Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:57

Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:55 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:53 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:50 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:48 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:45 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:44 ##lynch im317 So Herm does have a teammate. No, I would just rather keep potential poisoner in the game vs. mafia. 1. If Herm is town (I don't think he is, but go with me here), Maddie just claimed to be not town. 2. How is Herm more likely to be poisoner and not mafia roleblocker, based on how the game has played out? We don't know who the fuck is mafia RB vs. poisoner in this instance, and you arrogantly acting like you for sure know is frustrating. I'm sorry the guy who hasn't been paying attention seems to have solved the big question of the moment. The frustrating part is how everyone else is just ignoring it. Ahhh doubling down. Either way we are hitting scum here. Better to get the poisoner, but I feel more certain of im317 being scum, whether mafia or poisoner, than I do of Herm or Timmah being one or the other. It's going with my gut.

Run the math. Poisoner can't win as long as nobody current is poisoned. There aren't enough unknown people left to allow them to get 5 poison deaths before being lynched.

Poisoner is definitely not the better focus right now.

TIB we need your sound mind here.

Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:58

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:57 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:55 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:53 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:50 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:48 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:45 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:44 ##lynch im317 So Herm does have a teammate. No, I would just rather keep potential poisoner in the game vs. mafia. 1. If Herm is town (I don't think he is, but go with me here), Maddie just claimed to be not town. 2. How is Herm more likely to be poisoner and not mafia roleblocker, based on how the game has played out? We don't know who the fuck is mafia RB vs. poisoner in this instance, and you arrogantly acting like you for sure know is frustrating. I'm sorry the guy who hasn't been paying attention seems to have solved the big question of the moment. The frustrating part is how everyone else is just ignoring it. Ahhh doubling down. Either way we are hitting scum here. Better to get the poisoner, but I feel more certain of im317 being scum, whether mafia or poisoner, than I do of Herm or Timmah being one or the other. It's going with my gut. Run the math. Poisoner can't win as long as nobody current is poisoned. There aren't enough unknown people left to allow them to get 5 poison deaths before being lynched. Poisoner is definitely not the better focus right now.

Yes I already said it's preferable not to lynch the poisoner because of the delayed kill. But I don't want to just guess and then have a mislynch.

im317 @ 26/3/2021 13:58

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:55 I almost changed my mind, but IM is not helping his case with the self-block theory. That’s something he will use tomorrow as well if it’s him. not self block. my hypothetical is that Stargate was town role blocker and mafia Maddie either was blocked by them (idk how the order of operations would shake out) or Maddie lied about begging blocked night 1. i am not firm in this, hence me not voting Maddie. i just think ruling her out as mafia based on her claim of being blocked night 1 is dangerous.

Then let's vote Timmah and let me murder you with my gun tonight. :)

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 13:05

im317 @ 26/3/2021 13:58 Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:55 I almost changed my mind, but IM is not helping his case with the self-block theory. That’s something he will use tomorrow as well if it’s him. not self block. my hypothetical is that Stargate was town role blocker and mafia Maddie either was blocked by them (idk how the order of operations would shake out) or Maddie lied about begging blocked night 1. i am not firm in this, hence me not voting Maddie. i just think ruling her out as mafia based on her claim of being blocked night 1 is dangerous. Then let's vote Timmah and let me murder you with my gun tonight. :)

the problem with this is that i think Timmah is town

im317 @ 26/3/2021 14:09

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 13:05 im317 @ 26/3/2021 13:58 Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:55 I almost changed my mind, but IM is not helping his case with the self-block theory. That’s something he will use tomorrow as well if it’s him. not self block. my hypothetical is that Stargate was town role blocker and mafia Maddie either was blocked by them (idk how the order of operations would shake out) or Maddie lied about begging blocked night 1. i am not firm in this, hence me not voting Maddie. i just think ruling her out as mafia based on her claim of being blocked night 1 is dangerous. Then let's vote Timmah and let me murder you with my gun tonight. :) the problem with this is that i think Timmah is town

Not that I want to kill you? ;)

(my post was sarcastic)

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 13:10

im317 @ 26/3/2021 14:09 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 13:05 im317 @ 26/3/2021 13:58 Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:55 I almost changed my mind, but IM is not helping his case with the self-block theory. That’s something he will use tomorrow as well if it’s him. not self block. my hypothetical is that Stargate was town role blocker and mafia Maddie either was blocked by them (idk how the order of operations would shake out) or Maddie lied about begging blocked night 1. i am not firm in this, hence me not voting Maddie. i just think ruling her out as mafia based on her claim of being blocked night 1 is dangerous. Then let's vote Timmah and let me murder you with my gun tonight. :) the problem with this is that i think Timmah is town Not that I want to kill you? ;) (my post was sarcastic)

if i thought Timmah was scum then i would be willing to lynch him regardless of your claim.

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 11:59

TIB we need your sound mind here.

Lol we are doomed.

Right now i feel im is the safer vote. I'm kidding some arguments cause I'm working. I missed lamps claim and why timmah wasn't rb. Timmahb as poisoner and not killing last night could be a thing. He's dinner that before as sk.

I also missed Lamps' claim, actually.

Spin @ 26/3/2021 19:55

Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:53 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:50 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:48 Spin @ 26/3/2021 13:45 Gabagool @ 26/3/2021 12:44 ##lynch im317 So Herm does have a teammate. No, I would just rather keep potential poisoner in the game vs. mafia. 1. If Herm is town (I don't think he is, but go with me here), Maddie just claimed to be not town. 2. How is Herm more likely to be poisoner and not mafia roleblocker, based on how the game has played out? We don't know who the fuck is mafia RB vs. poisoner in this instance, and you arrogantly acting like you for sure know is frustrating. I'm sorry the guy who hasn't been paying attention seems to have solved the big question of the moment. The frustrating part is how everyone else is just ignoring it.

This is why it's important to pay attention so you don't come to a weird conclusion like Herm is 100% scum.

I don't know how you can be so certain.

Scum players can vote their own and distance.

I do agree with whoever said mafia RB likely blocked the poisoner, and neither want to come out with that info because it exposes them lol.

Will be annoying/funny if we lynch the person who was poisoned.

Lamps seens to know Timmah is not Mafia Rolrblocker.

I don't remember seeing a claim, but he had some valuable info.

I have to go run an errand, but I'll be back in an hour or two.

Day 4 "Passover Eve Eve" Vote Count

Herm (3/4)- Spin, im317, Timmah
im317 (2/4)- Herm, Lamps, Maddie
Timmah (0/4)- Herm

Not Voted: TIB
Unlynched: Lamps


Day ends at 8pm ET

Penner, hand me another one of those guns pls.