vladykins @ 6/3/2017 7:04

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 22:04 I also missed Rose. I think she's town. Now I need to go back- did Rose have the gun or not?

No

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 8:23

Rose- Nofo blocked you N1. If im317 hadn't said the gun came from Tinky Winky, I'd have you on the scum side right now.

Oh no how awful.

Nofo apparently accidentally blocks me. Im317 accidentally finds a gun at my house. Lurch doesn't realize what kind of claim he's being asked for. And you decide to use all those mishaps to try to brush just the littlest suspicion on me, as someone who is all but proven town. Alright.

I'm not sure where the jokester thing came from. I don't joke around! Well I do. But not as a role!

farlig @ 6/3/2017 7:25

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:17 Crazy theory time: Rose confirmed Lurchy as town through the neighbor stuff, Rose was RBed N1 when there was a missing kill, and Lurchy has been nearly non-existent except when he delayed the confirmation of them as neighbors. His explanation: Quote I'm here. Just got to the first couple mentions of me/Rose on like page 12. Trying to catch up. D1. I asked in what context was the question because I was trying to stall. I was also trying to catch up on 42 pages of mafia in FE and xx pages of mafia in FFA at the same time. I know, keep game in game, but any of the FFA guys will tell ya, I didn't even sign in over there until after I was killed in that game. Anyway, I just wanted to see what was revealed by Rose, exactly how, what the reaction was, etc, before I confirmed anything because obv I didn't want to blow a good thing. And yes, this is a pretty cool role(s) to have. I confirm, we are neighbors, neighbors with benefits. Rose is the power bottom though. Let's just be clear about that from the start! What if Rose and Lurchy are a killing team? Knowing we've only killed one mafia and probably have at least one missing killer this theory has some legs.

This makes a lot of sense. We've had a lot of unclaimed kills each night. Christian and I both thought they were sus D1, but then DS' "messy" night got us off the trail. Wouldn't mind putting some pressure in that direction now.

##lynch rose

Grunkle Drrr @ 6/3/2017 9:30

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 7:04 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 22:04 I also missed Rose. I think she's town. Now I need to go back- did Rose have the gun or not? No vladykins @ 6/3/2017 8:23 Rose- Nofo blocked you N1. If im317 hadn't said the gun came from Tinky Winky, I'd have you on the scum side right now. Oh no how awful. Nofo apparently accidentally blocks me. Im317 accidentally finds a gun at my house. Lurch doesn't realize what kind of claim he's being asked for. And you decide to use all those mishaps to try to brush just the littlest suspicion on me, as someone who is all but proven town. Alright.

Nofo may have accidentally blocked you, but we're still missing an attack from that night. And we only have Lurchy to confirm you as town (and he did it a bit oddly).

Frankly, we could lynch Lurchy and confirm you as town, right? He's contributing just about nothing to the game right now. I'm at least trying to scum hunt between people pointing their fingers at me.

JohnnyDollar @ 6/3/2017 9:35

This makes a lot of sense. We've had a lot of unclaimed kills each night. Christian and I both thought they were sus D1, but then DS' "messy" night got us off the trail. Wouldn't mind putting some pressure in that direction now. ##lynch rose

Personally, I'd rather go Lurchy. Rose is active and his flip clears or condemns her.

You could! But he's town, so I don't even remotely agree with that idea. Once one of us dies, the other is confirmed. I'm not in a rush to make that happen, and someone trying to MAKE that happen based on a crackpot theory and two hosting errors feels INCREDIBLY scummy to me!

I think that theory is bad

What's really interesting is the number of "confirmed" town we have, but mafia and SK seem too be staying away from them. I would assume Jamie would be watched at least once if there was a watcher ability out there, but when IM popped his information, a smart watcher would have flipped there, giving mafia or SK a clean shot at some of these confirmed townies.

If I was mafia, I'd have made a hit already on Jamie, Buffy, or part of the Rose/Lurchy pair. Ahoda picking Lamps is something I would have done too, since it silences and then kills someone with good reads early on. I kind of wish Lamps was around to give an opinion on me. :(

Grunkle Drrr @ 6/3/2017 9:39

You could! But he's town, so I don't even remotely agree with that idea. Once one of us dies, the other is confirmed. I'm not in a rush to make that happen, and someone trying to MAKE that happen based on a crackpot theory and two hosting errors feels INCREDIBLY scummy to me!

You seem to desperately want to keep an inactive Lurchy. You trying to play up the hosting error for RBing you is also interesting- brian may have screwed up the target, but not the results.

