Anyway, I actually ate lasagna for dinner yesterday. I take getting into character seriously.

Herm @ 12/9/2015 22:16

JC @ 13/9/2015 1:46 Herm, who did you hide behind last night? Well, I was gonna keep quiet about it and only tell you guys if this person was in danger of being lynched but I did successfully hide behind a new person so I know of another person who is town. As for yesterday, I was gonna write a reply and elaborate on my role as paraphrasingly as possible but when I clicked on reply all I saw was a closed Day 2 thread and im317 saying he was the vig. He does hide behind people, not only because he's a cat but he wants some nice and quiet every night. Also, Garfield do hide under his bed if there is an element of danger abroad like people wanting him to get up. You can't wake me if I'm hiding from you.

Why hide the identity of a potential town member? Wouldn't that make it easier to track down who is and isn't scum?

JC @ 13/9/2015 7:47

Herm @ 12/9/2015 22:16 JC @ 13/9/2015 1:46 Herm, who did you hide behind last night? Well, I was gonna keep quiet about it and only tell you guys if this person was in danger of being lynched but I did successfully hide behind a new person so I know of another person who is town. As for yesterday, I was gonna write a reply and elaborate on my role as paraphrasingly as possible but when I clicked on reply all I saw was a closed Day 2 thread and im317 saying he was the vig. He does hide behind people, not only because he's a cat but he wants some nice and quiet every night. Also, Garfield do hide under his bed if there is an element of danger abroad like people wanting him to get up. You can't wake me if I'm hiding from you. Why hide the identity of a potential town member? Wouldn't that make it easier to track down who is and isn't scum?

Would put a pretty big target on that player, who might have a good role. Vig and doctor are dead tho.

Would also be nice if people backed up their lynch votes with reasoning. This chaos isn't getting us anywhere

Ari @ 13/9/2015 6:38

JC @ 13/9/2015 7:47 Herm @ 12/9/2015 22:16 JC @ 13/9/2015 1:46 Herm, who did you hide behind last night? Well, I was gonna keep quiet about it and only tell you guys if this person was in danger of being lynched but I did successfully hide behind a new person so I know of another person who is town. As for yesterday, I was gonna write a reply and elaborate on my role as paraphrasingly as possible but when I clicked on reply all I saw was a closed Day 2 thread and im317 saying he was the vig. He does hide behind people, not only because he's a cat but he wants some nice and quiet every night. Also, Garfield do hide under his bed if there is an element of danger abroad like people wanting him to get up. You can't wake me if I'm hiding from you. Why hide the identity of a potential town member? Wouldn't that make it easier to track down who is and isn't scum? Would put a pretty big target on that player, who might have a good role. Vig and doctor are dead tho. Would also be nice if people backed up their lynch votes with reasoning. This chaos isn't getting us anywhere

I disagree. Scum already know for the most part who is town. Telling who he hid behind to clear them makes things a little easier for town and doesn't give away roles. If he dies that information goes with him. We may have lost some power roles but I am sure we have some left. Scum can go after the cleared if they want to gamble.

Well, we have lost Vigilante, Doctor and some sort of Jack of all Trades role so it really can't get much worse than this.

And we're only on Day 3.

JJ @ 13/9/2015 0:46

I missed Christian saying that. What page? Also, Schrauben, I don't see why Herm's claim is hard to buy? I mean, obviously he could be scum and lying but why in particular do you think so? I don't see his vote of Lamps as a big deal since he was just trying to make sure it didn't tie. Why be so obvious and switch like that if you're scum. I guess it goes back to Nofo? I'd lynch Nofo before Herm. I just didn't see him as scummy. And, Rose didn't either and she was town so that adds some cred for me.

Hider is a good role to claim to visit Poole if you get caught visiting. Especially as scum. And if he was trying to make sure it didn't tie the vote why did he even vote and then unvote Nofo after the lamps vote that put Nofo to within one of vespis and hen u voting to make sure it didn't tie. His whole play hasn't made sense, just like the push on Im317. I need to look at that train a little closer too.

Lol, who or what is Poole?

While I think the argument that I lynched Nofo to "save Vespis" and then unlynched him, leading to Vespis's death, has been beaten to death at this point lol, I don't think there's much more I can say to convince those who are suspicious of me that this doesn't mean that I'm scum lol, it just means that the whole thing was kinda stupid. I think this thing from Day 1 is being over-analyzed and it's gonna turn into a distraction. I'm not sure who in their right mind would pull something like that so close to the end for absolutely no reason.

Anyway, I do agree however that the events of Day 2 need to be analyzed, since Day 1 was not taken as seriously. My reasons for lynching im317 was that I found him the most suspicious, voiced suspicion of him, Angi and Christian throughout the Day. No one else really stood out to me.

Are we still talking about Day 1 shenanigans?

This is why town keeps losing...

Why the heck would Herm out another SAFE town role for mafia to kill??? Yes, Mafia knows who is town and who is scum, but they don't know if anyone has another killing role or whatnot, so why give them any more hints. Isnt' this why we don't mass claim within the first days of the game? So not to give Mafia any info they don't need??

Wikey @ 13/9/2015 14:12

Are we still talking about Day 1 shenanigans? This is why town keeps losing...

Town keeps losing cause people like you only make one post a day, don't even vote and therefore can't get any real read.

You want people to stop talking about day 1 then participate or do you already know who scum are and don't really have much to add? Blend in don't say anything until being called out?

##lynch wikey

Let's see if he'll participate and show us why we shouldn't be looking at any regarding day 1.

Angi @ 13/9/2015 14:15

Why the heck would Herm out another SAFE town role for mafia to kill??? Yes, Mafia knows who is town and who is scum, but they don't know if anyone has another killing role or whatnot, so why give them any more hints. Isnt' this why we don't mass claim within the first days of the game? So not to give Mafia any info they don't need??

Herm @ 13/9/2015 14:07

Lol, who or what is Poole?

Poole is evidently what my autocorrect change people to when I misspelled it.

That being said you didn't do yourself any favors being on the lynch of IM317 imp either as did JJ or Christian.

I find it odd that Dr was killed tbh. Would have thought she would be kept around given she led the train on the town vig, but whatever.

It's worth considering if the diversion to IM was to pull the vote away from either Curtis or Herm yesterday. If it was, then one of the following will very likely be scum:

Badger, JJ, Herm, Christian

The ones who followed Dr. Badger was the first to join the train. Scum would be more likely to join after somebody else had. Given that I buy Herm's claim for the moment, I'm looking at Christian or Buffy.

Hm...

##Lynch Buffy

Herm @ 13/9/2015 9:45

Well, we have lost Vigilante, Doctor and some sort of Jack of all Trades role so it really can't get much worse than this.

And you had a direct hand in the lynches of the doctor and vig.

Btw guys, elect me as next FE moderator.

I have a 'final solution' in mind for Ahoda's pals.