I know we can't always go with flavor, but I get the feeling there's things to read into with this game.

Night 1: Kidnapper (Brian), Dogs - failed (Redster)
Night 2: Kidnapper (Buffy), Axe death (Curtis), Dogs - failed (Redster)
Night 3: Axe death (Timmah), Dogs (Ari), Eaten (Canuck)

Without reading into flavor, it seems like Mafia attacked Redster Night 1, Curtis Night 2 and Timmah Night 3.

The only thing out of place is Canuck's death. Someone hungry for some canadian Thanksgiving?

P sure Herm is town too based on his posts. All over the place, but that's not the same as scummy imo lol. So not liking the lynch votes so far.

In terms of scum i'm thinking Boc, Primate, maybe Henry... Boc and Primate have been UTR, hard to get a read on. It seems like Boc jumped the easy train without good arguments (REEKS scum oh yes). Pushing hard for a redster lynch is not very convincing as an argument either.

Shadow @ 14/10/2015 7:30

I obviously pushed hard for Redster but I think pushing for Redster shouldn't necessarily clear anyone. He was bad but he wasn't mafia aligned. I doubt the mafia would have wanted the SK out so soon but it still doesn't really helo much in determining the other scum. I'm sure some jumped on the bandwagon

I don't think mafia realized he was the SK until the flip. I believed him until that claim lol.

Herm @ 14/10/2015 1:11

I know we can't always go with flavor, but I get the feeling there's things to read into with this game. Night 1: Kidnapper (Brian), Dogs - failed (Redster) Night 2: Kidnapper (Buffy), Axe death (Curtis), Dogs - failed (Redster) Night 3: Axe death (Timmah), Dogs (Ari), Eaten (Canuck) Without reading into flavor, it seems like Mafia attacked Redster Night 1, Curtis Night 2 and Timmah Night 3. The only thing out of place is Canuck's death. Someone hungry for some canadian Thanksgiving?

So you think the dogs and the mafia both attacked Redster night one? Could one of them have been blocked? We seem to be missing a kill from that first night

I'm not sure. I'm sure attacks on Nights 2 and 3 should come from a Vig so it's possible there's nothing to read into it. I'm just wondering why there's little variation in the attacks taking place at night, seems to be a pattern.

Herm @ 14/10/2015 8:14

Shadow @ 14/10/2015 7:30 I obviously pushed hard for Redster but I think pushing for Redster shouldn't necessarily clear anyone. He was bad but he wasn't mafia aligned. I doubt the mafia would have wanted the SK out so soon but it still doesn't really helo much in determining the other scum. I'm sure some jumped on the bandwagon I don't think mafia realized he was the SK until the flip. I believed him until that claim lol.

I bet they knew, like, GF was not an option and BP seemed unlikely based on Redster's denial. IF they thought Redster was BP though, then that would have been another reason to lynch him. That's about the best possible lynch target for scum.

Henry_42 @ 14/10/2015 7:11

beavereater or boc would be fine too....all scum!

Henry are you scum?

Herm @ 14/10/2015 6:27

Henry_42 @ 14/10/2015 7:11 beavereater or boc would be fine too....all scum! Henry are you scum?

commander in chief of the GET FUCKED gang is what I is...why so curious?!

Yesfo @ 14/10/2015 0:18

What's sad is I really trusted Redster until he couldn't get his story straight on his claim. I'm so fucking dumb. (:

Redster was so fucking shady right from his first survival lmfao That's why Boc voted for him without even reading the day ;)

I need a good reason to vote for Beaver. And so far, there isn't one. Wasn't one yesterday and not today.
And Boc didn't jump on any trains yesterday, he had no control over his vote.

Maybe the vig is the one with the dogs?

And doing a better job than the rest of us lol

Well, what laid the groundwork here so that's always good. I'd have a lot of hard work figuring out who's scum based on no intel and only what people say lol.

Herm

Henry are you scum?

Henry

commander in chief of the GET FUCKED gang is what I is...why so curious?

Is the GET FUCKED gang german for mafia team lol?

Shadow @ 14/10/2015 0:03

my ~rose colored glasses~ for lynching redster leaves me without a suspect. dr u scum?

