Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:16

Thisisbad @ 25/11/2018 16:10 I always feel like asking for role names and such is a cop out town read revoked :P

LOL well if your preferred method is to go around and ask for role names and tie them into their characters and such hey have at it.

I don't like it and i don't like mass claims and i'v always felt that way.

Zersch @ 25/11/2018 16:18

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 17:14 Herm @ 25/11/2018 16:14 I have always dreamed of including a Mafia Vigilante role, I just wanted to put it out there since we're on the subject. But that's an oxymoron. A vigilante is town by definition. Only by the standards of other games. Vigilante justice is criminal. Since the discussion is about eschewing typical role names and combos.

Carry on with your dream, Herm.

Thisisbad @ 25/11/2018 16:19

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:16 Thisisbad @ 25/11/2018 16:10 I always feel like asking for role names and such is a cop out town read revoked :P LOL well if your preferred method is to go around and ask for role names and tie them into their characters and such hey have at it. I don't like it and i don't like mass claims and i'v always felt that way.

I'm not doing the role/character thing. Just the role/action thing. I dislike early claiming (for no reason) but mass claiming does have a time and a place.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 16:18

Helios Garabandia @ 25/11/2018 16:16 Curtis @ 25/11/2018 16:04 Helios Garabandia @ 25/11/2018 16:01 Curtis @ 25/11/2018 15:51 I have no idea what to think of Brian’s claim and I’m not sure how much I should reveal here either. Part of me just wants to lynch him to see if he’s being truthful but that feels like a waste I dunno how he can be Town unless Shadow is making things...confusing (I’m not claiming mayor btw) Has Brian claimed anything other than the name of his role? He said he’s hard to kill and alluded to surviving lynches and night kills I know I shouldn't be reading into flavor, but "The Healer" plus this description PLUS X-Men knowledge is screaming "mutant cure", and that ain't Town... I don't know X-Men, which is probably why I'm one of the few who isn't reading into flavor/role names.. but isn't this an illegal post? I feel like it's hinting at a character.

Oh? I'm not intentionally trying to hint at a character, but rather, a story arc. If my post was an illegal post, hostie, I apologize.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:21

Thisisbad @ 25/11/2018 16:19 Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:16 Thisisbad @ 25/11/2018 16:10 I always feel like asking for role names and such is a cop out town read revoked :P LOL well if your preferred method is to go around and ask for role names and tie them into their characters and such hey have at it. I don't like it and i don't like mass claims and i'v always felt that way. I'm not doing the role/character thing. Just the role/action thing. I dislike early claiming (for no reason) but mass claiming does have a time and a place.

Disagree about mass claiming.

My role pm is awesome, and I want to thank shadow for it.

It's Day 3 so it's time for a LIST

Xmen:
Nav
JJ - seems like town Buffy. Also will probably die tonight so RIP.
Maddie - Town Maddie is usually easy to spot and this looks like her.
Merc - That post about Rose on D1 still makes him look very good to me.
Thisisbad - I don't think this is Mafia TIB. Pure gut read tho.
Spiderwoman - Another gut read. Her posts come across as genuine for the most part and if she's doing that as Mafia I'm very much impressed and fooled.
Primate - I tend to Townread Primate in most games and this is another one of those games I guess.


Muggles:
Zersch - His posting today makes me feel good about him but I'm not committing yet.
Shawn - What people have said about him makes me feel good about him more than his own posts.
Ahoda - Could be hiding behind the "shit townie" thing but I feel relatively ok with him for now.
Brian - I don't think Mafia brian would come out the way he did today. Then again I was wrong about im317 so meh.
Herm - I don't see scum Herm yet.
Lamps - Not TOO much from Lamps yet but so far it seems fine.
Christian - I don't think Christian looks that much better today. He unlynched me yesterday only when it seemed like im317 was dead in the water.
Jamie - Have said enough about him.
Cultis - I've had a scum vibe on Cultis since seeing Farlig and Sock flip dead on N1. The weird stuff with brian today gives me a little pause which is why he isn't the lower list.
Helios - I'm only putting Helios here because I don't think Helios and Joshie are mafia together and right now Joshie comes off worse to me. Could interchange the 2 tho.

Brotherhood:
Josh - Hasn't contributed enough and when he has it seems like filler posts.
Kat - Just a general vibe. Her posts don't read very townlike.
Mike - His unlynch of Rose on D1 and his random popin on D2 was very weird.
Timmah - Timmah is really good at appearing town when he's Mafia but something about him feels off. Also depending on his flip we would potentially get info about Cultis.

I could see a lynch on
Mike
Josh
Lamps
Shawn

very easily.

Christian is starting to feel more town. Esp after he drops this super long post.

Timmah i'm always wrong on.

I want to lynch spider

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 16:49

JJ - seems like town Buffy. Also will probably die tonight so RIP.

Thanks! Let's not kill me tonight, thanks.

Primate @ 25/11/2018 15:54

Farlig would tell me my list below is killer. Ahoda Christian Curtis Helios Jamie JJ Kat Lamps Maddie Mike Spider Timmah Zersch

What even is this list?

Also, Merc, where is your vote on invisi-Primate? or invisi-Brian?

##lynch spider

Ahoda @ 25/11/2018 17:02

##lynch spider

Are you scumhoda?

Cultis - I've had a scum vibe on Cultis since seeing Farlig and Sock flip dead on N1.

wut

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 17:03

Ahoda @ 25/11/2018 17:02 ##lynch spider Are you scumhoda?

Are you bufstanky?