Lamps @ 26/3/2021 1:00

Mafia RB candidates: Herm IM Poisoner candidates: Herm IM Timmah Timmah is 100% not the mafia and i believe he is genuine overall. Maddie can’t be either.

what if Stargate was town role blocker and Maddie lied about being blocked night 1? if Timmah is 100% not mafia then why am i? i was a key vote on both Ahoda and Curtis and i pushed for Gmaj to be shot.

How is 3. a reason the mafia RB == Herm?

im317 @ 26/3/2021 18:27

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 1:00 Mafia RB candidates: Herm IM Poisoner candidates: Herm IM Timmah Timmah is 100% not the mafia and i believe he is genuine overall. Maddie can’t be either. what if Stargate was town role blocker and Maddie lied about being blocked night 1? if Timmah is 100% not mafia then why am i? i was a key vote on both Ahoda and Curtis and i pushed for Gmaj to be shot.

It's you or Herm. Timmah is 100% not mafia.

I have a few more minutes to spare, so let's get this out of the way right away. I'll try to reach out to the players who are most likely town!

Maddie

Vibes, and also process of elimination. I know I'm town. TIB is proven town. Herm is mostly likely town or has a good claim. That leaves you and Lamps. And IM317. That's our pool.

There's at least one scumplayer here who kicked me out of the most likely town category and jumped in front of the line. You thought I was most likely town, and now you think I'm likely scum. Whatever made you change your mind about this, question it because you started out being correct and now you're listening to someone who's either wrong or is scum. I'm town and have been town since the start. :)

Spin

He's mafia, and Stargate was probably the Poison Doctor (if one even existed). Herm, if he is the poison doctor, didn't mention anything at all on D1 to even hint at the fact that poison might be in play. If I got a strangely specific role like that, I'd think I'd at least hint to it being a possibility early in the game. He's probably the last mafia member, and chose to kill last night instead of Roleblock (probably his original role).

I didn't think about that on D1. I mean, I actually wish I had thought about that now.

I couldn't exactly predict a janitor coming into play tbh. If you had time to look into what I'm trying to say a bit more, and not just focus on my awful voting record or how I didn't crumb my role precisely, I would really appreciate it lol. :)

Alright, so Lamps is back on the case.

I'm glad you're figuring me out a bit more!

TIB, you're probably an undecided voter at this point and have been for most of the day, but please listen to Lamps and don't lynch me PLEASE lol. :)

Spin @ 26/3/2021 19:20

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:20 Spin @ 26/3/2021 18:19 Timmah isn't the mafia RB, because Herm is. And if he isn't? I'd be shocked.

I'M BEING FRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMED LOL.

It's easy to frame me though, so I'm not giving scum all the credit.

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:28

How is 3. a reason the mafia RB == Herm?

Because if Herm is the last mafia member, he chose to kill last night instead of roleblocking someone.

Herm if you are somehow the poisoner and just need one more kill to win just admit it.


I said it before you claimed that it would be convenient for all your crumbs to come after night 1

Herm @ 26/3/2021 12:29

I didn't think about that on D1. I mean, I actually wish I had thought about that now. I couldn't exactly predict a janitor coming into play tbh. If you had time to look into what I'm trying to say a bit more, and not just focus on my awful voting record or how I didn't crumb my role precisely, I would really appreciate it lol. :)

I'm actually presenting the case in lieu of your voting record. Your voting record is just the cherry on top of the sundae.

Spin @ 26/3/2021 18:35

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:28 How is 3. a reason the mafia RB == Herm? Because if Herm is the last mafia member, he chose to kill last night instead of roleblocking someone.

Replace Herm by IM and the sentence is still true.

(I honestly think they’re both scum and Timmah is vt, just im a bit more likely scum)

So why isn't timmah possible poisoner

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:37

Spin @ 26/3/2021 18:35 Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:28 How is 3. a reason the mafia RB == Herm? Because if Herm is the last mafia member, he chose to kill last night instead of roleblocking someone. Replace Herm by IM and the sentence is still true. (I honestly think they’re both scum and Timmah is vt, just im a bit more likely scum)

This would require there to be an actual poison doctor. Making a SK a poisoner is already putting them at a disadvantage, but then to also throw a poison doctor into the mix? Come on, you are smarter than this.

Sk needs 25% in penner games? They killed 2 ppl now

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:38

Sk needs 25% in penner games? They killed 2 ppl now

Which means they need 5. They are no where near their secondary win condition.

(He also took that 25% thing from me, along with just about all the other rules)

Spin @ 26/3/2021 18:38

Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:37 Spin @ 26/3/2021 18:35 Lamps @ 26/3/2021 12:28 How is 3. a reason the mafia RB == Herm? Because if Herm is the last mafia member, he chose to kill last night instead of roleblocking someone. Replace Herm by IM and the sentence is still true. (I honestly think they’re both scum and Timmah is vt, just im a bit more likely scum) This would require there to be an actual poison doctor. Making a SK a poisoner is already putting them at a disadvantage, but then to also throw a poison doctor into the mix? Come on, you are smarter than this.

I agree that a poison doctor is unlikely. But Herm could be poisoner himself right?