Vic @ 16/1/2016 16:20

No counter claim is making me slightly believe it more than not believe it, but I'm not sure how common Millers are anyway. I can't really remember them being used that often so it's hard to try and bank on a counterclaim with that type of role.

i wouldn't expect any counterclaims for miller. its either Herm is telling the truth or there isn't 1. the odds of a fake claim of miller and a real miller are astronomical imo.

It's a straightforward. Either they're town or they're not. Miko and Herm are not down based on my results.

I dont feel like dealing with this herm thing every day. This needs to be resolved asap.

im317 @ 16/1/2016 16:23

Vic @ 16/1/2016 16:20 No counter claim is making me slightly believe it more than not believe it, but I'm not sure how common Millers are anyway. I can't really remember them being used that often so it's hard to try and bank on a counterclaim with that type of role. i wouldn't expect any counterclaims for miller. its either Herm is telling the truth or there isn't 1. the odds of a fake claim of miller and a real miller are astronomical imo.

I agree but I don't think it's something to just rule out.

Feels like we are in the same boat as the Xmas game ... Crazy ass role is distracting to the point of needing to removal. Even though the majority believes the claim and that it isn't harmful to town

Miko (11/13) - Ahoda, Herm, Rob, Patrick, Primate, Schrauben, Curtis, Vic, Bryce, Wikey, JC, Chris, Free Candy, Dadd
Dadd (2/13) - Vernon, Ari
JC (1/13) - Timmah
Angi (1/13) - JC
Herm (1/13) - Patrick
Merc (0/13) - Bryce
Curtis (0/13) - Vernon

1 hour 31 minutes remain.

ahoda @ 16/1/2016 16:24

I dont feel like dealing with this herm thing every day. This needs to be resolved asap.

Agreed with this. It's going to end up being a huge distraction. But I don't really know how to resolve it. Mafia won't kill him if he is indeed town because of the distraction and uncertainty and he claims to have "immunity" to being killed. So the only solution is lynching and unfortunately we can't lynch him today.

So basically we're going to have to live through this whole thing tomorrow anyway.

im317 @ 16/1/2016 16:23

Vic @ 16/1/2016 16:20 No counter claim is making me slightly believe it more than not believe it, but I'm not sure how common Millers are anyway. I can't really remember them being used that often so it's hard to try and bank on a counterclaim with that type of role. i wouldn't expect any counterclaims for miller. its either Herm is telling the truth or there isn't 1. the odds of a fake claim of miller and a real miller are astronomical imo.

Why would the odds be so low? Miller isn't THAT uncommon (maybe in about a third of the games I'very played here?) and Miller is one of the only outs for someone who has been scanned as scum.

Christian @ 16/1/2016 19:42

This was Miko's original D1 post: Oh fuck you Ryan I was gonna lynch someone else but the fact that you eve considered lynching me puts you ob my shit list. I wasn't lurking, I was simply thinking 'fuk, dis is too long', so I kept it till today to read it all, mmkay. ##Lynch Ryan Your ded anyways. This was Miko's edited D1 post: Oh fuck you Ryan I was gonna lynch someone else but the fact that you even considered lynching me puts you on my shit list. I wasn't lurking, I was simply thinking 'fuk, dis is too long', so I kept it till today to read it all, mmkay? ##Lynch Ryan Your ded anyways. He fixed spelling and grammar, except he forgot to change "your" to "you're". lol I told him the next time he's ded.

Oh god, that's cringy as fuck. I think I was drunk that day. :-p

And I just got caught up, and would like to say, that this is only my second mafia game since I've been active in the ORG community (2011), so everything is really new to me, I don't even know half the sayings people are saying, and Christian had to legit instruct me with like everything. I bet he was sick of me by the end of D1.

But considering that I now see I'm in deeper shit than I thought I would be, I'm going to role-claim. I'm the Vigilante.

Who were your kill targets N1 and N2?

Oh god

Who'd you kill and why?

aaand now hes left?

Desperate attempt to try and get the real vig to counterclaim?

Okay then

Don't jump to conclusions Ari, I'm at work mmkay?

But anyways, I targeted Redster on N1 and Canuck on N2, because I felt like they were trying to blend in to much, to an extent that made me weary of them.