Nah

Mafia, Town, Third Party

Day 1 Lynch Trains:

Brian (2/12) - JC, Curtis, Boc
Nofo (0/12) - Lamps, FC
Vern (8/12) - Curtis, Angi, Curtis, Badger, Rose, Wikey, Henry, Herm, Nofo
Gmaj (0/12) - FC
Herm (1/12) - Redster
Curtis (2/12) - Ari, Lamps, Brian
Wikey (3/12) - Shadow, Primate, Wikey, Canuck
Henry (0/12) - Nofo
JC (0/12) - Canuck
Badger (1/12) - Henry
Primate (2/12) - Buffy, FC

Not Voted - im317, Vern, Timmah, Gmaj7, Brian

Day 2 Lynch Trains:

Gmaj (4/11) - im317, Redster, Canuck, Boc
Lamps (3/11) - Wikey, Badger, Curtis
Redster (2/11) - Angi, FC, Buffy, Shadow
JC (1/11) - Angi, Redster
Badger (1/11) - Henry
Curtis (1/11) - JC
Ari (1/11) - Gmaj
Buffy (1/11) - ??

Not Voted - Timmah, Rose, Herm, Nofo, Ari, Lamps, Primate, Buffy

Day 3 Lynch Trains:

Redster (10/10) - Herm, ??, Shadow, Henry, Wikey, Timmah, im317, Angi, Primate, Nofo, Herm
Badger (2/10) - FC, Lamps, Timmah, Primate
Henry (0/10) - Herm

Not Voted - Rose, Ari, Redster, Canuck, Boc, Badger, JC

BadgerMcBeaver @ 13/10/2015 22:46

m identify the person who he role blocked this round because if that person was in fact role blocked, we would know for sure that he's town. And if he's unable to do so then it's a pretty clear indication he's mafia.

uhhh...the mafia RB is ded

Henry_42 @ 14/10/2015 0:02

hate to say I told you so, so...WELCOME TO MIAMI! so now who's next in line to GET FUCKED?!

i do not know what to think of you :-\

Daniel @ 14/10/2015 0:54

Someone explain how Badger is still a suspect plz? The theory was that he was the jailer, which he was not. So that leaves mafia. How is he mafia then, given his ability that prevents him from getting blocked?

it still does not explain why he is unblockable.

Looking at the Day 1 lynch train explicitly, Canuck was third on the Wikey train and Ari was first on the Curtis train. Since scum usually doesn't pile onto the same trains (inactive Vernon being the only exception here) I don't think that anyone else who piled onto the Curtis or Wikey trains were scum so that makes me think Lamps, Primate and Shadow has a low chance of being sided with the mafia.

I wouldn't rule out scumbuddies lynching their partners though, so Canuck single lynch vote on JC could've been a scumbuddy move. Notice how he jumped on the Wikey train as soon as it started gain strength. This also makes me think Wikey isn't mafia either.

Unlikely Mafia: Shadow, Primate, Lamps, Wikey

Moving onto Day 2, im317, Redster, Canuck and Boc all lynch Gmaj.

Boc was the tie breaker so it's hard to say, I'm not sure if he'd do that with Canuck already on that train. I don't think im317 is mafia either, there's no this train can be an all scum lynch train. I don't think the mafia would be that dumb.

Unlikely Mafia: Shadow, Primate, Lamps, Wikey, im317, Boc

Day 3 doesn't tell us much, but notice how both Ari and Canuck choose not to lynch anyone this time around. I'm not sure if it says anything but who knows. Free Candy also admitted to blocking Badger so I don't think scum would just out that out of the blue, they'd more likely keep quiet.

Unlikely Mafia: Shadow, Primate, Lamps, Wikey, im317, Boc, Free Candy

Alright, so who do we have left?

Angi
Badger
Rose
Henry
Herm
Nofo
JC

6 of them (myself included) jumped on the Vern train on Day 1.

JC is the only person who didn't jump on the Vernon train.

I'd say that there's at least one person on the Vernon train who jumped on the Vernon train, seems only logical.

My top two scums read rights now are Henry and JC. I'm gonna start by lynching JC since he isn't speaking.

## lynch JC

Oh yeah, Badger being more or less unblockable is kinda sketchy as well. Maybe it'd help to push a claim out of him soon to see if it's anything that makes sense. If he's town it's not like mafia's gonna target him since he's been a lynch candidate. I guess we'll have to hear more from him and his suspicions.