Every post from Zersch feels much more like genuine town than it does as frustrated scum. I think it’s entirely possible to have multiple roles with multiple abilities. Lamps had three power roles in one and to think there aren’t any other roles like that is really silly. Is everyone else a TV? Like nah b, that’s crazy talk. Lamps also didn’t have one shot abilities (iirc) where i’d assume Z has five one shot abilities?

If Jackie isn’t a viable option, I’d move to one of Curtis Cody Zach off the top of my head.

One of my bigger hold up, which nobody has bothered to engage me about besides Zersch, is why Nav’s role allowed for self-protection but Z’s didnt?

Doesn’t strike anyone else as weird?

Would also help if im317 provided clarity on how often he can kill. If it’s a one-shot, would make Zersch’s claim much more legit.

Towny
Jamie
Timmah
Zersch
im317
Spin
TIB

Penner&Rodney
Penner
Rodney

Neutral but kinda town
Brian
Mal
Matt
Kyle

True Neutral
Reaper
farlig

Neutral but kinda scum
Maddie
Perry

Scummy
Zach
Curtis
Cody
Jackie


This is kinda where i’m at rn

jamie @ 6/9/2020 16:12

Every post from Zersch feels much more like genuine town than it does as frustrated scum. I think it’s entirely possible to have multiple roles with multiple abilities. Lamps had three power roles in one and to think there aren’t any other roles like that is really silly. Is everyone else a TV? Like nah b, that’s crazy talk. Lamps also didn’t have one shot abilities (iirc) where i’d assume Z has five one shot abilities?

Lamps roles were in fact one shot

Pen Newton @ 6/9/2020 16:14

One of my bigger hold up, which nobody has bothered to engage me about besides Zersch, is why Nav’s role allowed for self-protection but Z’s didnt? Doesn’t strike anyone else as weird?

no

Malion 🌟 @ 6/9/2020 16:19

jamie @ 6/9/2020 16:12 Every post from Zersch feels much more like genuine town than it does as frustrated scum. I think it’s entirely possible to have multiple roles with multiple abilities. Lamps had three power roles in one and to think there aren’t any other roles like that is really silly. Is everyone else a TV? Like nah b, that’s crazy talk. Lamps also didn’t have one shot abilities (iirc) where i’d assume Z has five one shot abilities? Lamps roles were in fact one shot

o ok well nvm on that part but i still think there are multiple one shot roles out there like lamps/zersch

Pen Newton @ 6/9/2020 16:15

Would also help if im317 provided clarity on how often he can kill. If it’s a one-shot, would make Zersch’s claim much more legit.

i don’t like the idea of 317 outing how often he can kill

I agree there can be some roles with multiples. But right now we are looking at THREE roles with possible 1-shit killing roles for town (lamps mittens now Z) and then a town Vig? That just seems like too much?

jamie @ 6/9/2020 15:12

Every post from Zersch feels much more like genuine town than it does as frustrated scum. I think it’s entirely possible to have multiple roles with multiple abilities. Lamps had three power roles in one and to think there aren’t any other roles like that is really silly. Is everyone else a TV? Like nah b, that’s crazy talk. Lamps also didn’t have one shot abilities (iirc) where i’d assume Z has five one shot abilities?

Yes, five one-shot abilities.

I forgot Reaper was playing

Thisisbad @ 6/9/2020 16:23

I forgot Reaper was playing

i originally has reaper in a category as “forgot they were playing” but changed it to a neutral category

jamie @ 6/9/2020 15:19

Pen Newton @ 6/9/2020 16:14 One of my bigger hold up, which nobody has bothered to engage me about besides Zersch, is why Nav’s role allowed for self-protection but Z’s didnt? Doesn’t strike anyone else as weird? no

Exactly. Having the exact same characteristics of a role helps scum. Making it variable gives the edge back to town.

Cody @ 6/9/2020 16:22

I agree there can be some roles with multiples. But right now we are looking at THREE roles with possible 1-shit killing roles for town (lamps mittens now Z) and then a town Vig? That just seems like too much?

idk if 317 is a full vig but i also don’t think he should be outing how often he can kill unless it was one shot and he used it but even then, i don’t want to give scum that info