Also here is a scum list that I have put more or less no thought into before I go since I have missed most of the night playing games.

TOWN
Josh, cutest townie ever <3

LEAN TOWN
Christian
Nav
Stargate
Brian
Zersch
Nofo

NEUTRAL
Farlig
Moose
Curtis
Vern
Timmah
Penner
Kyle

LEAN SCUM
Spin
Herm
Shadow
Mittens
Lamps
Mal

SCUM
Jackie
ZacharyB

Star all ur scum suspects are people who have called u scum

ur literally just OMGUSing

Ok is Christian scum?

Josh @ 5/10/2020 8:05

I also trust Zersch and think we should look elsewhere today. Who else can we pressure into a claim so Spin can get that bingo? How about Lamps for checking in to jump in on an easy lynch, only to pull the "I'll catch up later" when he heard someone claimed it.

Easy lynch what lol?

Josh @ 5/10/2020 8:06

Spin @ 5/10/2020 0:34 I'm not going to be around much tomorrow and I don't want a vote out there potentially causing issues when I may not be able to change it based on new information. I'll check in when I can. This also feels like a weird post but I can't pinpoint exactly why.

It's probably because it's Spin's scum tell.

Lamps @ 5/10/2020 1:25

Josh @ 5/10/2020 8:05 I also trust Zersch and think we should look elsewhere today. Who else can we pressure into a claim so Spin can get that bingo? How about Lamps for checking in to jump in on an easy lynch, only to pull the "I'll catch up later" when he heard someone claimed it. Easy lynch what lol?

I was referring to the comment you made about im317's killer losing their vote.

Josh @ 5/10/2020 1:14

Stargate @ 5/10/2020 1:11 I really am town this game. But Nav keeps sussing me. I think I suck at mafia if you guys feel confident Nav and Kyle aren't scum. Hello Star <3 I don't know enough about Kyle tbh! I feel like I kind of missed the whole point of his train so I have no real opinion on it. Nav just hasn't done anything inherently scummy and is doing some active scum-hunting which I appreciate. I don't think he's fully cleared but he's doing more work than others so I trust it for now.

Helloes!

Nav had like 4 votes when he town mayored and spared himself this round. That was after talk of Kyle potentially getting votes as a secondary option emerged. Timmah also said Nav is for sure scum

My thinking is a mafia team could be trying to protect both nav and kyle with this. It would make sense for scum to do that early so a second name could more naturally overtake Kyle tomorrow. Instead of doing it late with Kyle having the second most votes and going when nav gets spared. Plus scum would want to avoid being on a different train than Kyle in that situation, at least one that they felt would flip town.

If Herm flips non mafia, then Navs push for Herm is exactly what I think scum would do here. He has sus, the bomb thing, and could be scummy. Idk Josh! I def could be wrong on Nav and Kyle. I wouldn't be surprised by that. The way people are is still so new to me.

NaVenom @ 5/10/2020 1:22

Star all ur scum suspects are people who have called u scum ur literally just OMGUSing

Ps) if you flip mafia then i will remember this gaslighting but you could be right

I'm still catching up, but I'm hella confused now. First Nofo said he placed the trap and sees actions being done on himself. Then he said Herm placed the trap. Is that correct?

Josh @ 5/10/2020 8:27

Lamps @ 5/10/2020 1:25 Josh @ 5/10/2020 8:05 I also trust Zersch and think we should look elsewhere today. Who else can we pressure into a claim so Spin can get that bingo? How about Lamps for checking in to jump in on an easy lynch, only to pull the "I'll catch up later" when he heard someone claimed it. Easy lynch what lol? I was referring to the comment you made about im317's killer losing their vote.

It was info I'm sure was there in the 300+ posts that I wanted to know after reading the OP. Has nothing to do with going for an easy lynch, I would read the whole thread before voting anyway.

Lamps day one Herms was joking about throwing bombs. Today nofo says a bomb was placed on them. But would herm joke about this if he actually was a bomb thrower? Well, he could but only if the bombs go off at the very end of a game or when he dies. It's weird and could be a nofo lie. Or a dif person is a bomber and herm really was just joking and it's bad luck. Or Nofo is the one person who can see bombs against them from the trip wire and more bad luck.

But it just seems weird that Herm would be this person after joking in public about it. Herm's smarter than that.

Josh @ 4/10/2020 23:20

Also here is a scum list that I have put more or less no thought into before I go since I have missed most of the night playing games. TOWN Josh, cutest townie ever <3 LEAN TOWN Christian Nav Stargate Brian Zersch Nofo NEUTRAL Farlig Moose Curtis Vern Timmah Penner Kyle LEAN SCUM Spin Herm Shadow Mittens Lamps Mal SCUM Jackie ZacharyB

well fuck my drag I guess

Timmah @ 4/10/2020 18:26

Not going to lie, nofo's claimed role makes no sense to me. He put a trap in front of himself that tells him the role of anyone that targets him, but only gets "sprung" in the case of a kill attempt on him at which time I guess it blocks the kill? Those different parts of the role claim don't really mesh.

ok and this 100000%

Nofo is making zero sense. Unless i'm just not following what hes trying to say.

The trap tells him what actions happen... but the trap didnt go off.... but he knows a bomb was placed at his place... and he can move the trap to other people still??

i.... i just dont know LOL. I feel like this is a weird way to get people not to visit him?

Shadow @ 4/10/2020 19:20

Oh that proves that he def killed him. ##lynch Zersch I think he feels backed in a corner and is forced to convey he’s the vig here. There’s 2/3 chance he is sk or mafia. Sorry Zersch ilu this just feels rational to me

This also makes zero sense and is scummy af imo.

Why would a sk or mafia member out themselves for the 317 kill just bc they know their vote wont show up?? thats.... ridiculous.

I believe Timmah here, so with Nav pushing Herm, I think Herm is town LOL.

I'm most sus of Shadow right now, and would probably put my vote there.

Stars theory of kyle/nav both being scum could be correct.... but ok question. I thought Town Mayor like nominated 2 ppl only to be lynched or something. no?