Very fun watch guys. Such a clash of titans. Good vs. Evil. 5/5 would watch again!

I didnt protect you Timmah

At that time I thought mafia believed there to be a backup doctor and he would definitively protect you, seeing as the backup doctor protected Bryce.

So I protected Bryce again thinking she would be attacked again :)

Christian @ 28/1/2016 11:35

I will say this in Badger's defense. His Night 3 kill was redirected, so he had no control over killing Primate. And he would have hit scum had he killed his intended target.

Ah, that definitely paints things in a better light!

Ari @ 28/1/2016 11:37

I didnt protect you Timmah At that time I thought mafia believed there to be a backup doctor and he would definitively protect you, seeing as the backup doctor protected Bryce. So I protected Bryce again thinking she would be attacked again :)

We had that discussion in the cult forum - I think Brian even called it the WIFOM game that you (we didn't know it was you at the time) were playing with the mafia. Your reasoning makes perfect sense, unfortunately the mafia came out on top in that one!

Ryan Grant @ 28/1/2016 11:28

Who gets LVP? Wait what Curtis Badger Titan (rob)

Curtis @ 28/1/2016 11:33

Ryan Grant @ 28/1/2016 11:28 Who gets LVP? Wait what Curtis Badger Titan (rob) lol how can you make the argument that I'm LVP. I WAS A HERO MAN! I had Herm and Vic pegged for some of their bullshit all day today and got the others to agree on at least Herm for now by fighting to prove my innocence. I lynched Angi because I absolutely had to to get her vote. Before this ending I nailed all scum every day. What a very selective memory you have!

Curtis was a very good townie, except the Ari lynch :P But, Singling out Badger and Curtis is dumb here. Look at ALL the mistakes town made in this game, even after the dumbass Wait/WUT and Titan/Robb crap. Badger's choices weren't great but he didn't singlehandedly lose this game JC! (ILU Tom!) I do wish he wouldn't have said he was upset about "something" because it clued people into the fact he was vig.

This was a collective loss, though.

Buffy @ 28/1/2016 11:22

Hello! Vic's actions D2 were SO scummy and I told you guys that lol! I think Timmah was the only one to really look at that but then it was just swept under the rug. That's all I want to say!!! ...besides wtf was that Ari lynch? :P

In my defense I wasn't here for D2 and haven't read it yet :yay:

Curtis @ 28/1/2016 10:33

Ryan Grant @ 28/1/2016 11:28 Who gets LVP? Wait what Curtis Badger Titan (rob) lol how can you make the argument that I'm LVP. I WAS A HERO MAN! I had Herm and Vic pegged for some of their bullshit all day today and got the others to agree on at least Herm for now by fighting to prove my innocence. I lynched Angi because I absolutely had to to get her vote. Before this ending I nailed all scum every day. What a very selective memory you have!

On the other hand, the lynch on Ari sealed the fate of the town. We HAD to lynch Herm that day, and you guys sped through it way too quickly. Up to that day, Town was still in control. After that, we were at the mercy of the roles we had left, and they didn't work out to take us to victory.

Timmah @ 28/1/2016 18:39

Ari @ 28/1/2016 11:37 I didnt protect you Timmah At that time I thought mafia believed there to be a backup doctor and he would definitively protect you, seeing as the backup doctor protected Bryce. So I protected Bryce again thinking she would be attacked again :) We had that discussion in the cult forum - I think Brian even called it the WIFOM game that you (we didn't know it was you at the time) were playing with the mafia. Your reasoning makes perfect sense, unfortunately the mafia came out on top in that one!

Sadly yes!

I'm surprised nobody pegged Vic as scum after im317 flipped really.

I dont get why I was lynched

Why would the mafia doctor protect the town tracker? He was literally the only person who could have had info on me killing people (if that was true). I would have used someone else if I was setting up that claim!

Herm and I were basically convinced Curtis was a traitor, that's one of the reasons we didn't kill him

Ari @ 28/1/2016 10:42

I dont get why I was lynched Why would the mafia doctor protect the town tracker? He was literally the only person who could have had info on me killing people (if that was true). I would have used someone else if I was setting up that claim!

You'll have to ask the TOWN HERO Curtis about that. I wasn't around to stop that train -- stupid work getting in the way of mafia.

Curtis @ 28/1/2016 11:40

Buffy @ 28/1/2016 11:22 Hello! Vic's actions D2 were SO scummy and I told you guys that lol! I think Timmah was the only one to really look at that but then it was just swept under the rug. That's all I want to say!!! ...besides wtf was that Ari lynch? :P In my defense I wasn't here for D2 and haven't read it yet :yay:

Well, Timmah pointed it out, I don't remember which day. I was waiting for SOMEONE to do it, lol!!!!!

Flashbacks to the awful Sons of Anarchy Mafia win (: . I hate when a team wins by utilizing a 'vote role' like that, those are always the worst way for things to end. The Mafia team there was blatant but they had a double vote and town didn't have the number of lynch votes needed. And here all three townies were gonna lynch Herm but couldn't. That's what this came down to really

JC @ 28/1/2016 11:44

Ari @ 28/1/2016 10:42 I dont get why I was lynched Why would the mafia doctor protect the town tracker? He was literally the only person who could have had info on me killing people (if that was true). I would have used someone else if I was setting up that claim! You'll have to ask the TOWN HERO Curtis about that. I wasn't around to stop that train -- stupid work getting in the way of mafia.

NOT MY FAULT! Ari and Vern were coming at me all day and weren't seeking alternatives and I was getting pissed knowing they were wrong. I cast one vote on Ari and before I knew it the others had speed lynched him