Herm @ 15/4/2017 17:28

Vic @ 15/4/2017 23:25 I meant how does my role makes sense for a member of the mafia Gravedigger is in direct conflict with Aries's Watcher role imo, since they're both information gathering roles.

has he given us any info at all that wasn't already public knowledge or unverifiable and super easy to fake?

Although I'd rather lynch Timmah today, unless the SK can't possibly be a bomb man.

im317 @ 15/4/2017 14:30

Herm @ 15/4/2017 17:28 Vic @ 15/4/2017 23:25 I meant how does my role makes sense for a member of the mafia Gravedigger is in direct conflict with Aries's Watcher role imo, since they're both information gathering roles. has he given us any info at all that wasn't already public knowledge or unverifiable and super easy to fake?

No.

I'll get back to you once I've looked over Vic's posts today. I'm probably gonna have to skip some of the pages for now and just look at im317, Vic, Timmah.

Christian @ 15/4/2017 14:23

If Cherry is not SK, it's someone who's been priming people to go boom or down in flames.

Theres no evidence of that and no one has claimed a counter role to that type of SK. Seems unlikely.

Vic @ 15/4/2017 20:06

I visited primate He visited Christian, Spin, Wikey, Helios

This seems like legit role info.

Can you tell us which order, or did you already do that and I missed it?

He says he gets them in random order.

But Primate told us everything he did, and left a clue for visiting Helios that someone deduced iirc.

Vic, list all your actions.

Who did you graveyard each night, and why did you graveyard them. Also, what information from each night you got for us?

I looked back and only found the Primate info.

I'm getting sleepy so I'm scum hunting on 50% of half of my full strength rn.

im317, how does your role make sense with bulletproof roles like Angi or Timmah in the game?

Timmah

For a lot of the last day and a half I was starting to think Angi was GF. I didn't originally because her claim didn't cc me exactly, and because nothing she posted sounded like she knew that her group tried to kill me. To make sure it is clear, she claimed she can choose when to be BP, While I started the game with two heart containers. With Chris' flip, I am back to thinking we are both town. I know I am, anyway.

The end of this part of Tim's post feels weird to me, I find it weird that he thinks both him and Angi could be town. He's rightfully suspicious of im317's claim tho.

Those three roles are not all town imo, not with me, Nofo, Farlig and TIB with our other protective roles.

Yeah all the information that Vic said had already been mentioned by Primate.

Herm @ 15/4/2017 14:47

Timmah For a lot of the last day and a half I was starting to think Angi was GF. I didn't originally because her claim didn't cc me exactly, and because nothing she posted sounded like she knew that her group tried to kill me. To make sure it is clear, she claimed she can choose when to be BP, While I started the game with two heart containers. With Chris' flip, I am back to thinking we are both town. I know I am, anyway. The end of this part of Tim's post feels weird to me, I find it weird that he thinks both him and Angi could be town. He's rightfully suspicious of im317's claim tho. Those three roles are not all town imo, not with me, Nofo, Farlig and TIB with our other protective roles.

Why couldn't they both be?

If Cherry flips as SK then it is likely they are both town.

Vic had to have used his roles the other nights, though. He's lynching himself too which seems to indiicate caught scum so that's a bit weird.

im317 never once considered timmah or angi to be SK, but he went straight for Cherry, and then he went for VIc.

I guess Timmah could be town. Vic and im317 are much more sketchy.

Based purely on behaviours today, Vic seems the most guilty. Sorry Vic. And lynching yourself doesn't make me want to help you get out of the jam you're in. I couldn't anyway.

Vic (6) - Timmah, Zersch, Spin, Cherry, im317, Angi, Vic
im317 (2) - Jamie, Angi, Herm
Cherry (1) - DS, im317
Timmah (0) - Zersch, Vic, Herm