JJ @ 9/7/2018 16:47

Nav, you did lie and say you were a member of the town on Day 2.

Yes of course. Had I not lied I would have looked scummy af.

Mercator @ 9/7/2018 16:47

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 16:45 Christian @ 9/7/2018 16:40 oh, because the SK is the bigger fish and you're "small potatoes" :P that's why you're focused on me or Vlady, yet your vote isn't for either of us. How do we truly know you're not a SK or Mafia? Look at my beautiful face. Would I lie. But yeah you don't TRULY know that I'm neither SK nor Mafia. And if you DO lynch me, well I'll lose the game for one but you're not getting rid of a night kill. Which town needs to do today. And odds are much higher given what we know about the night you and vlady survived attacks that one of you is the SK. Every single of your posts smells so scummy it hurts.

Aren't you the guy who said only Mafia members would want to keep an SK around in order to thin the herd.

JJ @ 9/7/2018 19:47

Anyway I'd rather ##lynch Josh

I'm kinda thinking of going with the sure thing here, B.

Christian @ 9/7/2018 19:53

JJ @ 9/7/2018 19:47 Anyway I'd rather ##lynch Josh I'm kinda thinking of going with the sure thing here, B.

What's the sure thing for you? I'm sure you've said it a dozen times but I forget your current stance

I mean, scum is scum and Nav losing the game is kind of a bonus. :P

Dislike this post all you want. lol

this is gonna get messy isn't it

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 16:53

Mercator @ 9/7/2018 16:47 Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 16:45 Christian @ 9/7/2018 16:40 oh, because the SK is the bigger fish and you're "small potatoes" :P that's why you're focused on me or Vlady, yet your vote isn't for either of us. How do we truly know you're not a SK or Mafia? Look at my beautiful face. Would I lie. But yeah you don't TRULY know that I'm neither SK nor Mafia. And if you DO lynch me, well I'll lose the game for one but you're not getting rid of a night kill. Which town needs to do today. And odds are much higher given what we know about the night you and vlady survived attacks that one of you is the SK. Every single of your posts smells so scummy it hurts. Aren't you the guy who said only Mafia members would want to keep an SK around in order to thin the herd.

Are you talking about that game where Curtis and I were the only sane people playing?

we lynch Vlady...we get either the Town Doctor or the Serial Killer. Not likely Mafia.
we lynch Josh...we get either Town or Mafia or whatever.
we lynch Nav...we get Third Party Lyncher/Survivor or Serial Killer or Mafia.

How do we still have 3 attacks a night though?

assuming that Mafia is one and the other is the SK.

Christian @ 9/7/2018 16:54

I mean, scum is scum and Nav losing the game is kind of a bonus. :P Dislike this post all you want. lol

A scum who can't hurt town and is a number not automatically against town is not the scum you want to hit today though.

Like are you just trying to find a way to not have vlady lynched because you know that if vlady flips town doc, you're next? That's what it comes off as to me.

You already ensured I lost a game once. How much gratification do you need! RNF AS was a LOOOOOONG time ago :P

Christian @ 9/7/2018 19:54

I mean, scum is scum and Nav losing the game is kind of a bonus. :P Dislike this post all you want. lol

This is not a good look.

Christian @ 9/7/2018 16:29

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 19:21 Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 16:17 Although I can see some merit in Cultis' argument that lynching Mafia Badger's partner is a good play for today, the best play is surely nailing the SK. So any votes not on vlady/christian are somewhat suspicious to me automatically For a couple reasons. 1. IF Mafia is actually 7 people instead of 6, this doesn't cut down the # of kills at night. b. If you mislynch (and I assume you mislynch me when trying to nail a Mafia member), then Town is FUBAR gamma. Seems like SK can't be killed at night. Mafia can be. yellow. I wish I had gotten the pleasure of lynching Zachary B. what if the SK is Josh?

I don't think both you and vlady are town. Just don't think it's possible at all.

But I'll humor your what-if

If Josh is the SK, then we have to find a teammate for Mafia Badger.

I know it isn't me.

I have to assume at this point Buffy is more or less mod confirmed town.

Ahoda-Cultis are backing each other. Could they be Mafia together? Yes it's a possibility. And if that's the case then given the number of deaths we see each night we should be lynching one of them instead of Josh here if the Mafia team is Badger-Cultis-Ahoda.

Maybe it's Merc. But Merc's role is proven and Mafia RB already flipped. Merc at this point looks the next best town after Jay Jay (something that's painful to say seeing as he is so dead wrong about me)

vlady being Mafia doc is a very weak argument as well. vlady does have a point that he's been on way too many scum trains way too early to be Mafia. Possible sure but less likely than him being SK.

Then there's you. I still have reservations about you but given that the Godmother already flipped, I don't think you're Mafia. Unless you're a usurper or something. But obviously I can't convince YOU that YOU are Mafia. It's actually not something I thought of seriously enough until I just started typing this. What you have going for you is that you helped Rose, which anyone would have done lets be real. And that you're scumhunting. Which is subjective at best. Super Town Tracker Buffy thinks you're town so you have that going for you.

So the argument that Josh could be SK falls apart for me because too many other what-ifs would all have to be true. Josh could absolutely be a Mafia member. But he can be dealt with the next day. Or you can go ahead and deny me a win by lynching me the next day if you're still paranoid about my role. With SK gone, I think Town has a realistic chance of winning this and I can win with them.

##unlynch

Oh hi Josh. I should've waited for you to show up to my pressure vote before unlynching. :P