Your reaction is noted.

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:42

Grunkle Drrr @ 6/3/2017 9:39 You could! But he's town, so I don't even remotely agree with that idea. Once one of us dies, the other is confirmed. I'm not in a rush to make that happen, and someone trying to MAKE that happen based on a crackpot theory and two hosting errors feels INCREDIBLY scummy to me! You seem to desperately want to keep an inactive Lurchy. You trying to play up the hosting error for RBing you is also interesting- brian may have screwed up the target, but not the results. Your reaction is noted.

Oh no what will I do.

Of course I want to keep lurchy. That isn't even a question for me. He's active enough to post every day, and I KNOW FOR A FACT THAT HE IS TOWN.

It's not suspicious. It's smart pro-town gameplay.

Vladdy how do you feel about Primate? He seems to be convinced that you are town.

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:40

What's really interesting is the number of "confirmed" town we have, but mafia and SK seem too be staying away from them. I would assume Jamie would be watched at least once if there was a watcher ability out there, but when IM popped his information, a smart watcher would have flipped there, giving mafia or SK a clean shot at some of these confirmed townies. If I was mafia, I'd have made a hit already on Jamie, Buffy, or part of the Rose/Lurchy pair. Ahoda picking Lamps is something I would have done too, since it silences and then kills someone with good reads early on. I kind of wish Lamps was around to give an opinion on me. :(

If you were mafia you'd target part of the Rose/Lurchy pair? Wait, I thought you just said Rose could be responsible for a kill but now you sound like you believe she's town. Which is it?

Also, Lamps read on D2 was me - he hasn't been so great at his reads this game. :P

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:40

You seem to desperately want to keep an inactive Lurchy. You trying to play up the hosting error for RBing you is also interesting- brian may have screwed up the target, but not the results. Your reaction is noted.

This is irritating me lol. She KNOWS he's town - obviously she's not proven but I believe her. Why wouldn't she want to keep him? This is not the time to go after inactives, especially if you have reason to believe they're town. But not inactives just for the sake of it - plus he's posted just isn't a serial poster like some people. ;)

Grunkle Drrr @ 6/3/2017 9:44

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:42 Grunkle Drrr @ 6/3/2017 9:39 You could! But he's town, so I don't even remotely agree with that idea. Once one of us dies, the other is confirmed. I'm not in a rush to make that happen, and someone trying to MAKE that happen based on a crackpot theory and two hosting errors feels INCREDIBLY scummy to me! You seem to desperately want to keep an inactive Lurchy. You trying to play up the hosting error for RBing you is also interesting- brian may have screwed up the target, but not the results. Your reaction is noted. Oh no what will I do. Of course I want to keep lurchy. That isn't even a question for me. He's active enough to post every day, and I KNOW FOR A FACT THAT HE IS TOWN. It's not suspicious. It's smart pro-town gameplay.

Active? Have you looked at his three posts from yesterday? His seven form the day before (a couple of which were related to the "Oh yeah, we're both town" aspect). TBQH, I'm not sure we can handle the usefulness he's brought to the table with his bacon/sulphuric acid post.

JohnnyDollar @ 6/3/2017 9:35

farlig @ 6/3/2017 7:25 vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:17 Crazy theory time: Rose confirmed Lurchy as town through the neighbor stuff, Rose was RBed N1 when there was a missing kill, and Lurchy has been nearly non-existent except when he delayed the confirmation of them as neighbors. His explanation: Quote I'm here. Just got to the first couple mentions of me/Rose on like page 12. Trying to catch up. D1. I asked in what context was the question because I was trying to stall. I was also trying to catch up on 42 pages of mafia in FE and xx pages of mafia in FFA at the same time. I know, keep game in game, but any of the FFA guys will tell ya, I didn't even sign in over there until after I was killed in that game. Anyway, I just wanted to see what was revealed by Rose, exactly how, what the reaction was, etc, before I confirmed anything because obv I didn't want to blow a good thing. And yes, this is a pretty cool role(s) to have. I confirm, we are neighbors, neighbors with benefits. Rose is the power bottom though. Let's just be clear about that from the start! What if Rose and Lurchy are a killing team? Knowing we've only killed one mafia and probably have at least one missing killer this theory has some legs. This makes a lot of sense. We've had a lot of unclaimed kills each night. Christian and I both thought they were sus D1, but then DS' "messy" night got us off the trail. Wouldn't mind putting some pressure in that direction now. ##lynch rose

OMGUS SO MUCH and I wish I could lynch 5 people today, including you.