I'm calling bullshit on Panda's claim. I don't believe for 5 seconds that there would be a THIRD protection role and one as OP as making someone BP for the rest of the game.

Actually, now I noticed in Dylan's second description that the third party can send him out to kill, so I guess the third party can kill someone at night, but if he was recruited that night, then I guess the third party selected a recruiting option instead of a killing option.



Dylan was also the reason why we had the ???? lynch vote coming out of nowhere? Unless he had to steal a person's vote at night.

Wikey White @ 13/4/2014 8:37

##Lynch: Greenday Despite my speculation about Curtis, I am not sure he would try to get another player mod killed. Tim was doing a good job of getting there himself regardless of any outside influence. Greenday came on as quite forceful over the DR lynch. He kind of just repeated the same thing. "You could be a liar, so I am lynching you." Not exactly a ground breaking case. Mafia would have definitely seen an easy lynch here.

That's wasn't the entire basis of my case. If you truly read the entire thing you'd see that I was also basing it off of her defensiveness, the point others brought up about what already flipped, and the weird claim. I still call bullshit on Panda's claim that he saved her. Seems like a scumsave to me.

Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 13/4/2014 8:53

I'm calling bullshit on Panda's claim. I don't believe for 5 seconds that there would be a THIRD protection role and one as OP as making someone BP for the rest of the game.

Maybe Panda is Giles and made Rose Buffy lol?

I missed the whole Jordan lynch cuz of the Go Daddy shit, so I missed the ???

Greenday, why would Panda come out and lie like that so early in the game? It doesnt' clear Rose of being scum, just clears her of being bullet proof in a way.

Angi @ 13/4/2014 9:04

I missed the whole Jordan lynch cuz of the Go Daddy shit, so I missed the ??? Greenday, why would Panda come out and lie like that so early in the game? It doesnt' clear Rose of being scum, just clears her of being bullet proof in a way.

Because when he claimed it was at a time where Rose was the prime suspect and it wasn't showing signs of slowing anytime soon.

## unlynch

Well, I still think it's possible that someone who jumped on the Rose train could be scum vampire. She was the most suspicious at the time so I don't think it's strange. And I don't think Panda was lying about her role. If it's a lie it's a pretty risky lie. But I dunno, he was drunk lol.

Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 13/4/2014 9:53

I'm calling bullshit on Panda's claim. I don't believe for 5 seconds that there would be a THIRD protection role and one as OP as making someone BP for the rest of the game.

One set of doctors had to both be alive to function as doctors. Dylan ran the risk of getting his target killed should he be the one attacked instead of his target. And it sounds like Perry's got a protective role that cannot ever change targets. It's hardly overpowered, and I'm fairly certain it's been used at least a few times before! If the target is lynched, or bad, or whatever else, the role goes to waste. But guardian angel/protector types are hardly rare.

It's strange that there are 3 different protection roles out there, but each of the roles has a drawback.

And I was being defensive because I had no way to defend myself! I DID NOT KNOW WHY I SURVIVED, AND THE REASON I WAS BEING LYNCHED WAS BECAUSE I SURVIVED AND COULD NOT EXPLAIN HOW.

You all know that everyone gets defensive all the time when accused in these games. So honestly, bringing up "she was defensive so she is scum" is bullshit.

Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 13/4/2014 10:10

Angi @ 13/4/2014 9:04 I missed the whole Jordan lynch cuz of the Go Daddy shit, so I missed the ??? Greenday, why would Panda come out and lie like that so early in the game? It doesnt' clear Rose of being scum, just clears her of being bullet proof in a way. Because when he claimed it was at a time where Rose was the prime suspect and it wasn't showing signs of slowing anytime soon.

It's a stupid lie to make. If Perry dies, the flip would reveal it as a lie, and then I would be lynched. If this was a scum buddy plot, it would be extremely risky because one being revealed as a liar would oust the other.

drrr @ 13/4/2014 9:28

Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 13/4/2014 10:10 Angi @ 13/4/2014 9:04 I missed the whole Jordan lynch cuz of the Go Daddy shit, so I missed the ??? Greenday, why would Panda come out and lie like that so early in the game? It doesnt' clear Rose of being scum, just clears her of being bullet proof in a way. Because when he claimed it was at a time where Rose was the prime suspect and it wasn't showing signs of slowing anytime soon. It's a stupid lie to make. If Perry dies, the flip would reveal it as a lie, and then I would be lynched. If this was a scum buddy plot, it would be extremely risky because one being revealed as a liar would oust the other.

And? If you're both scum and it saves you both for the time being, it might be a risk worth taking to keep your numbers up.

On day 2? It would be more beneficial to let me rot and jump aboard just to earn a few brownie points. If I was mafia, it would be more beneficial for the mafia to lose one member early and avoid incriminating the other members than be at an extremely high risk of losing two members at once.

Anyway I have to get some work done this morning, so I'll be back later

I don't think Perry was that drunk when he came on that he made such a faulty error in making a faulty claim that could potentially fuck two scum over if proven false. It makes the most sense for me right now that it's what actually went down. I'm not certain if Greenday is scum or not, but if we hear from him and his reasonings why Perry must be lying more it'll be easier to determine.

## lynch Greenday for now.

I guess we'll get a bunch of today with hangovers

Actually, if Panda was mafia doctor and was lying to save Rose it wouldn't be a bad claim. A risky claim, no doubt about it. But if it paid off, DR would have a neat explanation for her night survivals for the rest of the game.

Also, it does have me wondering, if DR is now supposedly BP, does that mean that there is no town BP role?

I am not asking anyone to claim. I am speculating on the possibility that is all.