Buffy @ 28/4/2016 22:03

Idk I kind of want to change back to Lamps just because it took him so long to say what he should have said much earlier, but I agree with Curtis's post that time will tell. That said, without a Lamps flip I don't know how it's so easy to lynch someone just because they wanted to lynch Lamps since there was good reason to lynch him.

It's not about ppl lynching me, but more about how they justified their vote imo (at least that's what my vote on Bryce is based on).

Okay not finished catching up completely but Lamps claimed JOAT.... the good thing about this claim is that it's provable through him using other abilities. But ehhh....

Why did he protect himself night 1? I barely remember Lamps sticking out at all yesterday, if I was JOAT I would NOT waste my doctor save on myself night 1, that's not a town thing to do at all. I would wait until I had a decent enough suspicion that somebody else with a power role was in danger. I just don't see a JOAT protecting themselves night 1 being a pro-town move

Buffy @ 28/4/2016 16:04

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 17:02 Buffy @ 28/4/2016 15:54 Herm @ 28/4/2016 16:16 ## lynch Mal I think he could be scum. I was thinking this but because of posts with lack of substance/impossible to read. :P I don't know how you can tell. He seems the same as always. That's what I meant - he was kinda trolly last game too from what I remember - I just didn't want to meta and talk about last game. :P

Oh, you meant from other games.

I meant ALL his posts.

:yay:

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 28/4/2016 16:07

Okay not finished catching up completely but Lamps claimed JOAT.... the good thing about this claim is that it's provable through him using other abilities. But ehhh.... Why did he protect himself night 1? I barely remember Lamps sticking out at all yesterday, if I was JOAT I would NOT waste my doctor save on myself night 1, that's not a town thing to do at all. I would wait until I had a decent enough suspicion that somebody else with a power role was in danger. I just don't see a JOAT protecting themselves night 1 being a pro-town move

What WOULD you have done with his JOAT role?

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 28/4/2016 22:07

Okay not finished catching up completely but Lamps claimed JOAT.... the good thing about this claim is that it's provable through him using other abilities. But ehhh.... Why did he protect himself night 1? I barely remember Lamps sticking out at all yesterday, if I was JOAT I would NOT waste my doctor save on myself night 1, that's not a town thing to do at all. I would wait until I had a decent enough suspicion that somebody else with a power role was in danger. I just don't see a JOAT protecting themselves night 1 being a pro-town move

I have been attacked/killed N1 before, and why would I wait and risk being killed right away making my other abilities go to waste? I didn't know who to block, I didn't have a single reason to use redirect, and well I did considder using watch but felt like I could be the target. Watch would have been shot in the dark. Please tell me how self-protect is not a town thing to do.

Lamps did you consider using anything else on anyone else or was it always gonna be the protection?

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 13:00

Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 20:12 Because in all scenarios we can see how people react, and even if you do get lynched still we can start to put together the pieces on who is scum or not. If you have a shit role then this is unlikely to help, but it's in the town's best interest to provide all info available so that we can make the most informed decisions. Angi @ 28/4/2016 20:22 I think Lamps is saying he has a good roll and he'll just get killed tonight if you all unlynch him so what's the sense? Ok you both have a point. I'm a dead fish in all scenarios so it doesn't necessarily help but also doesn't hurt any extra since votes seem to stay on me anyway. I am JOAT and protected myself last night because my other 3 abilities would go to waste in case I got killed. Do you guys want me to list my other abilities?

Because you're other 3 abilities would go to waste if you got killed N1?

They would go to waste if you got killed N2 and didn't use them N1?

Seriously retarded reasoning.

Mercator @ 28/4/2016 22:15

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 13:00 Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 20:12 Because in all scenarios we can see how people react, and even if you do get lynched still we can start to put together the pieces on who is scum or not. If you have a shit role then this is unlikely to help, but it's in the town's best interest to provide all info available so that we can make the most informed decisions. Angi @ 28/4/2016 20:22 I think Lamps is saying he has a good roll and he'll just get killed tonight if you all unlynch him so what's the sense? Ok you both have a point. I'm a dead fish in all scenarios so it doesn't necessarily help but also doesn't hurt any extra since votes seem to stay on me anyway. I am JOAT and protected myself last night because my other 3 abilities would go to waste in case I got killed. Do you guys want me to list my other abilities? Because you're other 3 abilities would go to waste if you got killed N1? They would go to waste if you got killed N2 and didn't use them N1? Seriously retarded reasoning.

