Really cool setup. At the start I thought it was a little scum skewed with 5 Mafia out of 18 and what ended up being an SK duo but Town had brian+Wikey in tandem where Wikey was BP Vig and then 317's caroler role, Lamps' daykils balanced it out well (in theory)

gmaj I'm so SO sorry for pushing so hard against you. I felt bad on multiple occasions seeing you saddened by people scum reading you but our pool of people to mislynch was very small so we had to keep doing it. You were amazing.

farlig @ 30/12/2019 10:11

So Josh got everyone but Jamie. Impressive.

We fear killed him because of his D2 list lol

Buffy @ 30/12/2019 13:13

Penner @ 30/12/2019 14:06 I told ya’ll Buffy and Nav were scum, but nope kill the SK that was town-leaning :/ Why'd you kill Herm, silly? He was 100% lynchable. Why go after Mafia at all at that point, actually? I mean in night kills, makes no sense as SK.

I thought Mafia had too many numbers and wanted to keep it balanced. Guess I was right!

Penner @ 30/12/2019 10:16

Buffy @ 30/12/2019 13:13 Penner @ 30/12/2019 14:06 I told ya’ll Buffy and Nav were scum, but nope kill the SK that was town-leaning :/ Why'd you kill Herm, silly? He was 100% lynchable. Why go after Mafia at all at that point, actually? I mean in night kills, makes no sense as SK. I thought Mafia had too many numbers and wanted to keep it balanced. Guess I was right!

You weren't right. Especially considering you guys had 2 people going into that night. Town siding that early meant Town could still afford to lynch the potential SK over Mafia especially considering Town had a Vig of their own (you didn't know at the time Town had a Vig but still)

If you take out another Town at that stage, the rest of the Town is forced to fixate on Mafia giving you 1-2 days of breathing room to kill more people at night.

Yeah, Gmaj, you were really good (besides character hinting lol) and it was really fun playing with you. You never gave up, I was pretty impressed!

was Wikey cookie blocked? or did he kill try to kill Nav?

Prince Navneeta @ 30/12/2019 13:17

Penner @ 30/12/2019 10:16 Buffy @ 30/12/2019 13:13 Penner @ 30/12/2019 14:06 I told ya’ll Buffy and Nav were scum, but nope kill the SK that was town-leaning :/ Why'd you kill Herm, silly? He was 100% lynchable. Why go after Mafia at all at that point, actually? I mean in night kills, makes no sense as SK. I thought Mafia had too many numbers and wanted to keep it balanced. Guess I was right! You weren't right. Especially considering you guys had 2 people going into that night. Town siding that early meant Town could still afford to lynch the potential SK over Mafia especially considering Town had a Vig of their own (you didn't know at the time Town had a Vig but still) If you take out another Town at that stage, the rest of the Town is forced to fixate on Mafia giving you 1-2 days of breathing room to kill more people at night.

Well I’ll take these lessons with me if/when I am ever SK again. Shoot as much town as possible, ASAP!

im317 @ 30/12/2019 14:19

was Wikey cookie blocked? or did he kill try to kill Nav?

I am guessing Christian gave him a cookie since he was giving them all to "town." But Wikey didn't have to eat it, I think he could pass it the next day, right, so he had to have taken a shot at Nav.

im317 @ 30/12/2019 10:19

was Wikey cookie blocked? or did he kill try to kill Nav?

He must have shot at me since you actually had to eat the cookie to be roleblocked. IDT it matters since once Christian died Wiley lost his BP.

Hey Penner. Did you ever find the hidden text to the gift exchange? (:

Fuck sake.

Well played Mafia. I made the stupid assumption that there could only be two of you left.

Nav/Jamie's fake mason claim was a great play. Risky as fuck but it paid off.

I made a few mistakes too. Shooting Havo was stupid, as was lynching Gmaj. Gotta say though, was there any other way yesterday could have gone? You guys could have forced the tie anyway.

And I swear we need to do something about the random.org algorithm, because it fucking loves making Nav Mafia.

wikeyb9m3bek @ 30/12/2019 14:42

Fuck sake. Well played Mafia. I made the stupid assumption that there could only be two of you left. Nav/Jamie's fake mason claim was a great play. Risky as fuck but it paid off. I made a few mistakes too. Shooting Havo was stupid, as was lynching Gmaj. Gotta say though, was there any other way yesterday could have gone? You guys could have forced the tie anyway.

I was kinda trying to be not very aggressive against Gmaj to make it seem like we were the two scum and not Nav/Jamie since we needed them both alive but Gmaj wouldn't get off my back lol.. and also Jamie really wanted to open his present. :P

So character hinting is even against the rules as a last resort. Got it. :D

Sorry I wasn't able to contribute more. I got so busy with a houseful of people and Christmas stuff that I wasn't a lot of help..