Darren Sanders @ 15/4/2017 23:49

Herm @ 15/4/2017 14:47 Timmah For a lot of the last day and a half I was starting to think Angi was GF. I didn't originally because her claim didn't cc me exactly, and because nothing she posted sounded like she knew that her group tried to kill me. To make sure it is clear, she claimed she can choose when to be BP, While I started the game with two heart containers. With Chris' flip, I am back to thinking we are both town. I know I am, anyway. The end of this part of Tim's post feels weird to me, I find it weird that he thinks both him and Angi could be town. He's rightfully suspicious of im317's claim tho. Those three roles are not all town imo, not with me, Nofo, Farlig and TIB with our other protective roles. Why couldn't they both be? If Cherry flips as SK then it is likely they are both town.

Time will tell I guess, I naturally get suspicious with a bunch of bp. I feel like one of the BP people could be SK tho.

Herm @ 15/4/2017 17:53

Vic had to have used his roles the other nights, though. He's lynching himself too which seems to indiicate caught scum so that's a bit weird. im317 never once considered timmah or angi to be SK, but he went straight for Cherry, and then he went for VIc. I guess Timmah could be town. Vic and im317 are much more sketchy.

i jumped on Cherry as SKer once we got proof there is a SKer. sometimes the simplest solution is the right one. also on multiple occasions i mentioned that i felt the game balance was off and that because of that i suspected either a second cult member from the start or some kind of SKer. i only tabled the arsonist type SKer once everyone had claimed and there was nobody saying there job was to stop one.

oh, and to answer Spin's comment about whoever gave him the boots wasting it on him:

My action is delayed by one day. So I have to predict who will a) not die the night I submit the action and b) survive the following day.

I had never given to Cherry since I assumed he'd be a high priority target for scum. Little did I know, he'd be alive on Day 6.

Anyway, Zersch's experience with the mirror shield seemed like an action apart from his actual role. Same with Curtis and the slingshot. I don't know what the items do. But I assumed the hover boots would get Spin out of dodge if someone attacked him, since he's confirmed Town.

That's not important information right now.

Also, I was informed that if I had died the night I submitted an action, my item would still be delivered to the recipient. So at least, if it wasn't obvious already, we know that actions would go through even with a death.

Could it also be possible there is no SK? Maybe that part of the hidden text was thrown in to mess with us? Or just forgotten to be removed?

I did like that Timmah was trying to come up with a plan. See Vic, that's what made him come off as more Townish today.

If Cherry isn't the SK, then the actual SK is holding in attacks or something. Probably not an arsonist since there would be someone to stop him, as im317 explained.

let's assume that Cherry is not the SK for a moment. Would the real one want to get Cherry lynched or leave them in the game longer?

we give Cherry one more night? See if she goes after im317, like Timmah suggested. I mean, at this point, he'll have to keep killing the suspicious sorts to try to look like a vig (if he isn't).

Herm @ 15/4/2017 19:09

If Cherry isn't the SK, then the actual SK is holding in attacks or something. Probably not an arsonist since there would be someone to stop him, as im317 explained.

This is counter the SK's win condition though, right?

im317 @ 16/4/2017 0:03

Herm @ 15/4/2017 17:53 Vic had to have used his roles the other nights, though. He's lynching himself too which seems to indiicate caught scum so that's a bit weird. im317 never once considered timmah or angi to be SK, but he went straight for Cherry, and then he went for VIc. I guess Timmah could be town. Vic and im317 are much more sketchy. i jumped on Cherry as SKer once we got proof there is a SKer. sometimes the simplest solution is the right one. also on multiple occasions i mentioned that i felt the game balance was off and that because of that i suspected either a second cult member from the start or some kind of SKer. i only tabled the arsonist type SKer once everyone had claimed and there was nobody saying there job was to stop one.

You don't think all these protective roles is weird, or you believe that means Cherry is SK?

If he isn't, then there must be something up with all these protective roles right?

CherryBerry @ 16/4/2017 0:11

Herm @ 15/4/2017 19:09 If Cherry isn't the SK, then the actual SK is holding in attacks or something. Probably not an arsonist since there would be someone to stop him, as im317 explained. This is counter the SK's win condition though, right?

He wins if he's the last one standing. Who do you think is the SK?

I've waffled today a lot in how I think. At the moment, I'm thinking we don't have one. The rules say play to your win condition, and that means killing if you're SK. It's easy for me to say knowing who I am and what I've done, but I can say all of the deaths thus far are accounted for without the presence of a serial killer.

I dunno i lean towards no sk honestly. If there was it would have to be Cherry and that just seems off.

I think Curtis role is the only one so far that mentioned sk. We have no role that tries to find sk. And even Ahoda's role doesn't say what happens if he tries to recruit the sk.

Day 6 of this game has entered into my top 10 list of worst days in the history of the planet.

If there wasn't a SK, then Curtis's role wouldn't have mentioned it in his "hidden" flavor.

The fact that the SK information was hidden until Curtis's flip means there's a SK in the game.

Christian @ 15/4/2017 15:07

Could it also be possible there is no SK? Maybe that part of the hidden text was thrown in to mess with us? Or just forgotten to be removed? I did like that Timmah was trying to come up with a plan. See Vic, that's what made him come off as more Townish today.

If its posted by a mod it should be considered true imo