The rule of thumb here on FE is that there is an SK, Lamps and other people have been defending him without taking an SK into account all fucking day, and it really fucking reeks of scum.

People argue that JC can't be taken down by scum so it must've been the Vig.

That's mostly where the No-SK thing comes from.

Mercator @ 28/4/2016 16:53

The rule of thumb here on FE is that there is an SK, Lamps and other people have been defending him without taking an SK into account all fucking day, and it really fucking reeks of scum.

I believe it was mentioned.

I think we most likely had Mafia/SK kills last night. Not sure we have a Vigilante for sure, or if they were blocked, or some other reason for a missing kill.

Vigilantes usually doesn't go out to kill on the first night.

Anyway, I guess we'll find out tonight and see if there's 2 or 3 kill attempts.

I mean, sometimes they do, it depends on the player but it isn't necessarily a must.

Herm @ 28/4/2016 18:10

I mean, sometimes they do, it depends on the player but it isn't necessarily a must.

JC went full retard on D1. If I was vig I would have taken him out as well. If he didn't do that then I wouldn't fall on the side of "it was mos likely a vig hit"

I suppose an SK wanting to look vig would take out JC

Buffy @ 28/4/2016 12:07

Nofo of December 2015 @ 28/4/2016 14:06 Buffy why did you visit thisisbad last night I didn't.

why not??

I don't fully buy the lamps claim, but i agree with others it seems easily provable in the next day or two. no issue letting him live.

I mean, letting a known/probable scum live when they are caught never seems to backfire.

And once again, people pulling in other games gets annoying. People talking about doc protecting - that's on the mod. It might have never happened before, doesn't have anything to do with this game.

(but since it was brought up, i've been doc once, i could self protect. )

##lynch badger

i'm ok with an inactive this early.

thisisbad @ 28/4/2016 15:46

I don't fully buy the lamps claim, but i agree with others it seems easily provable in the next day or two. no issue letting him live. I mean, letting a known/probable scum live when they are caught never seems to backfire. And once again, people pulling in other games gets annoying. People talking about doc protecting - that's on the mod. It might have never happened before, doesn't have anything to do with this game. (but since it was brought up, i've been doc once, i could self protect. )

How is it easily provable?

If he's scum it's easy to fake it, and we can never rule out mafia JOAT?

Could he actually be a small potato lamp?

## unlynch
## lynch Eben

Not sure I like this Lamps lynch.

Since no one wants to lynch scummy Vlady, I'll switch to

##unlynch


##lynch Badger

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 15:53

Angi @ 28/4/2016 14:38 Nothing Vlady says makes sense, that's why I expected more from you ;) I'll say it nice and slow, so everyone can understand, even chris, who is trying to lynch the mod again. Someone survives an attack. This could mean they are a BG or a GG, but it makes sense, given that this is the only info anybody has to try to figure this out. That person implies that mafia attacked them, because the vig "clearly" killed JC. Now, you would expect people's reactions to be either "What- we need more info? How do you know the vig took out JC?" or "That sounds liker a load of BS!" Instead we have a group of people who go "Oh shit, the JC killed by vig makes total sense" despite the fact that there is absolutely no information to lead someone to this conclusion. Now if someone has information that will lead me to believe that JC was killed by the vig and thus Lamps was targeted by mafia, I am more than happy to vote someone else. But until then, Lamps defense has been pretty weak, involving stuff like "Lamps is likely to be targeted N1, so the doctor would have tried to save him." Wouldn't that also have lead scum to steer clear of him? I feel like every defense of Lamps, including his own, has been a big WIFOM meta game, yet if I bring in situations from another game, I shouldn't?

Geez, I was making a joke