Yes

cool so either we take a chance on herm or on angie

or we go with who seems most scum right now, and thats im317

Darren Sanders @ 4/12/2016 16:31

cool so either we take a chance on herm or on angie or we go with who seems most scum right now, and thats im317

Make a case for im317

Darren Sanders @ 4/12/2016 17:31

cool so either we take a chance on herm or on angie or we go with who seems most scum right now, and thats im317

Or you can pull your head out of your ass and lynch the mafia role cop ;)


Have you ever seen a town cop get role flavor? No. that's Calle mafia cop. Maddie scum slipped

Ok catching up...skimming though so I might be missing stuff.

Question: Why are we assuming that one of Ahoda's Christmas carolers could be scum? Isn't it just as plausible that it's a meaningless flavor role?

Also, Herm was quick to throw a lynch on Maddie

Something is weird with Maddie's claim. She kept giving us bits at a time, and we had to ask her to clarify things. She said she investigated Wikey, and said he was Vanilla Town, but she only received the word 'vanilla' as her clue. So she either is a role/flavour cop, or her scum team has a role/flavour cop that scanned Wikey and she's using that info to have Wikey back her up or maybe try to get the real cop to counter claim? Maybe I'm not on the right track at all.

I think one of the three (Maddie, Herm, Angi) needs to be lynched today.

Herm would be my second choice, but Angi always plays the same way whether she's town or scum.

Herm says he has a way out of this. So he can prove something to clear himself maybe?
Angi said she had info originally, but has since said it's not that vital to be known yet.

anyone know the current vote count?
I have to leave in about 5-10 minutes, I won't be back before deadline.

Gut feeling: Herm immediately lynching one of the carolers is sketchy. I would be down for a vote on him.

Maddie specifically claimed Town Cop, but what she has described sounds more like a Role Cop. And Role Cop could deffo be a scum role.

But...it's possible with this being Maddie's second game she wasn't aware of the difference between Role Cop/Alignment Cop. Also, would a Mafia role cop have wasted a scan on me last night, given I contributed jack shit to the days proceedings?

That's my two cents. UNTIL NEXT TIME FOLKS

Christian @ 4/12/2016 15:41

anyone know the current vote count? I have to leave in about 5-10 minutes, I won't be back before deadline.

Last count was post 302 (not at my comp right now) - I think the only changes was an unlynch by angi and a vote for maddie by im317 (or someone else). I'll post another updated list when I get home in a bit.

I think Maddie's got 4 or 5 lynch votes. I should be back down to 1 after im317 switched.

This is just the lynch vote count, I think it's correct.

Vote Count
Maddie [5] - Herm, ????, Ahoda, Mittens, Angi, Helios, Vern, DS, im317
Herm [1] - Mittens, im317, Angi
TIB [1] - vlady
im317 [1] - Timmah
Angi [0] - Vern

Wikey @ 4/12/2016 16:24

Just kidding. However, I am an expert in the field of alien anal probes, and this is a textbook case. I would venture that Maddie is an alien role cop. DO NOT PHYSICALLY CHALLENGE HER

ugh. why would you do that? at this point im keeping my vote, i don't like how Maddie has gone about giving her info.

Maddie's behaviour doesn't suggest Town to me, but it's her second game, so I'm not sure how to read that.