nor by Roleblocks. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/?title=Strongman But again, scum would have no reason to out a real mafia role.

That's a can't lose role to out as mafia whether it exists or not.

If I'm mafia, I would gladly out a strongman role. It doesn't help town to know it exists in any way.

If Jamie was strongman there is no real worry. If he's caught he just outs himself. But if he didn't add a mafia role it makes his claim less believable

Rose did you gun have to be used at end of day or lose it?

I'm more convinced of Christian being scum looking at his posts this game

##lynch Christian

I do t Jamie's role. He's randomly told of a role? Does he pick the role and find out if it's in the game?