I believe the list is true, it's too specific for it not to be, so it's just a matter of role and alignment to be confirmed.

I don't believe Jamie at all.

In any way.

Even a little

No Sir!

Hey Dadd!

RIP























And FU!

Primate @ 15/8/2017 15:10

I don't believe Jamie at all.

Primate @ 15/8/2017 15:10

In any way.

Primate @ 15/8/2017 15:10

Even a little

Primate @ 15/8/2017 15:10

No Sir!

i know she's clearly hiding something!!

well i missed a lot. i don't see Spin lying about his results, but then we get into WIFOM territory. at least Dadd's flip might explain the bus driver thing i thought was going on. i could for sure see Dr as mafia and killing already outed Maddie for town cred, far more likely then Spin lying but still not the best choice to go after. Jamie's claim seems to specific to be fake, especially as the mason part when Shaggy already flipped as something else. i still have an odd feeling about Christian but that's just vibes


anyone have a vote count? im totally lost on where the votes have been going other then Jamie.

farlig @ 15/8/2017 14:57

Ahoda @ 15/8/2017 13:56 farlig @ 15/8/2017 13:54 JJ @ 15/8/2017 13:31 Ben @ 15/8/2017 14:28 ## lynch Jamie, it's time for her to do some talking. Seems like she has done nothing to alleviate any thoughts of her being scum for the past couple days. Jamie is a he (as in son). Also, he just claimed. I buy it. idk if that could be a scum role, though? Possibly, but strongman being listed as one of the roles... I'm trying to figure out how masons would fit into a Scobby Doo game tbh. Shaggy wasn't in it so the main characters dont' seem to be part of it. That too. It's a really odd list with none of the more standard roles (doc, watcher, role blocker). That one could easily be fishing for the possibility of them being present or not.

If you're going to fish for roles, why fish for Mason or Hated Townie? And Strongman... why couldn't there be one? If he listed doc, watcher, role blocker then people would be saying - oh well that would be obvious. Could still be a mafia role but I don't think he's lying about the roles he listed.

I tend to agree with Lamps, plus I think we still learn more from a Jamie Lynch today.

##lynch Jamie

I agree JJ, I believe the list its a matter of alignment.

JJ @ 15/8/2017 14:14

If you're going to fish for roles, why fish for Mason or Hated Townie? And Strongman... why couldn't there be one? If he listed doc, watcher, role blocker then people would be saying - oh well that would be obvious. Could still be a mafia role but I don't think he's lying about the roles he listed.

Dadd is that you? I was only referring to fishing in connection with the mason role. Not saying there couldn't be any of those but strongman is normally a mafia role and hated townie is a :meh: role to go fishing for.

Only one of those really would be beneficial for mafia to confirm through fishing if you stop and think about it.

Nope! Mason, Strongman, and Hated townie would be perfect roles for mafia to lie about the existence of.

Primate @ 15/8/2017 14:18

Nope! Mason, Strongman, and Hated townie would be perfect roles for mafia to lie about the existence of.

Someone gets me.

I would definitely list the last one myself if I was mafia, tbh.