Day 3 Lynch Count:


Jackie (6/11) - Zersch, Spin, Farlig, Jamie, Mal, Perry
Zersch (5/11) - im317, Rodney, Penner, Curtis, TIB
Kyle (1/11) - ???
Curtis (1/11) - Kyle
Maddie (0/11) - Perry


Day will end 10:00PM EST Sunday

I think this is right. Lots of non voters.

My scum list is probably:

Z
Perry
Zach
Maddie
Farlig

I guess you could throw Jackie/Reaper in there but they're both borderline inactive so like, its hard to place them

Actually wait. one of maddie/perry, I dont think they both can be scum.
Scumreads:
Z
Perry/Maddie
Farlig
Zach

Town reads:
TIB
Rod
Jamie
Penner bc of Rod tho

I'm back home for a little bit and reading up now

3.5 hours until deadline. Posting my reads list shortly.

Penner and 317 are the only ones I can put in a strong town tier.

Why is Z getting votes?

Town:
Penner
TiB

Probably Town:
Rodney
Kyle
im317
Brian
Matt
Jamie

Neutral:
Jackie
Perry
Farlig
Cody
Curtis
Reaper
Mal
Maddie

Likely scum:
Zersch
Spin
Timmah
Zach

Suddenly in the mood for Italian food!

Even though today has turned into Zersch vs. Me, I don't feel Zersch is scum. The only scummy thing I would callout is choosing not to use an ability on N1. The anvil choice and his posts today have all been reasonable and solid.

For my scum list I'm not feeling great about either Kyle or Reaper.

Kyle's posts have mainly been filler and not game related. He's not fitting into an inactive/non-participant category since he fills the thread with 40 non game posts a day.

For Reaper I could def see them trying to keep their head low today. With the narrative so focused on Z or myself, as long as they don't post anything the spotlight shouldn't shine in their direction

Actually yeah bump Kyle down to neutral. I could see his whole “what’s a factional kill?” thing as an act

Spin @ 6/9/2020 15:27

Here's a question I don't think has been answered yet: If im317 is the Town Vig, and Town basically couldn't take any actions last night, why did mafia take him out with their factional kill the one night they were guaranteed to not be blocked/tracked/watched/etc.?

Mittens was a bigger target? especially if they figured his role out.

Spin @ 6/9/2020 15:37

The Goose @ 6/9/2020 14:32 I don't think 317 is a dedicated vigilante, but I don't see how Mafia would know that going into the night only seeing a single one-shot kill flip at the time. Too many other kills scattered around in town to have a dedicated one, surely. Like I could imagine there being five or six town with a night kill (maybe more are unlocked like Mittens was) instead of one person that can do it every night. But im317 was the only known killer from Town going into last night. He was the obvious target. Mafia rarely, if ever, gets a chance at the obvious target without worrying about investigative roles catching them.

maybe mafia has a role blocker? also we know my kill was messed with in some way night 1...

The Goose @ 6/9/2020 15:48

If they have a permanent redirector anyone they think has a permanent kill becomes a utility tbh.

...so this is a possibility.

Spin @ 6/9/2020 17:22

Rodney @ 6/9/2020 16:19 Have you read today at all? Almost no one is convinced and that includes me and all the z voters. He's making it very hard because he sounds so town What are you talking about? Everybody who is voting for Zersch references Herm and the anvil stuff for their reasoning. Some people mention that he didn't use his ability on N1, but with only 1-shots, so what? I'd probably save them too to find better options. I don't see how Zersch and Herm are tied together, simply because Herm had that part of his role negating a night's worth of actions if he was lynched. From my recollection, Herm was never a serious candidate to be anvil'd, so dropping the anvil on anyone else wouldn't be suspicious.

with 5 1 shots you would not use any night 1? also for me his saying he has a kill is very suspect when we already had a town player flip with a kill and another town player flip with the ability to earn a kill, plus me

Pen Newton @ 5/9/2020 23:08

The Goose @ 6/9/2020 0:05 To me crowd consensus seemed pretty clearly everyone but Nav and Rodney was for me dropping it on gmaj. I don’t recall anyone’s opinion besides my own

I advocated for killing gmaj over herm. I still think it was the right decision given what was going on and known at the time. not sorry.

With Kyle I was thinking yesterday that if he were scum, he'd probably be a bit more nervous in his posting. His last game I believe was his first, and he was town there...and his tone is pretty similar.

Could just be though that his scum team was like "kyle just shit post and people will probably think you're good" (:

Pen Newton @ 6/9/2020 17:41

Town: Penner TiB Probably Town: Rodney Kyle im317 Brian Matt Jamie Neutral: Jackie Perry Farlig Cody Curtis Reaper Mal Maddie Likely scum: Zersch Spin Timmah Zach

It's hilarious how bad at this you are.