Christian @ 5/1/2019 19:59

Rodney @ 5/1/2019 19:58 I think the more info that's out the the more we can track what's going on which is pro town you mean by telling the mafia which Townies have roles and which are not threats? :P

I'd counter that more info means more potential lies to catch someone in which I see as more important than any given role but that that with a grain of salt as I've never played this before

is this actually your first game of Mafia?

It depends, like we weren't allowed to discuss, but do we think that scum was allowed to?

But yeah it may also give roles away etc. However, if scum was allowed to discuss then they probs got the better roles anyway.

A short summary of Nav's actions yesterday:

1-voted to lynch Cody early on
2-called out Helios, Rose, Rodney as scum before finalizing his scum list as JJ, Brian, Rodney and Rose
3-asked Buffy not to kill him

and then someone killed him.

Now why? To frame the Buffster? To get revenge for a previous lynch vote or a previous game? Because he called someone scum?

I'd have thought that anyone pushing the no-lynch thing yesterday was scum, but now seeing two of them flip Town, I've changed my opinion on that. :P

I liked where my vote was yesterday.

##lynch Helios

Considering there was literally nothing to go off of its pretty predictable scum would frame the people he sudo-randomly called out. Congrats it must be your first game too

If there's 4 scum, then 4 scum 8 town on day 2, that's rough.

Rodney @ 5/1/2019 20:10

Considering there was literally nothing to go off of its pretty predictable scum would frame the people he sudo-randomly called out. Congrats it must be your first game too

lol it's my first mini-mafia game. I'm not used to these smaller numbers.

Christian @ 5/1/2019 19:06

is this actually your first game of Mafia?

I think he's just the founding member of the 'Mass Claim D2" fan club.

Spin @ 5/1/2019 20:11

Christian @ 5/1/2019 19:06 is this actually your first game of Mafia? I think he's just the founding member of the 'Mass Claim D2" fan club.

I don't know what mafia acronyms mean :(

Lamps @ 5/1/2019 20:10

I liked where my vote was yesterday. ##lynch Helios

I don't think this is a bad place to start. I was thinking maybe Brian, but I'm over that.

Why are we lynching with no information? Weren't there actions last night?

I agreed with Spin about the Helios tradition of voting the third voter. It gives no information to look back on, no matter how Helios or the third voter eventually flip.

I only agreed with Helios' stance on the no-lynch yesterday.

Hopefully Rose will have more time for us today, and brings any leftover birthday cake.

Rodney @ 5/1/2019 20:15

Why are we lynching with no information? Weren't there actions last night?

it's possible that Lamps has information or it's possible he doesn't and is voting based on gut right now. Early day votes are not uncommon. And they can always be changed later.