Curtis @ 3/12/2018 11:02

Hey Nav how dope would it have been if you had just used your fake role. Especially on Lamps the night we were all asking you to Imagine that!

Can we move past this? I choose to approach my role differently than what you would have done. I stand by my decision to not use it because I was going to nominate Kat and Lamps until she claimed. And Lamps could just as easily had been some other town role instead of Mafia Strongman. We hadn't heard nearly enough from him to draw a reasonable inference.

JJ @ 3/12/2018 20:06

Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n

If Ahoda isn't killed tonight, he's definitely scum so Y.

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06

Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n

Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town.

I mean, the same argument could be used against me I suppose.

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town.

I already did.

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:12

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town. I already did.

So in that scenario, the remaining scum are Z and Herm only?

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:12

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:12 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town. I already did. So in that scenario, the remaining scum are Z and Herm only?

If you're really town then yes.

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:24

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:12 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:12 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town. I already did. So in that scenario, the remaining scum are Z and Herm only? If you're really town then yes.

So mafia started with only 6?

I think you're married to the idea that all the remaining scum are in Z, Herm, Ahoda and I.

And if that's the case then yes lynching Ahoda makes sense.

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:25

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:24 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:12 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:12 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town. I already did. So in that scenario, the remaining scum are Z and Herm only? If you're really town then yes. So mafia started with only 6?

5 have flipped

inb4 parrot

Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:25

JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:24 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:12 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:12 Sebclops @ 3/12/2018 14:10 JJ @ 3/12/2018 11:06 Herm, Zersch, Nav - would you lynch Ahoda? y/n Only if you can give me a scenario where Town doesn't lose if Ahoda is Town. I already did. So in that scenario, the remaining scum are Z and Herm only? If you're really town then yes. So mafia started with only 6?

Not if Ahoda and/or Herm are mafia ... with Zersch.

5 flipped so if there are 2 left (or 3 which is a lot if it includes a DV), then they started with 7/8.

Oh only scum as in one is mafia and one is SK?

I’d be shocked if there’s only two overall scum left. I think two mafia and SK

Curtis @ 3/12/2018 14:30

inb4 parrot

nailed it

Both Herm and Z can't be Mafia because one of them is SK

If you keep operating under the assumption that I am SK then your starting point itself is inaccurate