I did think you came across as town tib earlier this game though.

Lamps @ 10/8/2019 2:40

Kk well with Primate never going to confirm, this is where I stand. Normally Primate would have watched Rod, and I am just going to assume he would have seen Cody there. It is a bad claim to make when it can easily be disproven. There is a possibility that Cody has some powerful scum role with this handicap to compensate. Have seen that before. It’s possible. But i am going to assume that what he said about the ability is true.

Fuck man, Primate could have cleared me.

I still believe cody.

So abt yesterday.

Either Rodney was hiding behind me, because I drew all actions.
Or my action didn’t affect him which means he was hiding behind someone else.

Still there is no explanation for all the unsuccessfuls.

Cavin as SK doesn’t make much sense btw since we had 2 kills N1 with Ahoda blocked, and he said he was unsuccessful (which may be a lie, but doesn’t really look like one).

So then do all of you voters think he is mafia?

Primate @ 9/8/2019 21:09

I fucked up I was gonna watch Rodney, but apparently forgot to hit send on my pm. In other news I woke up next to a robot who looked just like me. He left after I woke up. Maybe I fucked myself? After that the mod told me I've been poisoned and will die by end of day.

I'm so glad I signed up for this

Rodney the maf kill and Ahoda the SK kill?

Given how much fuckery we've seen going on during the night phases, why does everyone seem so ready to take their results from last night at face value?

I find myself believing Cavin, his defence feels very genuine to me and my gut feeling is that he is telling the truth.

But his claim is iffy. Very iffy. If Farlig is an even night Doctor only then I may actually buy it. Farlig hasn't confirmed doctor at all, only hinted strongly at it.

The amount of deaths last night bugs me, especially when combined with the poisonings today. This can't be the usual intended amount of kills per phase, otherwise this would be a very short game, so I'm guessing a lot of one shot powers were used last night.

That, or Rodney really did die hiding behind someone. Hell, have we considered that Rodney hid behind someone he thought was town last night and died because they turned out to be scum?

^I need to stop forgetting Rodney was even night only. Fucking disregard above

The last paragraph anyway

Yeah and Farlig confirmed doctor.

I don't take Penner's result at face value either, it must have been very obvious to scum that he had to be vig or tracker.

I prefer to lynch Herm or maybe TIB, mayyybe Josh or Nav.

Doc + BG is not unlikely. Doc is ALWAYS in the game, so that would imply Bodyguard is never used. It is used. What gives me pause is the thing Primate talked about. But Doc + BG is not unlikely.

Question for Penner: Were you told it was Cavin specifically that you saw visit Rodney, or did it just say 'your target'?

If Cavin wasn't specifically named, I'd be willing to bet that Lamps is onto something and you were potentially redirected.

Imo it helps if Nav fully claims, he's let out so much info that it shouldn't matter. We're also kinda at a point where we're losing so many townies that mislynching would not feel comfortable. This comes from someone who hates claims but yeah :/

Oh right that is true about Cavin. The BG claim is really not something you'd give scum much info with when claiming. Like who cares. And it is a typical scum claim. Still, I may prefer lynching Herm today.

The only thing about the Penner redirect theory is that it would mean that a scum redirector either:

1: Willingly redirected Penner to one of their scummates who killed Rodney, in the hopes that he would track a townie.

or

2: Redirected him to one of the SK's, either on purpose or accidentally

Scenario 1 seems unlikely and risky. 2 is possible.