BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 0:00

So Spin, let me get this straight. Your role is just to literally look for Arthur and your reward is that if you find him, you die if he dies? And there is no faction change involved?

I guess my reward is that I can protect him now? There was nothing in my role pm or messages from brian that would indicate faction changing, but after seeing the clifford show things, I guess it was a possibility.

Anyone else from my list wanna character claim?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 1:01

Anyone else from my list wanna character claim?

I've given the same hint on several days to my character.

Christian @ 8/3/2017 0:01

so then Spin, what do you make of mod-confirmed Townie backing up Zersch's claim?

No idea. All I know is what I've learned through my role.

My new tinfoil theory.

Herm IS Arthur (lines up with Ahoda). Arthur is maf (lines up with Jamie and Zersch). Spin found Herm and is now maf (lines up with Clifford), and will die when he dies (lines up with Spin)?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 0:00

So Spin, let me get this straight. Your role is just to literally look for Arthur and your reward is that if you find him, you die if he dies? And there is no faction change involved?

If your line here was question the action of my role, remember that Buffy could only play the drums. Why wouldn't someone be here to aimlessly search for a player, and then be able to protect them?

Christian @ 8/3/2017 1:02

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 1:01 Anyone else from my list wanna character claim? I've given the same hint on several days to my character.

I know nothing about any PBS shows, so hints wouldn't really help me. I'm sure others are the same way

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 0:04

My new tinfoil theory. Herm IS Arthur (lines up with Ahoda). Arthur is maf (lines up with Jamie and Zersch). Spin found Herm and is now maf (lines up with Clifford), and will die when he dies (lines up with Spin)?

I agree with part of this, but why would mafia have essentially "lovers" where they both die if one dies? Especially if that player (Herm) was the sole target of a 3rd player lyncher?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 1:04

My new tinfoil theory. Herm IS Arthur (lines up with Ahoda). Arthur is maf (lines up with Jamie and Zersch). Spin found Herm and is now maf (lines up with Clifford), and will die when he dies (lines up with Spin)?

I can get behind this. Spin wouldn't have a choice but to claim and try and save Herm. Would really hurt Mafia's numbers.

Vic @ 8/3/2017 1:04

Christian @ 8/3/2017 1:02 BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/3/2017 1:01 Anyone else from my list wanna character claim? I've given the same hint on several days to my character. I know nothing about any PBS shows, so hints wouldn't really help me. I'm sure others are the same way

I know. I will claim my character today. I just want to point out that I've left clues.

...if the fashionable Ashley checked out my outfit lol

so when Herm comes back, it's going to be Zerch and Jamie vs. Herm and Spin.

I know this is meta, but do any of you think I'd be this creative with a claim? You've played my games...my characters are nothing like this, lol.

Christian @ 8/3/2017 0:09

so when Herm comes back, it's going to be Zerch and Jamie vs. Herm and Spin.

Didn't someone claim they knew Aras was scum? Why isn't he a viable lynch candidate? I'd prefer not dying today, and you guys can continue getting more information and even check out Herm (or myself) again, to see if either of us is lying tonight.

spindoctor02 @ 7/3/2017 23:14

Christian @ 8/3/2017 0:09 so when Herm comes back, it's going to be Zerch and Jamie vs. Herm and Spin. Didn't someone claim they knew Aras was scum? Why isn't he a viable lynch candidate? I'd prefer not dying today, and you guys can continue getting more information and even check out Herm (or myself) again, to see if either of us is lying tonight.

Speaking as someone who has been suspicious of Aras the past two days and voted to lynch him D4, I think hearing that Herm was mafia from someone mod-confirmed town and also hearing that Herm was mod-confirmed scum to both Zersch and Jamie made it kind of difficult NOT to resist lynching Herm.