Maybe that's what you want us to think Curt :)

Who do you think is the scum?

Ari @ 26/1/2016 17:33

Vic @ 27/1/2016 0:31 I've been trying to gauge whether or not Ari could just be a Mafia doctor Who protected Bryce then?

Yeah that's what I'm struggling with. I mean, you could've I guess. If you're the last Mafia member left and can't do the same person back to back nights

Idk anything is possible at this point. Someone is lying

This is gonna be tricky. At LEAST of the following is true:

Mafia Vernon: Dadd bussed the Patrick scan away from him and also stole his vote to make him look townish

Mafia Angi: Is either a hindered Mafia role or received a disadvantage from the supply group and is claiming it as her role

Mafia JC: Made a ballsy bullshit Town BP claim and got away with it

Mafia Vic: Jay said hey I'm not doing anything to help, throw me under the bus hardcore to make yourself look good and to save Wikey, so Vic did it and looks townish for it. Also would've made up the Hider claim

Mafia Herm: Truly is Mafia like he scanned and his Miller claim has been working like a charm. A lot of his team kept pushing for him to distance

Mafia Curtis: Lynched every scum buddy and put a good amount of heat on each of them to make them look shitty. Helped flipped trains against scum buddies

Mafia Ari: Fake claimed Faith Healer. Would've been responsible for saving Bryce, who the Mafia attacked. That one doesn't make sense to me unless Ari both killed and protected Bryce to set up a great claim

TRICKY!

Ari @ 26/1/2016 15:25

im thinking Curtis right about now.

Me too

## lynch curtis

Hey stop

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 0:39

This is gonna be tricky. At LEAST of the following is true: Mafia Vernon: Dadd bussed the Patrick scan away from him and also stole his vote to make him look townish Mafia Angi: Is either a hindered Mafia role or received a disadvantage from the supply group and is claiming it as her role Mafia JC: Made a ballsy bullshit Town BP claim and got away with it Mafia Vic: Jay said hey I'm not doing anything to help, throw me under the bus hardcore to make yourself look good and to save Wikey, so Vic did it and looks townish for it. Also would've made up the Hider claim Mafia Herm: Truly is Mafia like he scanned and his Miller claim has been working like a charm. A lot of his team kept pushing for him to distance Mafia Curtis: Lynched every scum buddy and put a good amount of heat on each of them to make them look shitty. Helped flipped trains against scum buddies Mafia Ari: Fake claimed Faith Healer. Would've been responsible for saving Bryce, who the Mafia attacked. That one doesn't make sense to me unless Ari both killed and protected Bryce to set up a great claim TRICKY!

If Vernon is mafia then thats some real great setup.
Angi has been cleared by Vic. Unless Vic is mafia with her as well.
JC has been cleared by Vic. Unless Vic is mafia with him as well.
Vic could have made the hider claim up, trying to get help from Angi/JC by clearing them.
Herm could def be mafia.
Curtis could def be mafia.
Ari is not mafia :)

Ari @ 26/1/2016 17:34

Maybe that's what you want us to think Curt :) Who do you think is the scum?

Maybe Ari :) . Would be very dumb of me if I was Mafia though, agreed??

MOST LIKELY
Vernon
Herm

Ari
Vic
Angi

JC
Curtis!
LEAST LIKELY

I literally keep switching this around in my head the more I think of it

Vernon can you explain your god awful Mafia lynch record? You've done a great job of never lynching or catching scum

Would be very risky. Wouldnt say dumb.

Ari @ 26/1/2016 17:52

Would be very risky. Wouldnt say dumb.

I would say VERY dumb and I would absolutely never do it!

We all know vanillas are purged at the end in situations like this. I would not put myself in that spot. I've been very pro-town all game I feel and I would be saying hey how about I ruin that right at the end and claim vanilla, not a bad idea!

Well maybe you are vanilla, just not town vanilla :)

But ya your record is pretty good and it is a bad end game mafia claim. If you were mafia, what would you claim? :)

Ha! Called Bryce as cult after he kept coming at me trying to get me lynched.

Could this really be as simple as Herm, who scanned scum, is scum? Do we think there is only 1 mafia left? If so, I say we risk it and just get rid of the one known. If we think there are multiple mafia left, we probably can't risk it.

Ari @ 26/1/2016 17:59

Well maybe you are vanilla, just not town vanilla :) But ya your record is pretty good and it is a bad end game mafia claim. If you were mafia, what would you claim? :)

Haven't had to think about it!

Maybe Hider, maybe Doctor that might not work ;)

4 mafia dead with 32 players? Could see there being 2 left tbh.

Going to sleep. Expect great discussions when I wake up!