Tell me how you would have used them N1.

Curtis @ 28/4/2016 22:15

Lamps did you consider using anything else on anyone else or was it always gonna be the protection?

No action or doc. Did consider watch too to get info.

The use of the word retarded is only revealing lack of intelligence of the user.

Herm @ 28/4/2016 16:16

## lynch Mal I think he could be scum.

Nah just distracted.

Buffy @ 28/4/2016 17:04

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 17:02 Buffy @ 28/4/2016 15:54 Herm @ 28/4/2016 16:16 ## lynch Mal I think he could be scum. I was thinking this but because of posts with lack of substance/impossible to read. :P I don't know how you can tell. He seems the same as always. That's what I meant - he was kinda trolly last game too from what I remember - I just didn't want to meta and talk about last game. :P

Hey I was involved last game. I woofed a lot but I was into it. Trying to get into this but it's mostly lamps talk and I'm shit at reads otherwise.

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 17:07

Buffy @ 28/4/2016 16:04 Dadd @ 28/4/2016 17:02 Buffy @ 28/4/2016 15:54 Herm @ 28/4/2016 16:16 ## lynch Mal I think he could be scum. I was thinking this but because of posts with lack of substance/impossible to read. :P I don't know how you can tell. He seems the same as always. That's what I meant - he was kinda trolly last game too from what I remember - I just didn't want to meta and talk about last game. :P Oh, you meant from other games. I meant ALL his posts. :yay:

I'm gonna be like you, dadd
You know I'm gonna be like you.

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 14:22

The use of the word retarded is only revealing lack of intelligence of the user.

I could use longer words, but then you would have to look them up.

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 17:22

The use of the word retarded is only revealing lack of intelligence of the user.

Don't be so hard on yourself lamps

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 14:15

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 28/4/2016 22:07 Okay not finished catching up completely but Lamps claimed JOAT.... the good thing about this claim is that it's provable through him using other abilities. But ehhh.... Why did he protect himself night 1? I barely remember Lamps sticking out at all yesterday, if I was JOAT I would NOT waste my doctor save on myself night 1, that's not a town thing to do at all. I would wait until I had a decent enough suspicion that somebody else with a power role was in danger. I just don't see a JOAT protecting themselves night 1 being a pro-town move I have been attacked/killed N1 before, and why would I wait and risk being killed right away making my other abilities go to waste? I didn't know who to block, I didn't have a single reason to use redirect, and well I did considder using watch but felt like I could be the target. Watch would have been shot in the dark. Please tell me how self-protect is not a town thing to do.

I was killed N1 last game, but if I got JOAT I wouldn't use that as a reason for protecting myself N1 this game. I was just wondering if you had legitimate reasoning for believing you would be a target, but it seems like it was just a gut instinct. A really luck gut instinct apparently.

I'm not lynching you just yet because it's a provable claim if you block/watch/redirect the right person, but in my opinion I don't see self-protecting night 1 without any demonstrable evidence that you'd be a target to be something pro-town. You had like a 1/15 chance of actually getting attacked, (there's like what, 30 people in this game? 2/30 translates to 1/15 roughly, I'm sure the number isn't exactly thirty so add or subtract as needed), and instead of taking that 1/15 chance and saving the healing power for whenever another pro-town got outed and was in danger, you used it on yourself. If you are actually JOAT, that's incredible intuition. But I'm just looking at it with suspicion is all.

Buffy @ 28/4/2016 15:47

Herm @ 28/4/2016 16:40 Buffy and Curtis, who are you lynching? Calm down I was just catching up! ##unlynch ##lynch Chris We don't need another award-winning HOF/HOL thread when we already have a great one.

There's never too much of a good thing