Josh's reads are pretty wild to me.

How do you have Jamie in neutral when he claimed vig, for instance? Especially considering that Steph had taken credit for the previous day kill but turned out to (most likely) be SK converted to town? That would have been very ballsy for Jamie to claim if he wasn't vig, and it would have been very weird for Jamie not to be attacked by the vig in that case.

I get that his kill last night was not ideal but I would ve *very* surprised if he wasn't vig.

Also, having Rose in 'Leaning Town' when we know so little about her role or reads seems odd to me as well.

The situation matters. Kat only had 2 (at the time) no-shows to choose from and chose Maddie over lamps. Kat and Lamps turned out to be on the same team. Is it possible all 3 were on the same team? Sure, but just from a numbers standpoint it feels safe to call that unlikely. Maddie isn't cleared but I am comfortable putting her in probably not mafia tier for the time being

Penner @ 10/8/2023 8:49

Alright guess I’m getting ignored today. See ya’ll later.

Do I think rose is scum? Yes. Do I think her forgetting you on her reads was a scumslip? Probably not, but I'd vote her

My lynch vote pool for today is among these:

Stargate
Badger
Josh
Rose (sry)

Badger, you are a conundrum to me because I know that even when you're scum your posts are very thoughtful and I'm always very conflicted.

Town: Sami, Maddie, Josh, Havo, Stargate, Rose, Jamie, im317, RIP Brian and TT
Curtis and Nav: Curtis and Nav
Could be town but they've slandered me: Herm, Badger
Neutral: Farlig, Ahoda, Scúmph
Rodney: Rodney
The rest of the films cast in order of appearance: Penner
Bad vibes: Spin, Tib
Confirmed bad: Dead Lamps and Kat

gabagool @ 10/8/2023 8:52

My lynch vote pool for today is among these: Stargate Badger Josh Rose (sry)

I guess ahoda goes on that list too.


Also not sure what to make of Spin. And I guess Herm's gotta be on my list too.

Sami @ 10/8/2023 7:47

Damnit furling always auto corrects to furling

I go by garlic.

Sami @ 10/8/2023 8:54

The rest of the films cast in order of appearance: Penner

This was an intentional shot at Penner's ego

Thisisbad @ 10/8/2023 3:45

BadgerMcBeaver @ 9/8/2023 22:02 BadgerMcBeaver @ 9/8/2023 23:31 Regarding Tib/Rod, even though I have been feeling like this is town Tib, his role kind of seems more geared towards the mafia. I feel like No Lynch days in general tend to be more beneficial to scum than town. In the very late game, that's a very powerful scum role because it can buy you the precious time you need to get majority. I don't think it really does that much to benefit town though - town tends to rely upon lynches to get rid of scum because the vig can only do so much. Canceling a lynch is kind of counter productive towards what town is trying to do as a whole. Also, I think there's a lot more reason for reason for Rodney to come forward with his role if he's town than if he's scum. If he was scum, he could just say nothing for the moment and avoid getting heat for having a similar role to Tib. Also, a double vote in the late game is somewhat powerful for scum and he'd be kind of wasting it by using it so early. As town though, I don't think there's the same benefit to saving it for later because it's so easy to die at night, so I feel like he'd be more likely to use it before he gets killed during a night phase. In addition to this, Tib's logic about how mafia would have used the no-lynch to save Lamps day 1 doesn't really feel very well reasoned to me. Sure, they'd buy themselves a day by using it that way, but they also kind of 2 for 1 themselves when Lamps does end up flipping. I think most mafias would recognize that its in their best interest to let their inactive member fall by the way side rather than risk trying to save them and potentially outing themselves. This argument kind of felt like him grasping at straws and doesn't really make sense to me. I'm willing to be open to other ideas, but for now... ##lynch Tib I honestly don't know what to think about you or anyone else anymore

I do feel bad voting for you because you are one of my favorite posters here.

But also you didn't really provide an argument against any of the points I was making.

Do we want to talk about why Spin wasn’t able to give (the) head to Ahoda?

It is hard to tell if TIB is frustrated Town or frustrated scum. He is giving off frustrated vibes either way.

Penner @ 10/8/2023 8:57

Do we want to talk about why Spin wasn’t able to give (the) head to Ahoda?

I mean, good point to raise, but I don’t think we have anything else to say about it because we don’t know anything lol

Maybe Ahoda can shed some light on it. I’d also love to know more about how he knew I got the taser from Sami last night.

gabagool @ 10/8/2023 8:53

Badger, you are a conundrum to me because I know that even when you're scum your posts are very thoughtful and I'm always very conflicted.

It's all good, I shouldn't be above suspicion.

I am just happy to be alive past Night 1 tbh.