JJ @ 27/4/2017 23:36

Miko @ 27/4/2017 19:31 JJ @ 27/4/2017 23:29 I don't buy it. Can you explain why? It just seems weird that you would be BP but have to pick the right night.

Why does that seem weird? Is it common in mafia games that people who have BP actions can use it multiple times?

The description says you can pick only one night to use the BP vest, and only the actions that night against you are blocked.

OK so to me, the claim seems kinda bogus. But it does line up with something I was looking for when pushing for him to claim.

Zersch @ 27/4/2017 23:39

So your role is Town Bulletproof?

Yes

BadgerMcBeaver @ 27/4/2017 18:41

OK so to me, the claim seems kinda bogus. But it does line up with something I was looking for when pushing for him to claim.

Can you elaborate on this at all?

Kinda but not without claiming myself.

Not that Badger is sketch at all, but i do hate the kinda throwing out info thing.

(don't hate me more than you already do)

Nofo was a one-shot bodyguard, I guess a one-shot BP isn't exactly out of the realm of possibility or anything we haven't seen before. I just don't like the 'pick the night' stipulation added to it.

I also just realized you said the claim was bogus but you were looking for it?

OK well it's not a huge deal I guess, so I'll just confirm that Miko did not leave his house last night. It's certainly not enough to make or break his case, but it's a point in his favor.

I thought that maybe if he was scum, he might have a scum slip when he claimed and claimed to visit someone last night.

thisisbad @ 27/4/2017 18:47

I also just realized you said the claim was bogus but you were looking for it?

I meant the claim itself, not the fact that he provided the claim.

Nofo's role also specified in the role title that he was one-shot Bodyguard (Punching Bag).

Dunno why Miko's wouldn't and he's just Town Bulletproof.

Miko @ 27/4/2017 18:41

JJ @ 27/4/2017 23:36 Miko @ 27/4/2017 19:31 JJ @ 27/4/2017 23:29 I don't buy it. Can you explain why? It just seems weird that you would be BP but have to pick the right night. Why does that seem weird? Is it common in mafia games that people who have BP actions can use it multiple times? The description says you can pick only one night to use the BP vest, and only the actions that night against you are blocked.

it seems weird because a 1 time BP who also has to guess right when to activate there BP ability is weird. for example last game Angi had to chose to activate her BP ability but it was 3 shot. as much as i don't really buy it, i feel like you would have used a standard 1 shot BP if you were making it up, especially if you are mafia and have a team to help. so i need to think on this.

Time is running out to pick a runner-up then. One hour, forty minutes.

Picking the night of using a BP active ability is done in Town Of Salem, so I could see Maddie implementing it here. I implemented a similar role in the game I just hosted.

But only allowing it to be activated one time seems weak - in Town of Salem it's a three time use ability. It could be that she just felt she stacked the town with strong roles already and intentionally made it weaker, but I'd think that there'd still be at least two activations?

thisisbad @ 27/4/2017 18:46

Not that Badger is sketch at all, but i do hate the kinda throwing out info thing. (don't hate me more than you already do)

Lol I don't hate you at all.

Yeah I figured after I posted that, I might as well just out the info.