In fact, the key thing leading me to believe Merc now is he could have claimed the Ahoda kill, but instead claimed Maddie. So I'm actually starting to believe Merc is town.

I just wish we had kill flavor- it would make tracking some of this much easier. :(

Only one we can track down is Lamps from Ahoda given the "poisoning" then silencing, then death.

Ahoda has to be an SK (or some variant) kill. If Merc's kill was tampered with by Mafia they obv wouldn't redirect to themselves. And Lamps was definitely killed by Ahoda, I don't think the likely qualifier is needed. I'd say Maddie was either bussed with 317, or Merc was just redirected to 317. While Mafia used their standard kill on and janitored Dylan.

^^ This makes a whole lot of sense to me.

More claims or hints at claims. So...

2. Jamie - town per brian
4. Merc - vig?
5. Zersch
6. Vic
7. Rose - jokester
8. Spin
9. JJ
10. Maddie
11. Herm
13. farlig - silenced himself
17. Christian
18. Primate - foodie
21. TIB
24. Aras
25. Johnny Dollar
28. Angi
29. Lurchy - neighbor
30. Badger
31. Vlady - class clown

Feel free to help me fill this out for stuff I missed. Will update as we go.

I'm also cleared of one of the third party killers- I was RBed by Nofo N2 and so could not account for one of the attacks. So the argument that I'm an SK with BP goes out the door.

Yes, i could still be GF or cult leader. I'm not, but you only have my word to go on. But it does help narrow down possibilities some for townies who are scum hunting. Especially since I'm now leaning Merc as the townie attacker as well.

JJ's role is expert drummer. I'm assuming it's her and not someone else announcing her the last two days.

Also can't place them next to players, but it's worth noting on that list that there is the Ghostwriter role unaccounted for.

Someone mentioned either a night messenger or visitor role (or both) too.

farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:01

More claims or hints at claims. So... 2. Jamie - town per brian 4. Merc - vig? 5. Zersch 6. Vic 7. Rose - jokester 8. Spin 9. JJ - expert banger/drummer 10. Maddie 11. Herm 13. farlig - silenced himself 17. Christian 18. Primate - foodie 21. TIB 24. Aras 25. Johnny Dollar 28. Angi 29. Lurchy - neighbor 30. Badger 31. Vlady - class clown unacocunted for roles: ghost messenger night messenger/visitor (or both) Feel free to help me fill this out for stuff I missed. Will update as we go.

farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:01

More claims or hints at claims. So... 2. Jamie - town per brian 4. Merc - vig? 5. Zersch 6. Vic 7. Rose - jokester 8. Spin 9. JJ 10. Maddie 11. Herm 13. farlig - silenced himself 17. Christian 18. Primate - foodie 21. TIB 24. Aras 25. Johnny Dollar 28. Angi 29. Lurchy - neighbor 30. Badger 31. Vlady - class clown Feel free to help me fill this out for stuff I missed. Will update as we go.

rose claimed jokester? that seems awfully similar to what vlady is claiming?

Crazy theory time: Rose confirmed Lurchy as town through the neighbor stuff, Rose was RBed N1 when there was a missing kill, and Lurchy has been nearly non-existent except when he delayed the confirmation of them as neighbors. His explanation:

Quote

I'm here. Just got to the first couple mentions of me/Rose on like page 12. Trying to catch up. D1. I asked in what context was the question because I was trying to stall. I was also trying to catch up on 42 pages of mafia in FE and xx pages of mafia in FFA at the same time. I know, keep game in game, but any of the FFA guys will tell ya, I didn't even sign in over there until after I was killed in that game. Anyway, I just wanted to see what was revealed by Rose, exactly how, what the reaction was, etc, before I confirmed anything because obv I didn't want to blow a good thing. And yes, this is a pretty cool role(s) to have. I confirm, we are neighbors, neighbors with benefits. Rose is the power bottom though. Let's just be clear about that from the start!

What if Rose and Lurchy are a killing team?

jamie ♂ @ 6/3/2017 9:16

rose claimed jokester? that seems awfully similar to what vlady is claiming?

Rose claimed jokester and neighbor?

I don't remember this claim, but it is interesting, to say the least.

Farlig- Can you link this claim?

Corrected. Was still drinking my morning coffee :)

farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:13

farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:01 More claims or hints at claims. So... 2. Jamie - town per brian 4. Merc - vig? 5. Zersch 6. Vic 7. Rose - neighbor 8. Spin 9. JJ - expert banger/drummer 10. Maddie 11. Herm 13. farlig - silenced himself 17. Christian 18. Primate - foodie 21. TIB 24. Aras 25. Johnny Dollar 28. Angi 29. Lurchy - neighbor 30. Badger 31. Vlady - class clown unacocunted for roles: ghost messenger night messenger/visitor (or both) Feel free to help me fill this out for stuff I missed. Will update as we go.

vladykins @ 6/3/2017 9:17

Crazy theory time: Rose confirmed Lurchy as town through the neighbor stuff, Rose was RBed N1 when there was a missing kill, and Lurchy has been nearly non-existent except when he delayed the confirmation of them as neighbors. His explanation: Quote I'm here. Just got to the first couple mentions of me/Rose on like page 12. Trying to catch up. D1. I asked in what context was the question because I was trying to stall. I was also trying to catch up on 42 pages of mafia in FE and xx pages of mafia in FFA at the same time. I know, keep game in game, but any of the FFA guys will tell ya, I didn't even sign in over there until after I was killed in that game. Anyway, I just wanted to see what was revealed by Rose, exactly how, what the reaction was, etc, before I confirmed anything because obv I didn't want to blow a good thing. And yes, this is a pretty cool role(s) to have. I confirm, we are neighbors, neighbors with benefits. Rose is the power bottom though. Let's just be clear about that from the start! What if Rose and Lurchy are a killing team?

Knowing we've only killed one mafia and probably have at least one missing killer this theory has some legs.

farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:23

Corrected. Was still drinking my morning coffee :) farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:13 farlig @ 6/3/2017 9:01 More claims or hints at claims. So... 2. Jamie - town per brian 4. Merc - vig? 5. Zersch 6. Vic 7. Rose - neighbor 8. Spin 9. JJ - expert banger/drummer 10. Maddie 11. Herm 13. farlig - silenced himself 17. Christian 18. Primate - foodie 21. TIB 24. Aras 25. Johnny Dollar 28. Angi 29. Lurchy - neighbor 30. Badger 31. Vlady - class clown unacocunted for roles: ghost messenger night messenger/visitor (or both) Feel free to help me fill this out for stuff I missed. Will update as we go.

LOL- thanks.