im317 @ 29/12/2013 20:33

Tom Brady @ 29/12/2013 20:18 I enjoyed the brief period where we fucked with everyone on day 3 since we had obviously lost at that point, and a lot of people didn't cotton on. I don't think we deserve HOF for all joining that lynch though. Mafia very often join obv trains. Sometimes it helps them blend in. We can be forgiven for not expecting town to have a superman role! But fheh, this is coming from the guy who hosted the worst mafia ever, so what do I know! it was not an OP role, mafia just voted super stupid. you had 2 choices to vote on, both town, yet you all voted, and all voted the same choice.

I disagree. That role is super OP. I voted exactly how I would've as town. Generally, people expect mafia not to join trains together and it would've never been expected that most on that vote were mafia. PS you're always grumpy. :p

Yeh it was a total underestimation of how powerful the role was on my part, I thought it would narrow the field slightly, but naw.

Also thought I put the Rob lynch in the HOF guess I didn't, cause that was hilarious as shit

Rob was my hero after his lynch.

Would've been fun to see this game play out without DD's role. The mafia had a really great start and virtually no heat on us. It was a shame it went down that way really

I think the mafia would've cruised to victory tbh

im317 @ 29/12/2013 20:33

Tom Brady @ 29/12/2013 20:18 I enjoyed the brief period where we fucked with everyone on day 3 since we had obviously lost at that point, and a lot of people didn't cotton on. I don't think we deserve HOF for all joining that lynch though. Mafia very often join obv trains. Sometimes it helps them blend in. We can be forgiven for not expecting town to have a superman role! But fheh, this is coming from the guy who hosted the worst mafia ever, so what do I know! it was not an OP role, mafia just voted super stupid. you had 2 choices to vote on, both town, yet you all voted, and all voted the same choice.

Just for the record, I didn't see if the Mafia board is open yet, but you'll see that I suggested splitting our votes 3-2....

Mafia had a perfect night 1, took out their only killing thread, avoiding everything relevant to their discovery, honestly thought they'd sweep it.

Buffy @ 29/12/2013 20:38

im317 @ 29/12/2013 20:33 Tom Brady @ 29/12/2013 20:18 I enjoyed the brief period where we fucked with everyone on day 3 since we had obviously lost at that point, and a lot of people didn't cotton on. I don't think we deserve HOF for all joining that lynch though. Mafia very often join obv trains. Sometimes it helps them blend in. We can be forgiven for not expecting town to have a superman role! But fheh, this is coming from the guy who hosted the worst mafia ever, so what do I know! it was not an OP role, mafia just voted super stupid. you had 2 choices to vote on, both town, yet you all voted, and all voted the same choice. I disagree. That role is super OP. I voted exactly how I would've as town. Generally, people expect mafia not to join trains together and it would've never been expected that most on that vote were mafia. PS you're always grumpy. :p

in and of itself im not sure it is more then borderline OP. it got combined with the challenge role which forced all the votes that were cast onto only 2 people, which removed the potential for the mafia to toss single votes on multiple other individuals.

toss in plurality making the 6 votes enough to lynch and it became OPed. if it had been majority that day then there would have been 12 votes and we would have had to sift thought 7 town to find all the mafia.

I still disagree wholeheartedly. Any role that can effectively end the game in one fell swoop is OP. Mafia just lucked out in using my role to kill Rob before he reached majority. Really though, that role had the potential to end the game right then and there, and THAT is OP.